Bank: 'worst' over in 2014 despite $4.2m loss

By NEIL HARTNELL

Tribune Business Editor

nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

Bank of the Bahamas International yesterday expressed confidence that “the worst” of its net losses and bad loan provisions will be behind it after 2014, following a quarter in which shareholders incurred a further $4.172 million in ‘red ink’.

Paul McWeeney told Tribune Business that the bank’s second quarter financial performance was “slightly better than what we had projected”, even though it took shareholder losses for the half-year to end-2013 to $7.348 million.

Pointing out that all commercial banks had, or were going through, what the BISX-listed institution is now enduring, Mr McWeeney said a spectacular economic turnaround was needed to make a major dent in the industry’s non-performing loan crisis.

He revealed to this newspaper that Bank of the Bahamas International had “materially reduced our presence” in commercial lending, which prior to the 2008-2009 recession was one of its key pillars.

And, with the bank seeking to reduce its reliance on loan-related income through achieving a 50/50 split with fee-based revenues by 2017, Mr McWeeney said it was continuing to focus on electronic banking as “the way of the future”.

Mr McWeeney was speaking after Bank of the Bahamas International unveiled results for the three months to end-December 2013, which showed that shareholders suffered a negative $4.843 million swing into the red ‘year-over-year’.

The second quarter loss took the half-year plunge ‘into the red’ to $7.348 million, an $8.48 million swing from the prior’s $1.5 million profit. Some 65 per cent of that $7.348 million loss, or $4.776 million, belongs to the Government as 65 per cent majority shareholder through the Treasury and National Insurance Board (NIB).

“The worst will definitely be this year,” Mr McWeeney told Tribune Business of the bank’s profitability hits. “No two ways about that.

“I’m confident the worst of it will be this year. I’m confident that it won’t last beyond the calendar year, but I’m hoping it will not go past June 30 [financial year-end]. So much of it is beyond our control.

“Every bank has done this at one time or another. This is our time. We had it good for 20 years and have to take care of this. We will.”

Bank of the Bahamas International’s top and bottom lines continue to be squeezed by the non-performing segment of its credit portfolio, and the latter’s recovery is directly linked to economic recovery and job/income creation.

Interest income for the 2014 financial year’s second quarter dropped by more than $5 million year-over-year, falling 30.9 per cent to $11.522 million compared to $16.665 million the previous year.

Mr McWeeney attributed this drop to borrowers defaulting on their loans, and failing to make the necessary interest payments. “A lot of that also involves loan restructuring,” he added.

“We have to augment the [borrower’s] rate to better suit cash flow. The loan book is not growing, and that affects the top line as well.”

Bank of the Bahamas International’s loan portfolio declined slightly in size during the first half of its 2014 financial year, falling from $735.089 million to $725.816 million

As for the bottom line, the BISX-listed institution’s loan loss provisions increased by 19 per cent in the second quarter, rising from $3.975 million in the same period the year before to $4.734 million this time around.

For the half-year to end-December 2013, Bank of the Bahamas International’s loan loss provisions increased year-over-year by more than $4 million, growing 71.4 per cent to hit $10.961 million compared to $6.393 million in 2012.

“We hear so many rumblings on the street about businesses having problems, and we can’t predict how long this thing is going to last,” Mr McWeeney told Tribune Business. “You have to adjust your internal strategies to account for the worst case scenario.

“We have a lot of money provisions, and we’re confident a lot of that will come back in. But that’s based on how quickly the economy turns around.”

Collectively, the commercial banking industry’s total loan arrears totalled $1.316 billion at end-February 2014, with non-performing credit - that 90 days and more past due - accounting for $971.4 million (73.8 per cent) of that figure.

Mr McWeeney said economic recovery had to be “fairly drastic” to make a major dent in these figures, adding that it had to be far greater than the 1-2 per cent GDP growth projected for the Bahamas.

“Otherwise it’s going to be a long run,”he said. “Your internal strategies have to advance faster than the speed the economy is recovering at.”

Mr McWeeney disclosed that the recession, and resulting non-performing loan crisis, had forced Bank of the Bahamas International to refocus its business model away from a historical staple - commercial and industrial loans.

Given the increased business delinquency and failure rates, Mr McWeeney explained: “We have materially reduced our presence in the commercial arena, which was one of the major lines of business several years ago.

“Back in November 2012, we decided to reduce that and place less emphasis on that line of business going forward. We have not focused on growing it.

“We’re not even looking at it right now. We’ve got a lot of inquiries from commercial customers at other banks, but we’re not even looking at that.”

The Central Bank’s economic report for February shows why the bank has adopted this policy, as delinquent commercial loans increased by 2.3 per cent that month to $360.6 million.

Mr McWeeney said Bank of the Bahamas International was instead focusing on “the automation of retail banking” as central to its plans to increase fee-based income to 50 per cent of revenues by 2017.

“We’ve made good progress on that,” he told Tribune Business. “We’re at that position now of getting the infrastructure and capacity in to get it done.

“We feel confident that electronic banking, the automation of retail banking is the way of the future.”

Comments

Reality_Check says...

Can't help but wonder whether PGC has sent all sitting parliamentarians who owe significant real property tax in arrears to Bank of The Bahamas (BOB) to obtain unsecured loans to pay off their arrears, which loans will eventually be written-off by BOB resulting in more erosion of BOB's capital thereby necessitating an additional capital injection from the people's National Insurance funds. Wow!

Posted 1 April 2014, 6:42 p.m. Suggest removal

JohnDoe says...

Wow, some of the most extraordinary commentary from the leader of a commercial bank that I have heard in ages. From what I understand a significant amount of the non-peforming commercial credit was originated after the global recession had began in 2008 and therefore, a first year economics student would have been able to accurately predict the likely outcome, yet apparently, no one at BOB saw this coming. Unbelievable! May I remind BOB that in 2013 Commonwealth Bank experienced their third best year in its over 50 year history in terms of profitability and they are operating in the same economy, business and market environment.

Posted 2 April 2014, 6 a.m. Suggest removal

John says...

OK lets be fair: RBC/FinCo went through 3 years of operating losses (First time ever for them to incur losses after operating in the Bahamas for over 100 years. Then they went through another two years plus of 'recovery' where the bank returned to profitability, but no dividends were paid to shareholders because management wanted to be sure that the economic storm was over.) While Commonwealth Bank did not experience any periods of losses, there were several years when there was a decline in net income and their share price dropped from $7.00 to its current $6.17 give or take. Many of the other commercial banks experienced losses and/or scaled back on their operations. While the problem at BoB may not be specific, some of their losses stem from setting up a branch in Florida, then having to close it down. One must look at other factors before casting judgement. Look at the number of stores and businesses that have closed in seven years. The company that was operating John. S. George was operating at one time almost THIRTY different business outlets. Less than TEN are now in operation. KFC has been operating since way back then has closed two of it's outlets in recent times and some that remain are still struggling to turn a profit. City Markets changed ownership/management several times and could not turn around. Now even under Super Value management the owner admits that all of the stores they took over from City Markets are yet to make a profit. Abaco Markets that operates Solomons and other franchises have their challenges and claim that in the third quarter of last year they experienced losses close to $1M. And with the road works more than half the businesses on parts of Robinson Road, Prince Charles and surrounding areas went belly up. Some are still closing because these roads have become highways and persons no longer want to stop and shop once they hit the highway. So many of these persons may have had loans or mortgages with BoB or with other banks. Some may have borrowed loans to pay of other loans. Then there are few signs that the recession is letting up, at least anytime soon. Many people are still in denial that the recession is real and some people have lost the shirts of their backs.

Posted 2 April 2014, 10:05 a.m. Suggest removal

John says...

So now you must question the wisdom of government getting aggressive on property tax collection at this time, when so many properties, residential and commercial are in foreclosure or unoccupied. Maybe there needs to be an extended period of amnesty where persons can make payments over a period of time and still get some relief on the arrears or time to get current. If you have a shopping center or commercial building or apartment complex that is sitting empty and you are already paying mortgage on it, it will be difficult to stay current on the taxes.

Posted 2 April 2014, 10:30 a.m. Suggest removal

GrassRoot says...

well it seems, the ones that have the money to pay the taxes tend not to pay them bcz they have friends in both camps, and the ones that cant afford, don't have the jobs to make enough money to pay the taxes. The property tax issue reflects the deep crisis the Bahamas is in both socially and economically. So yes pushing the enforcements in the real estate market (owed taxes and default mortgages) will blow the balance sheets of the local banks. The only way again is putting money into the homeowners pockets by means of income from work. That means, jobs.

Posted 2 April 2014, 12:52 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment