Deputy PM: Local firms could not match landfill deal

By RASHAD ROLLE

Tribune Staff Reporter

rrolle@tribunemedia.net

DEPUTY Prime Minister Philip “Brave” Davis said yesterday that Renew Bahamas was selected to remediate the New Providence Landfill after Bahamian-owned companies conceded that they could not match the deal the foreign-owned company made with the government. 

He subsequently dismissed concerns that choosing the company over a Bahamian-owned waste management company contradicts the government’s “Believe in Bahamians” mantra.

His statements came after concerns were raised over the “secretive” process that led the government to award Renew Bahamas with a contract to address long-standing issues at the city dump.

“What I know about that process is that there were a number of initiatives and proposals put to government to remediate the landfill but they wanted to remediate and then move from waste to energy,” Mr Davis said. “All the proposals contained a waste and energy end result.

“When this proposal (from Renew Bahamas) came to the government, which was devoid of the end result of energy, I’m advised that the Prime Minister met with a number of Bahamian interested parties or persons and spoke to them about what the government is intending to do. And I’m advised that they were satisfied that what the government intended to do was in fact something they could not match or they did not wish to.”

After the last general election, Renew Bahamas was formed and registered by Davis & Co, Mr Davis’ law firm. This led some to question whether a conflict of interest existed in the selection of the company.

Mr Davis yesterday dismissed the concern. “It came to my attention that the firm that I once was active in incorporated the company and I’m not aware that my firm acted for them in their quest to get the contract that they got. They were not a part of that.”

The Free National Movement (FNM), the Democratic National Alliance (DNA), private sector businessmen and representatives of Bahamian-owned waste management companies have raised concerns about the process that led the government to award the contract to Renew Bahamas.

Mr Davis dismissed those, saying, “I’ve not seen any concerns about the fact that a contract was awarded to Renew Bahamas without the job going up for public tendering.”

Last month, FNM Deputy Chairman Dr Duane Sands said: “You would think something of this magnitude, when you’re talking about waste management, would have had some type of public disclosure.”

Ginny McKinney, a principal in the waste management company Waste Not, also told The Tribune that her company invested over $500,000 in consultant fees for the drafting of its proposal, adding that the company was willing to adjust its proposal to accommodate the government’s demands.

A representative of another company, Dynamis Energy, also emailed The Tribune last month to express dissatisfaction about the process that led to Renew Bahamas’ selection.

“I am part of a company - Dynamis Energy– that bid on the ‘waste to energy’ (contract) to handle the city dump,” the representative from Dynamis Energy said. “We sat numerous times in (Mr) Davis’ office discussing this situation with him and he knew full well that he was going to take this over. The government did not even have the decency to write a letter to all of the companies that worked hard to submit bids on this project.  Another scandal and lack of transparency where our government is concerned.”

In addition, the chairman of the Bahamas Chamber of Commerce and Employers Confederation (BCCEC), Robert Myers, reportedly told The Nassau Guardian last month that the government’s contracting of Renew Bahamas to take over the landfill without a tendering process provided “another strong argument for a transparent process and the need for a Freedom of Information Act.”

Comments

proudloudandfnm says...

This is a pitiful lie....

Posted 3 July 2014, 11:30 a.m. Suggest removal

ThisIsOurs says...

Absolute STUPIDITY, FOOLISHNESS.whatever you want to call it. It makes no sense to hire a firm for pennies on the dollar and promises if they cannot do the work. All this talk of how sweet this deal was and for a month we've had a looming environmental health and fire hazard right in peoples back yards. Did anyone look to see what work this company had done before they were hastily incorporated by DAVIS & Co? Right after the PLP won the election? Further it seems that Waste Not is refuting the claim that they could not match services. There's no businessman in history that would allow a contractor to fester for one whole month without providing a service they promised, effectively allowing them to "catch up". The argument that they were waiting on govt to provide fuel is ludicrous.for government to agree to provide fuel for this company when they haven't paid their electricity bill for 9months in Freeport port is CRAZY. Btw has the govt paid its BEC bill?

Posted 3 July 2014, 11:45 a.m. Suggest removal

ThisIsOurs says...

Delaying work for the start of new construction is a little different than delaying work on a project that has to be tended to daily. I am nit angry because it was politically motivated, I am angry because incompetence and stupidity reigns supreme

Posted 4 July 2014, 1:59 p.m. Suggest removal

thomas says...

And they are "puzzled" by the criticism.

Posted 3 July 2014, 11:55 a.m. Suggest removal

HarryWyckoff says...

Davis sees no reason for concern simply because "this is how it is with the PLP" - their blatant corruption and continual lies really aren't your concern, so please stop putting this dishonest actions in the spotlight.

Posted 3 July 2014, 12:04 p.m. Suggest removal

GrassRoot says...

of course you can not match a deal that is not realistic. hello!!! the proof of any pudding lies in the eating. seems we are eating shXt now.

Posted 3 July 2014, 1:58 p.m. Suggest removal

GrassRoot says...

one group submitted a waste 2 energy proposal. did not even get a response, they probably forgot to send a check with the letter.

Posted 3 July 2014, 2 p.m. Suggest removal

JohnDoe says...

What does Renew Bahamas, BPC and Bluewater have in common. All three were granted significant government contracts, the negotiations for all three were shrouded in secrecy and all three were clients of the DPM law firm. Is that just a coincidence?

Posted 3 July 2014, 2:32 p.m. Suggest removal

realfreethinker says...

Good point. Where there is smoke there bound to be fire

Posted 3 July 2014, 3:18 p.m. Suggest removal

ThisIsOurs says...

You are 100% correct. The same kinds of things happened under the FNM. but something seems to be really really off with this one. When the DPM, not a party member, **the DPM** can say, if his ministers were paid more they wouldn't resort to (at minimum) ~unethical means to support themselves, something is **wrong** . There is an almost "gratuitous" display of cronyism and nepotism. They do it and almost dare someone to say something, they in fact they threaten those that do, "have to learn how the game is played or you won't last long In this business". They consistently telegraph that "they don't care where your money comes from or how you made it", give us some of it and you're in business, whether or not you can do what you promise, we really don't care. And for goodness sake don't overlook Fred Mitchell, I don't know who he believes himself to be on the world stage but he consistently shakes his fist at the US, quite unbecoming for a diplomat, a "mini Chavez". Well, he recently demanded a report from the US on the allegations of phone tapping, as a friend told me, he got his report, now *shoo fly*.

Yes this report could have been printed during the Ingraham administration as God knows things weren't perfect, you have to ask yourself why wasn't it? Is it because Ingraham was in their back pocket while PGC flies in their face? Who knows. But in an upside down nation where your chief diplomat is the most contentious man in the country, your Minister of Finance doesn't know underworld money flows can rock the foundation of a legitimate financial systems, your Minister of Labour doesn't have a clue how unemployment numbers are calculated and your Minister of Works says he knows nothing about how a hundred thousand dollar payment entered his Ministry and signs a landfill management contract with a hastily incorporated company that has the dump site overflowing within one month of them taking over. He then looks us in the eye and tells us what a good deal we struck....in that nation, maybe some outsider **with a big stick** needed to say something

Posted 4 July 2014, 8 a.m. Suggest removal

asiseeit says...

It is time for this nation to grow up. The childish back room deals are no longer acceptable. Ministers doing as they please is no longer acceptable. The Bahamas is no longer a little island nation with a bunch of fishing villages, we are a nation with cites, big business, major crime, and hundreds of thousands of citizens. We can no longer afford the party old boy network, lodge loving, corruption, and crony loving governments that we have endured for far to long. It is time to level the playing field so that this Nation can become what it can be, GREAT. You crooked ass politrickans have had yor day and have become very wealthy. We as a people now say NO MORE!

Posted 4 July 2014, 10:34 a.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment