Sunday, June 22, 2014
By NEIL HARTNELL
Tribune Business Editor
nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
A well-known retail entrepreneur has called for the minimum wage to be increased by 75 per cent to $7 per hour despite acknowledging that such a rise would “be challenging for me”.
Andrew Wilson, the Quality Business Centre (QBC) and Radioshack owner, told Tribune Business that such a rise was necessary for the lowest earners to have “a liveable wage”, acknowledging that it would be $1 per hour higher than the ‘minimum salary’ in his businesses.
And Mr Wilson, who is also the Democratic National Alliance’s (DNA) chairman, conceded that such a minimum wage increase would likely cause an “adjustment” in employment levels in his and other businesses it impacted.
Detailing a series of cost-saving measures he has taken to ensure his remaining retail businesses survive in an economy that remains depressed, Mr Wilson disclosed that total staff numbers across his formats have been cut from around 160 pre-recession to 30-plus today.
Backing the Government’s plan to increase the minimum wage from its current $4 per hour level, Mr Wilson told Tribune Business: “The minimum wage, as it exists now, at $150 per week, can pay for someone’s transport to work and lunch, but cannot sustain anyone.
“I do think it’s necessary for the minimum wage to be increased to a minimum of $7 per hour, so that our people can have a liveable wage.”
The proposed minimum wage increase has sparked mixed reaction in the private sector. Rupert Roberts, Super Value’s owner, said he would be in favour of raising the weekly rate by 33 per cent to $200, and would adjust salaries at the lower end of the supermarket chain’s pay scale accordingly.
Others, such as Phil Lightbourne at Phil’s Food Services, have also backed a minimum wage increase. However, Robert Myers, the Bahamas Chamber of Commerce and Employers Confederation’s (BCCEC) chairman, expressed concern that such a rise would spark pressure for similar salary increases throughout the economy - especially in union-dominated sectors.
Emphasising that the BCCEC’s concern was the economic context/background against which a minimum wage increase would occur, Mr Myers also called for such a move to be backed by empirical data and studies.
A minimum wage increase would effectively raise the marginal costs of employing/hiring workers in sectors such as hotels and restaurants (where many staff are gratuity-reliant), construction, retail and gas stations. As a result, to compensate many such businesses might reduce their workforces to avoid the increased costs.
Mr Wilson conceded as much, telling Tribune Business of his proposal: “I know that’s [$7 per hour] going to be challenging for me. I know that adjustment would have to be made. Maybe whereas I have nine workers now, I might have to make do with seven to eight.
“I have, for many years, had a minimum wage in my businesses of $6 per hour. I think $7 per hour is what is needed.”
Suggesting that an increased minimum wage might also help boost consumer spending, he added: ‘When you consider that over 70 per cent of the local economy is consumer driven, how is the economy going to survive off $4 per hour.
“There are so many components to the cost of living that are not adjustable. I cannot adjust the cost of coming to work, I cannot adjust the cost of bread.”
The DNA chairman implied that a minimum wage increase was also essential given the likely reduced living standards set to result from the imposition of a 7.5 per cent Value-Added Tax (VAT).
“Quite honestly, conceptually, VAT and devaluation of the Bahamian dollar are one and the same,” he said, “in that out of $100, it now becomes $92.50 after VAT.”
Mr Wilson, who took over John S George when it was likely beyond saving, and with the world on the brink of recession, explained how he now manages to keep QBC, Radioshack and his fashion retail formats in business.
“We have moved to a position where we turn on the A/C two hours or one hour after opening, and shut if off an hour before closing,” he told Tribune Business. “We have structured our hours so that we can operate a single shift instead of a shift-and-a-half or two different shifts.
“We are staggering hours. In quite a few weeks, we have a person working 32 hours instead of 40 hours. We’ve made the hard decisions. We’ve adjusted. We’ve adjusted to survive.”
Mr Wilson added: “At one time I had 160 employees, and today I suspect I have about 30-plus. There comes a time when you have to choose: Is it to be 160-170, or zero?
“I’m still in business. I still have quite a few retail stores and other businesses, but it’s not as it was pre-recession.”
The QBC entrepreneur added that with ever-increasing tax and other cost pressures set to be imposed on the private sector in the short-term, many business owners were either seeking an exit route or eyeing a move into the informal economy.
“I can say for a fact that most businesses in this country are struggling and making the necessary adjustment to ensure their necessary survival,” Mr Wilson said. “I speak to many people who say it’s not worth the bother, and they’re calling it a day.
“I expect a large number of entrepreneurs to move into the informal economy and under the radar, as they see that as the way to survive.”
And he further told Tribune Business: “I suspect a lot of business persons, certainly those in my age category, most certainly will be questioning the viability of staying active in the long-term.
“Business has been challenging in the best of times, although we were able to make a profit. But, in the aftermath of the recession, there’s been a major adjustment to the business landscape.
“It calls one to question the feasibility of continuing, especially in the absence of light at the end of the tunnel. Recovery soon is wishful thinking. We have to assume it’s going to be a couple of years before we see, or hope to see, any type of turnaround in this situation.”
Comments
John says...
This man has to be seriously off his rocker. He managed a chain of stores of which 80% are now closed and out of business and now he is suggesting to raise the minimum wage by 75%. What he seems to forget is that when you raise the wage at the bottom, everything above it has to rise also, and I challenge Mr. Wilson to name one business that can afford a 75% across the board increase in salaries at any one time. Not to stop there but National Insurances on workers pay will also increase along with other employer contributing benefits. Minimum wage was not intended to be an amount that persons could sustain a living. Rather it was a reasonable amount where persons could enter the work force, get some experience or tenure and move up to higher paying wages. We must not forget that many persons entering the job market are not properly equipped and has to be trained and re-trained at the employers expense. Also most persons entering the job market still live at home with parents or family and if they are still earning minimum wage after 6-8 months in the work force it has to be a problem of their own. To put the minimum wage beyond the reach of many employers will create a greater hardship on persons trying to get a job than it will help.
Posted 23 June 2014, 4:25 p.m. Suggest removal
John says...
Then Mr. Wilson must also not forget the small mom and pop shops where the owner is not making $7.00 an hour. They survive, not on profit, but paying themselves minimal wages. Call it gainful occupation. And they have to put in long and extended hours to do so and cannot afford to reduce their operations to a single shift like he claims he is doing to keep his doors open.
Posted 23 June 2014, 4:33 p.m. Suggest removal
Mayaguana34 says...
Mr. Wilson is nuts!! He has clearly given up on whats left of his businesses and been reduced to just another politician. Saying anything that sounds good - without thought and careful consideration
Posted 24 June 2014, 1:55 p.m. Suggest removal
TheMadHatter says...
Raise minimum wage? He mussy really want dem Haitian boat to be full-up now !!!
**TheMadHatter**
Posted 24 June 2014, 10:36 p.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment