Friday, October 17, 2014
By RASHAD ROLLE
Tribune Staff Reporter
rrolle@tribunemedia.net
JUNKANOO costs the country more than $18 million per year, $10m of which is unwaged labour and personal contributions, according to a new College of the Bahamas study.
Conducted by cultural anthropologist Dr Nicolette Bethel with the help of COB students, the study highlights the untapped economic potential of the festival, noting that the costs of hosting it far outweigh the revenue it generates, with ticket sales for the parades averaging below $1 million annually.
Confirming years of established conjecture, the study indicates that the festival diverges from similar major festivals in the region in its failure to produce a high return on investments.
It also conservatively estimates that it costs Junkanoo practitioners at least $3,400 in labour and $1,000 in materials per person each season to participate in the two major Junkanoo festivals.
The paper, “The Economic Impact of Junkanoo in the Bahamas,” is featured in the latest edition of the International Journal of Bahamian Studies.
In it, Dr Bethel writes: “While recent survey data indicates that Bahamians consider Junkanoo to be very important or essential to Bahamian national identity, the festival still struggles to attract the kind of investment that will generate the kinds of returns seen in festivals elsewhere.”
The study reveals the parades have weak links to tourism, with relatively few tourists aware of its existence.
Dr Bethel writes: “Ministry of Tourism officials believe that there is no need to promote Junkanoo to tourists, as during the Christmas season hotels are full.
“A study of 197 tourists in 2010 indicated that although 35 per cent of tourists had heard of Junkanoo, only nine per cent of them had attended the parades.”
Nonetheless, the study notes that Junkanoo makes considerable contributions to the wider economy by generating employment and creating linkages among otherwise unrelated industries.
While Junkanoo provides little financial gain to its practitioners, Dr Bethel, during a presentation on the paper at COB yesterday, noted that for many, participating in the festival remains a very fulfilling experience.
“There are very few things in our societies that are self-reifying activities - Junkanoo is that one thing that exists as this for people who take part in it,” she said. “It affirms their identity, their right to be in the world. The happiness factor is very high. I know that I’ve talked to people who’ve said that we had to make a decision between replacing a washer or dryer, and doing our Junkanoo costume.”
The findings presented in Dr Bethel’s paper comprises results from 13 studies conducted between 2009 and 2013. A combination of quantitative and qualitative methods were used.
Comments
Andrewharris says...
If we would just allow Junkanoo to evolve rather than try to stifel it's growth and evolution (because we are afraid it will cease to be Bahamian) it has the potential to generate millions.
Posted 18 October 2014, 6:58 a.m. Suggest removal
PKMShack says...
Junkanoo can evolve, the same money and promotion that is being pushed to carnival, is the same that can be pushed for Junkanoo. You have to ask the masterminds behind this carnival movement why they chose to use carnival instead of Junkanoo. They apparently like people tings better than their own
Posted 18 October 2014, 8:48 a.m. Suggest removal
John says...
JUNKANOO: after all the years it still holds mystery. Two problems basically. Because the preparation and production of Junkanoo has not been allowed to enter the 21 sat century, it still remains very labor intensive and still very costly. Spending $18 million on parades that lasts only a few hours is insane. Modern methods can be incorporated to reduce the man hours put into Junkanoo and hence the cost. Secondly, at one time there used to be large numbers of tourists at the parades. Today the tourist numbers are scarce, to say the least. is this either because tourists do not want to pay to attend the event, or because of the crime element and violence at the parades they have been advised to stay away from the event. Persons may argue that you cannot put a price on culture but at least you can make the parades more effective, by increasing the number of paying spectators attending the event and/or reducing the cost of production.
Posted 18 October 2014, 9:16 a.m. Suggest removal
thomas says...
I would like to know how she came up with a dollar amount for the time spent in preparing for junkanoo when it for the most part is done out of a love for the parade and the competition.
Posted 18 October 2014, 1:28 p.m. Suggest removal
ThisIsOurs says...
Just take a random sample and ask people *can I see your costume, how long did it take you to complete*...just guessing. Most people can tell how long it took them to complete last year some can tell you "shack" stories for a couple years
Posted 18 October 2014, 9:22 p.m. Suggest removal
TalRussell says...
Comrades not only is this report a sad reflection on the ministry of tourism but don't be thinking that $18 million is much contributed to, if anything much, by whomever happens be the government of the day. Typical bureaucrats, create something new in the millions while ignoring what we all know is well received and enjoyed by locals and visitors alike. Who knows may be more difficult pay under and over tables monies with Junkanoo - gives damn good excuse for spending millions creating just another inefficient level government bureaucracy. I guess it's only after the People's Public Treasure checks start bouncing will the bull sh@% cease. And, that ain't far around da corner.
Posted 18 October 2014, 2:43 p.m. Suggest removal
duppyVAT says...
Junkanoo reflects every other aspect of our country. We fly to South Florida to support American sports and lotteries; we buy Jordan shoes and Lebron jerseys.We go to Mardi Gras, Carnival and Rio for Olympics. BUT GIVE NO SUPPORT TO OUR LOCAL SPORTS AND CULTURE. ........... and VAT and Gambling cant solve that. Its a mindset. In the meantime, we think only of having a good time while private sector and civil service suffer for non-productivity.
Posted 18 October 2014, 4:33 p.m. Suggest removal
EnoughIsEnough says...
you are absolutely correct. i see so few of my peer group there.
i support junkanoo every year and am always disappointed by the lack of tourists that i see there. one reason could be, however, because all of the tickets are purchased by the time they arrive on island and actually hear about it (due to our govt's/tourism lack of global promotion of the event). so really, the only tourists i see are in the sunrise hours when bahamians have vacated their seats. and think about the reverse - if we heavily promoted it and tourists were buying up tickets far in advance, then bahamians would be left to stand on shirley street and there would be an outcry that junkanoo was only for tourists! i think it's a no-win situation. and who wants to stand on shirley street with all the rock and knife fights that occur every half hour. not I! done it, won't do it again.
Posted 19 October 2014, 1:56 p.m. Suggest removal
duppyVAT says...
When a person spends $1,000 on materials and takes 2 weeks to build an off the shoulder piece to parade on Bay Street............. what is its monetary value ???????????
Posted 18 October 2014, 5:57 p.m. Suggest removal
ThisIsOurs says...
I say it's priceless, can you imagine a Christmas with no Junkanoo?
Posted 18 October 2014, 9:24 p.m. Suggest removal
The_Oracle says...
Junkanoo is not what it used to be, however instead of a natural progression we have destroyed it politically, culturally, and one could fall asleep with the gaps in the music/beat.
It used to be continuous non stop, akin to being possessed for hours.
Add to the above the dangerous element, nasty rank smell,
It isn't something you could seriously present to tourists as Festive and happy.
So instead we will attempt to Create a "cultural event" from scratch.
Good luck with that.
More money train for the bleacher and fencing connections.
Posted 19 October 2014, 1:08 p.m. Suggest removal
TalRussell says...
Oh yeah Comrade we create something new and wait for stench set-in? What if we cleanup what we have and enjoy, before dropping it move on?
Posted 19 October 2014, 1:14 p.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment