100 MW outsource ‘fastest way out’ of BEC energy crisis

By NEIL HARTNELL

Tribune Business Editor

nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

Inviting bids to provide 100 Mega Watts (MW) of extra power to the Bahamas Electricity Corporation (BEC) was yesterday proposed as “the fastest way out” of this nation’s energy crisis, which a former chairman said is now “past the 11th hour”.

Michael Moss, who headed the Corporation under the Ingraham administration, told Tribune Business that awarding such a supply contract would give the Government much-needed breathing space to complete BEC’s restructuring.

He recommended that the contract to supply BEC with 100 MW of power be awarded to the bidder able to install such generation capacity at the lowest cost, and in the shortest possible timeframe.

While acknowledging that such an arrangement could impact BEC’s attractions in any privatisation/outsourcing process, Mr Moss said the energy sector needed to follow its communications counterpart and be opened up to generation competition.

Despite BEC’s ever-deepening problems, the latest being a generation capacity shortfall likely to result in week-long load shedding, the Government has still to announce a management/operating partner for the Corporation.

Well-placed Tribune Business sources, speaking on condition of anonymity, said Prime Minister Perry Christie was last week scheduled to have a conference call with the US commerce secretary, Penny Pritzker, in a bid to move the BEC process forward.

This newspaper was told Mr Christie is seeking additional guarantees from the Obama administration regarding the integrity of Power Secure, the company that the Government favours as BEC’s management partner.

Power Secure is currently facing two class action lawsuits in the US over securities fraud allegations, and the Prime Minister is keen to ensure his selection is seen as beyond reproach.

The issue of further guarantees is understood to have been raised at the early April Jamaica summit that was attended by President Barack Obama.

However, given that the Government already possesses Power Secure-related certifications from other senior US government personnel, especially secretary of state John Kerry, the need for more seems questionable.

Mr Moss yesterday told Tribune Business it was “critical” that the BEC restructuring process be completed, given the worsening situation at the monopoly energy provider.

“To me, it’s past the 11th hour,” he said. “BEC is in a critical stage of load shedding with Baha Mar coming on stream.

“To me, perhaps, the fastest way out of this problem would be for the Government to invite bids for the installation of 100 MW of power that would be sold to BEC.”

Mr Moss said that the installation of such generation capacity would “take at a minimum 12 months if you’re lucky”, and likely closer to 18 months.

He suggested that the winning bidder be the one offering the lowest power costs in the shortest possible time, adding that such a move would give the Government more time to determine how BEC should be reformed.

“While the Government muddles through the privatisation process, it can begin privatisation without having to touch BEC,” Mr Moss said.

And both itself and BEC would have access to increased generation capacity without having to finance it.

The former executive chairman, though, acknowledged that his suggested solution might “erode the value in BEC” unless the 100 MW contract winner and the Corporation’s ultimate private sector partner were the same entity.

If the two were different, Mr Moss said BEC might be locked into a power supply contract with an entity its new manager did not like.

He likened this to “having a monkey on your back that you are not able to get rid of”, but added that such an outcome was “not too bad” in the context of the Government’s wider energy sector goals.

“What happened in the communications sector needs to take place in the power generation sector,” Mr Moss told Tribune Business. “There ultimately needs to be competition in the generation sector.”

He added that it was impossible to accurately assess BEC’s financial position, given that its financial statements had not been tabled in Parliament - as required by law - for almost five years.

The last financials posted on BEC’s website are for the year to end-September 2010. Mr Moss, when he stepped down in May 2012, had returned the Corporation to a more solid financial footing, the effects of hurricane repairs preventing it from building on the $1,000 profit achieved in 2010 under his watch.

Since then, Mr Moss’s successor as executive chairman, Leslie Miller, has repeatedly warned that BEC has incurred annual losses in the $20-$30 million range.

Mr Moss yesterday implied that it was ironic that BEC was now having to hire 40 MW of temporary rental generation capacity, given that he had been heavily criticised for doing the same by the-then Opposition Progressive Liberal Party (PLP).

“When I had to take the step of having to bring in 40 MW of temporary generation while we dealt with the backlog of outstanding maintenance, I was heavily criticised by the Opposition party,” Mr Moss told Tribune Business.

“I smile because their failure to carry on with the plans I left in my stead means they are having to bring in 40 MW of temporary generation, and the chairman said that may not be enough.”

Mr Moss said that while the 24 MW gas turbine contracted for under his watch had been commissioned, there was a 30 MW generation shortfall as a result of the current administration failing to follow through on what else his Board left in place.

These included a Heat Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG), which captures the exhaust gases from gas turbines and converts them to steam. The HRSG would have combined with a steam turbine generator to produce 12 MW, and plans were also made to add an 18 MW slow speed diesel generator at Clifton Pier.

Mr Moss yesterday said BEC was likely to be “stuck” with its latest temporary generators for 12 months.

Yet he added that the extra 60 MW produced by these units, and the gas turbine he contracted for, meant BEC should be able to meet Baha Mar’s power needs provided the Clifton Pier and Blue Hills plants were fully operational and properly maintained.

Comments

SP says...

**................................................ Absolute Waste Of Time ...................................................**

NO ONE is interested in wasting anymore time and money phucking around with government and BEC.

Several groups invested serious $$ on study's resulting in offering these idiots concrete multifaceted solutions to resolve BEC woes mitigating 40+ years of corruption and political stupidity 18 Months ago.

What power company with a monopoly on power production in ANY COUNTRY ever went bankrupt? ......HOW IS THAT REMOTELY POSSIBLE?

Bahamas is reaping 40+ years of political stupidity and corruption period.

Simple truth is PLP & FNM FAILED with BEC.

Posted 28 April 2015, 6:06 p.m. Suggest removal

HarryWyckoff says...

Agreed. The time for clinging on to personal wealth at the expense of the entire fucking country is over.

These imbeciles need to remember that this is not a dictatorship, this is not communist country, and the do not own the rights to the people they pretend to represent.

Step off the block, you moronic fools. You have utterly failed this country. Admit it and walk away with the tiniest bit of dignity.

Or go down in history as the parties that destroyed this nation through personal greed.

You are all, PLP and FNM, disgusting, money grubbing traitors.

Posted 28 April 2015, 7:46 p.m. Suggest removal

The_Oracle says...

Which is also why the Government cannot allow unfettered private sector Alternate energy:
Those with the money to invest in it,
are the ones who pay their damn power bills!
Who in their right mind would buy a utility with no income left?
SP is right, the bill is due on 40 years of incompetence!

Posted 28 April 2015, 8:52 p.m. Suggest removal

SP says...

I personally know of a group of experienced renewable energy solution providers in 2012 that offered this government 20,000 solar net metering systems at cost and relevant training for the 2000 jobs that would have been created for Bahamian installation and maintenance technicians.......Government turned them down without explanation!

20,000 solar net metering systems would have immediately enabled people with lights off to have power, relieve pressure on rapidly failing BEC while simultaneously adding excess produced power to the grid for other consumers consumption.

BEC and Bahamians would not be in these dire straights today if government had half an ounce of sense.

Jamaica rapidly developed a net billing solar system, created 1000's of jobs for their people, while our dumb jackass government sit back waiting to see who they can swing the hardest
at the expense of the Bahamian people.

http://www.myjpsco.com/net-billing/

Posted 29 April 2015, 9:55 a.m. Suggest removal

GrassRoot says...

well there were many in that business SP. However since this government wants to get paid before they talk to you, many gave up. No one gets a bank to extend a loan that is partially being used to provide for fat cats. Only people that do that are the ones that want to take advantage of the situation of the Bahamian people by getting a deal that screws the power consumer in the Bahamas for another 20 years or so. If you want to do fair business, at reasonable terms and a strong benefit for the consumers, you have to find another place than the Bahamas. Our models offered the government to purchase electricity at 18 cents/kwh for 15 years. the persons in charge were not interested in engaging in a discussion - I bet it was because we didn't bring cash to the meeting.

Posted 29 April 2015, 1:17 p.m. Suggest removal

Sickened says...

And the government's best option for a company to run BEC is facing two class action lawsuits in the US over securities fraud allegations. WTF! Why is Power Secure even being considered? Surely there were other un-corrupt companies in the bidding!

Posted 29 April 2015, 11:39 a.m. Suggest removal

Well_mudda_take_sic says...

WORTH REPEATING: Christie has told Miller that no matter what it takes our National Stadium and hotels must have all the electricity they require during the IAAF Relays to avoid embarrassment for Christie and his government on the international stage. Miller in turn told Christie that this will mean all his black crabs on New Providence with no generator will have to be over-baked during the IAAF Relays. Christie's response: "Don't worry bout over-cooking dem black crabs - they gonna vote for me no matter what when da time come and they ain't fool enough to go crawlin' all over my National Stadium to cause a ruckus during the Relays when they get too much heat to dere heads!"

Posted 29 April 2015, 12:09 p.m. Suggest removal

duppyVAT says...

The DPM who is responsible for BEC says that he needs $200 million for a new Clifton Pier plant ................................what is the timeline??.................... I hope it runs off LNG

Posted 29 April 2015, 12:24 p.m. Suggest removal

GrassRoot says...

remind me, we have a DPM?

Posted 29 April 2015, 1:20 p.m. Suggest removal

asiseeit says...

The question is "What company would be stupid enough to get in bed with government?" Seeing how they operate and treat their "partners" (Baha Mar for instance) would you want to deal with the Government?

Posted 29 April 2015, 12:38 p.m. Suggest removal

GrassRoot says...

Amen. Many tried to provide this government with good and better solutions. No one was listened to by this Government, but then greasy ones - and it seems other than grease, nothing gets produced.

Posted 29 April 2015, 1:21 p.m. Suggest removal

John says...

So are we going to make the same mistake with BEC that made with BTC? Bring in a company full of marketing gimmicks and suck out every dollar they can out this economy? Then have to turn around and hire the same (Bahamian) person they fired to fix the mess they made of BTC. When last did you have a dropped call? Can you hear the clarity on your phone now? We have enough human and financial resources within this country to fix BEC exclusive of direct foreign involvement. Keep the jobs at home. BEC can sell 49% of its worth exclusively to Bahamians and appoint a competent and qualified, non political board of directors to oversee the company. The money generated from the sale of shares along with the floating of bonds can raise more than enough revenue to fix BEC. Once the company becomes profitable those funds will remain in the country.

Posted 29 April 2015, 5:35 p.m. Suggest removal

Well_mudda_take_sic says...

Don't be an idiot. A country with a D minus educated work force is totally incapable of running any utility enterprise at a profit, even if it operates as a monopoly. We just want to be freed of the losses being racked up by BEC, just like the losses that were previously being racked up by BTC. If it takes foreign management and majority foreign ownership to get us basic utility services without losses and debt, then so be it!

Posted 30 April 2015, 9:30 a.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment