Saturday, January 24, 2015
By NICO SCAVELLA
Tribune Staff Reporter
nscavella@tribunemedia.net
FREE National Movement Leader Dr Hubert Minnis yesterday criticised the government for the lengthy delays that stalled the full opening of the Princess Margaret Hospital’s Critical Care Block.
Dr Minnis said if the Christie-led administration “truly believed in Bahamians” they would have “accelerated the process and ensured it was completed a year ago”.
Dr Minnis was one of numerous political and healthcare dignitaries present at the government’s official commissioning ceremony of the CCB on Thursday.
The CCB, a project originally introduced by the FNM in 2011, was originally set to open in June 2013. However, a number of challenges had plagued it since its inception under the former Ingraham administration.
Prime Minister Perry Christie Thursday lauded the commissioning as a “high-water mark in our progress of a nation,” and a positive step towards the government’s proposed 2016 rollout of its $600m National Health Insurance (NHI) scheme.
Speaking with The Tribune Friday, however, Dr Minnis expressed his disappointment with the commissioning. He said Mr Christie also has to explain where he will get the money for the government to jumpstart the NHI scheme.
“We’re very disappointed that the PLP had taken so long to open (the CCB), especially in view that they said they believe and care about Bahamians. It’s quite evident that they didn’t,” Dr Minnis told The Tribune. “We have been preaching repeatedly when we designed (the CCB), that it would relieve the waiting time in the emergency room, the bed situation, and especially the waiting time for surgical procedures, especially those coming from the Family Islands who are inconvenienced and on many occasions cancelled and must return home.
“If (the government) truly believed in Bahamians they would have accelerated the process and ensured that it was completed and opened a year ago as opposed to allowing and forcing Bahamians to suffer and endure the long waiting times for an additional year. That cannot be a government who believes and cares in Bahamians yet allows them to suffer for an unnecessary additional year.”
A number of challenges have plagued the Critical Care Block since its inception under the former Ingraham administration in 2011.
In July of last year, Public Hospital Authority (PHA) officials said the initial attempts at obtaining a $35 million loan from First Caribbean Bank, which was needed for funding the purchase of important medical equipment, had become “problematic.” The PHA also faced issues of insufficient staffing needed to operate the block, which further added to the delays.
Shortly afterwards in August, after PHA Managing Director Herbert Brown and the PHA became embroiled in a multi-million dollar dispute with Cavalier Construction, the company’s Managing Director Richard Wilson said that constant design changes – especially in the mechanical and electrical areas – had delayed completion.
Mr Wilson told Tribune Business that the Critical Care Block was supposed to have been a 20-month project to end in June 2013, but work was still required some 15 months later.
However, as reported by Tribune Business last year and confirmed by Mr Brown, the PHA had since “approved the $35 million loan for the procurement of the equipment, furniture and also management information systems”. He added at the time that the PHA was “very advanced” in its progress to open the facility.
At the commissioning ceremony Thursday, Mr Christie said while the project had “not been without challenge,” its commissioning was a reminder of “how far we have come in terms of the level and quality of healthcare that is available in our public institutions.”
He also reaffirmed the government’s commitment to ensuring that “every citizen of the Bahamas has full access to quality care when they need it,” referring to the government’s proposed 2016 rollout of NHI.
Regarding the latter, however, Dr Minnis said the government needed to “explain to us and the Bahamian people where’s he’s going to get the $350m for phase one” of the NHI rollout.
“(Mr Christie) said that in 2016 he would roll out phase one,” Dr Minnis said. “We do not know what phase one entails, but he did state that phase one would cost $350 million. Already he has introduced VAT on the backs of Bahamian people and caused the cost of living to increase.
“We would love for Bahamians to receive the best possible care the world can offer. They deserve that. It would improve the quality of care. But at the same time (Mr Christie) must inform us where the $350 million that he’s anticipating for his rollout programme January 1 is coming from.”
According to Mr Christie, the CCB is the “single largest financial investment in the public health system,” costing the government over $50m in construction costs and $45m in medical equipment, management information systems and furniture.
NHI was first developed as a policy priority under the first Christie administration. A 15-member Blue Ribbon Commission was appointed to review the feasibility of a National Health Insurance Plan. The National Health Insurance Act 2006 was then tabled in Parliament by the Christie government on November 2006.
Last year Mr Christie said the government plans to introduce NHI in three stages. Stage I would cost $350-$360m, Stage II would cost $500m, and Stage III would cost over $600m.
Comments
Islandgirl says...
Yes, Christie. How do you intend to pay for NHI? You are currently raiding the National Insurance Fund for BoB and other unworthy causes, VAT is here and was supposed to be used to pay down our debt but you are talking mess about using it for infrastructure, now NHI? You people cannot manage the public health care system as it is. As a further insult, you parliamentarians either take yourselves to the expensive private hospital on island or to physicians abroad. Yinna don't have to go through what the rest of us do and yet you want to force something like this on us? Why should more of my money be snatched from me to pay for something like that? We barely get what we need through PHA now, and I DO NOT WANT YOU MAKING CHOICES FOR ME ON MY HEALTH CARE! Why are you always looking for ways to sink this country? Scrap that man! Barely making it around here now! Get accountable with BAMSI and other of the country's raped and wasted funds and return all that largesse to the public treasury, make HEALTHY foods affordable, promote exercise heavily and emphasize PREVENTION and thus avoid this nine to ten figure disaster that you are determined to shove down our throats. I and so many others are so sick of the ineptness and lack of accountability your government is. Retire man and call an early election. We need a coalition of business geniuses to run this country, not PLP, FNM or DNA. This crew needs to go tho and now.
Posted 24 January 2015, 5:34 a.m. Suggest removal
Cobalt says...
Preach it girl!!!! Preach!!!
Posted 24 January 2015, 10:16 a.m. Suggest removal
ThisIsOurs says...
How can they implement a 600m NHI and they can't even pay COB lecturers the money they owe them, TODAY? cant pay service providers for months after service is rendered. Behind on utility bills. They are going to bankrupt us with all of their feel good initiatives.
Posted 24 January 2015, 6:51 a.m. Suggest removal
Cobalt says...
Here is what I don't understand.......
Perry Christie and the PLP have always been an incompetent, corrupted, unaccountable, dishonest, lot. This has always been the legacy of the PLP (at least in the Bahamas I grew up in). So how in the world do bahamian people walk into their polling divisions and vote for this man as their leader??????? Seriously Bahamians??????
And then y'all want to complain when he and his party displays hapless leadership?????? C'mon Bahamians!!! This is who and what the PLP does best!! This is who they are!!!
Dogs bark..... Cats meow..... And the PLP steals, cheats, and is a bungling, dishonest, unaccountable, government!! As a matter of fact, they're nothing more than an extension of the Bahamian people.
In my opinion, the bahamian public are responsible for this mess.... because they are the ones who place Perry and the PLP in a position of power. So yinna deal wit it!! Ya gats 28 more months a dis foolishness ta go!!
Posted 24 January 2015, 10:37 a.m. Suggest removal
duppyVAT says...
BTW ........... how old are you????? Do your research on Pindling & 1984.
Posted 24 January 2015, 1 p.m. Suggest removal
Publius says...
Can we talk about the mold in a building that is supposed to be for critically ill patients?
Posted 24 January 2015, 10:47 a.m. Suggest removal
duppyVAT says...
Perry put VAT on us ............. next year NIB will take 10% of our salary for national health insurance ............... then the shit ga hit da fan!!!!!!!!!!!!! Cobalt ........... I feel you ma bey
Posted 24 January 2015, 1:03 p.m. Suggest removal
TalRussell says...
Cuz these red shirts heads as hard as cement block, they might need secure a bed in clinical care brain injuries ward. Luckily. Minnis is a doctor, doctor, so maybe he can analyze his own reds for explanation and interpretation.
Comrade Tribune bloggers, you unleashed on me for my comments on the hospital photo picturing PM Christie and he former law partner Papa. Why the complete flip flop up positions in less than 24 hours? Is this just an incurable red shirts blogging disability?
Yesterday you reds were all giddy head about, how this was a positive step where one government rather than criticizing the former, is giving credit pastachievements. Or, did I get jest of your blogs all wrong? Doubtful. Cuz if, I was out step, your leader Minnis was be all negative with his lambasting of PM Christie.
My blog comments, unlike your leader, were confined to the two smiling PM’s and the fact that Tribune’s story never even bothered mention Papa’s name, not even in picture’s caption. A cement block is crackable but no hope anything classified Papa spoiled red. Here they go again, upstaging their duly elected red leader? Thank God, Thank You Jesus, them remaining Papa reds are but a fill-a-phone booth sized bunch.
Posted 24 January 2015, 1:36 p.m. Suggest removal
Stapedius says...
Get real. Minnis is dishonest and disingenuous. Anyone who has some idea about healthcare and its administration knows a hospital is more than a building. The equipment, staff and the operational components are challenging. Especially when Cavalier construction has noted the many vexing design changes. So Minnis needs to be honest. The critical care block is not a panacea to the problems of our healthcare system. We have a poorly run system with limited resources. Bahamians didn't want to pay taxes for years but want the best in healthcare technology. We have to get real and stop the political bull$#@t. Government after government has neglected the healthcare system and these jokers behave as if this is the answer to their problems. What about the family islands with years of neglect of education, healthcare and decent safe airports? Chew on that you donkey.
Posted 24 January 2015, 3:27 p.m. Suggest removal
TalRussell says...
Comrade Stapedius I have had family members and friends up in Abaco, who came into this world and left go see Jesus, well hopefully, without ever setting eyes on medical practitioner, above da grade local nurse. Even nurse has disappeared. You die in morning and you is in hole before sundown. You'd be shocked at the occupations who has signed many death certificates. Comrades, if you want see all days your three score and ten - and is late sleeper - best you stay put in Nassau or Freeport. Most islanders never even seen no undertaker. Your Comrade family and friends does give you your last bath and if they really like you will chip in some coin build wooden box, lay you final rest.
Posted 24 January 2015, 3:42 p.m. Suggest removal
Cobalt says...
Stapedius..... I honestly can't argue with your point. You are right. A hospital is more than just a building. Proper healthcare in the Bahamas will ultimately depend on hospital administrators and staff.
Building an extension to the PMH hospital will not alleviate the existing problems at the hospital if the healthcare system is not ran and managed properly.
But as we all know..... Bahamian people offer terrible customer service and are void of any complex management skills. Especially those who operate in the government system. So what good will it do the general public to have "state of the art" technology in the hospital, only to have incompetent, non-caring Bahamian staff members running it???
This new building won't change anything at the PMH. It's the hospital administrators and staff members who must initiate change. And we all know dat ain ga happen.
Posted 25 January 2015, 9:12 a.m. Suggest removal
duppyVAT says...
Renovating PMH is a better option right now than building a new PMH. Just look at what building the new LPIA airport, BTC, Bahamar etc has cost us .... sell out to Canadians, Brits and Chinese. Can we afford more???????
Posted 26 January 2015, 4:30 p.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment