Thursday, July 30, 2015
By NEIL HARTNELL
Tribune Business Editor
nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
Baha Mar yesterday accused the Government of “refusing” to pay its expatriate staff $1.776 million in collective wages that are due today, amid fears this will prompt many upper management executives to quit.
Magdalena Hamya, Baha Mar’s vice-president of human resources and organisational development, told the developer’s 2,500-plus staff via e-mail that the Government was effectively discriminating by moving to pay the salaries of its Bahamian, but not foreign, staff.
“The Government is refusing to pay the salaries owed to Baha Mar’s non-Bahamian employees due this Thursday. We are shocked and extremely upset by this action, and we have urgently appealed to the Government to reverse its damaging and short-sighted decision,” Ms Hamya wrote.
Baha Mar’s expatriate staff are paid monthly. They received their June pay cheques just prior to the developer going into Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, this will be the first payment due since that event.
Ms Hamya said the Government was sending “a terrible message” by moving to pay Baha Mar’s Bahamian, but not foreign, staff.
She was swift to point out that the Government was responsible for preventing the developer paying all staff salaries itself, because by successfully uniting with Baha Mar’s Chinese partners to block the Supreme Court’s recognition of the Chapter 11 proceedings, it had prevented the $80 million financing facility put in place by Sarkis Izmirlian, the project principal, from being used to pay wages.
Bahamian staff are paid bi-weekly, and most observers felt the Government had little choice but to keep paying their wages given that it had already set a precedent by meeting two previous bi-monthly pay cycles from the Public Treasury.
It is unclear why the Government has elected not to pay Baha Mar’s non-Bahamian staff, although this may have been driven by a desire to keep its costs and financial exposure to the developer’s $7.5 million monthly wage bill down.
The move might also be part of the Government’s strategy to further squeeze Mr Izmirlian and Baha Mar, in the hope they will be driven to settle, if key expatriate executives leave because they are not being paid.
Expatriate workers in the hotel and tourism industry tend to hold upper management jobs, and any mass exodus at Baha Mar as a result of non-payment would have a severe impact on the developer’s operations and ability to function.
Should no deal between Baha Mar and its partners, China Construction America and the China Export-Import Bank, be worked out, then the developer plans to reduce its workforce to a ‘skeleton’ 52 staff necessary to preserve the resort assets. It is likely many of this ‘skeleton’ staff would be expatriates.
The Government’s strategy of applying the ‘Bahamian must come first’ slogan directly to the Baha Mar situation is not without risk.
Should a speedy resolution to the Baha Mar dispute be reached, the developer could be deprived of top employees essential to a smooth opening and operation of the $3.5 billion resort if non-payment of wages drove them away.
The departure of key management executives, and their in-built knowledge, would also make it more difficult for the PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) provisional liquidators to organise and negotiate agreements for Baha Mar’s eventual completion and opening.
It potentially threatens to send the wrong message to overseas investors looking at the Bahamas, as well as allowing Baha Mar’s executives to potentially ‘bad mouth’ this nation if they are forced to leave. This could deter skilled expatriate talent from coming to the Bahamas, impacting local businesses.
And an immediate exodus by Baha Mar executives will negatively impact the economy via broken lease agreements, reduced private school fees with children being pulled out, and lower consumer demand and spending resulting in reduced activity.
Ms Hamya, in her e-mail yesterday, said Attorney General, Allyson Maynard-Gibson, had promised in early July to cover Baha Mar’s full $7.5 million monthly payroll.
“The unfairness of the Government’s refusal is underscored by the fact that the Government has already processed two payroll cycles for our Bahamian citizens, and requested details required to process the third cycle,” she said.
“The Government’s refusal is all the more unfair because, as you know, over a month ago, Sarkis and Baha Mar sought to make arrangements to ensure that we would fulfill what we viewed as our ongoing obligations to our citizens, both Bahamian and non-Bahamian, by seeking and obtaining the approval of the Delaware Court under the Chapter 11 process for payment of all salaries and benefits for our citizens in the ordinary course of business.
“Unfortunately, the use of these funds has been blocked at this time because of the subsequent actions by the Government of the Bahamas. Sarkis remains ready and willing to make funds available needed for the payments of your salaries, but he is regrettably unable to do so as a result of the Government’s actions.”
Ms Hamya threw Mrs Maynard-Gibson’s concerns that Baha Mar was using its employees as “pawns” back at her, suggesting the Government was now doing this with the expatriate staff.
“This is a terrible message the Government is now sending to our non-Bahamian citizens,” Ms Hamya said. “We acknowledge the irony that you came to the Bahamas based on the Government’s stringent review of your qualifications in granting you a work permit..........
“It is very distressing for us to contemplate that the Government of the Bahamas finds it acceptable to leave you without salaries that you have already earned. We have vigorously responded to Government’s decision and urged them to reconsider and make immediate arrangements to have your salaries paid.”
Comments
Well_mudda_take_sic says...
Maynard-Gibson aka the Wicked Witch and Gomez aka the Minion know full well that the salary payments being made to the Bahamian employees are unlawful, especially given the government's filing of a petition that Baha Mar be placed in liquidation. The government's assertion that it has the right to make these salary payments from amounts that it purports to owe Baha Mar in connection with the road works is both specious and fallacious. There is no legal right of offset here that would justify the government applying the salary payments made to reduce the amounts it owes Baha Mar. The government is wrongfully (illegally) behaving as if Justice Winder has already heard and approved the government's petition for Baha Mar to be placed in involuntary or compulsory liquidation and as if the salary amounts owing to the Bahamian employees rank ahead of, and in priority to, the salary amounts owing to the non-Bahamian employees on work permits as well as all other creditors of Baha Mar, whether they be secured or unsecured. Moreover, if the government truly believes it has the legal right to offset amounts it purports to owe Baha Mar against the amounts Baha Mar purportedly owes the government (including all of its departments, agencies and corporations), then why have the amounts owing to Baha Mar not been applied in the first instance to reduce the various unpaid taxes and unpaid electricity bills owing by Baha Mar according to the winding up petition filed by the government? What gives our government the right to try and buy votes for political purposes by making these discriminatory salary payments, which payments are tantamount to the government cherry picking on its own whim which of Baha Mar's creditors are to be paid for political purposes without any regard whatsoever for the laws of our land? No doubt we can expect more of the same kind of cherry picking by government of favoured creditors to be paid for political purposes if Baha Mar is placed in liquidation. The government (Christie, Maynard-Gibson and Gomez in particular) will simply lean very heavily on the appointed liquidators and the Court to get done whatever the corrupt Christie-led PLP government wants done for its own purposes, and to hell with the law. This is precisely why Baha Mar and the Izmirlian family had absolutely no choice but to avail themselves of foreign courts in an effort to seek a just and fair outcome to their many legitimate grievances against the Chinese general contractor for the project. Our government, by its wrongful meddling and taking of sides in this matter, has caused almost irreparable and fatal damage to the very substantial efforts made over many years to see this project through to satisfactory completion at the earliest possible time.
Posted 30 July 2015, 5:44 p.m. Suggest removal
Reality_Check says...
It's indeed amazing that the Bahamian government is making these discriminatory salary payments without court approval if, as the government purports in its petition, Baha Mar is insolvent. These illegal salary payments being made by the government are for its own political purposes; the government is clearly using the Bahamian employees concerned as pawns. The salary payments undoubtedly constitute a fraudulent preference perpetrated by our government against the creditors and other stakeholders of Baha Mar, not to mention all Bahamians as taxpayers. All foreigners and foreign courts cannot help but notice our government's blatant and contemptuous disregard for the law in order to achieve its own greedy and vindictive agenda; an agenda that it apparently shares with the project's principal general contractor, CCA, and lender, CEXIMB.
Posted 30 July 2015, 5:46 p.m. Suggest removal
BahamasB2B says...
Indeed this move is discriminatory and illegal. It may also violate the Bahamas Constitution, which states that the rights of ALL people, regardless of place of origin, will be respected.
Posted 30 July 2015, 6:25 p.m. Suggest removal
BaronInvest says...
Some of my neighbors work in management positions at the Baha Mar and are already leaving the island within the next 3 weeks due to this situation.
I also know a few cooks who have been hired who are leaving - Guess Christie will have to cook italian and french food on his own now... The Bahamas are loosing some exceptional talents with every week this situation is not solved.
Just a matter of time until the real estate and car market drops and more people loosing jobs.
Posted 30 July 2015, 8:32 p.m. Suggest removal
Economist says...
This is all about votes, nothing else.
Posted 31 July 2015, 1:42 p.m. Suggest removal
birdiestrachan says...
The Bahamas does not have the means to pay those people. and there is no law that says they should. Those from other Countries who decide to return home. are free to do so.
Posted 31 July 2015, 8:03 p.m. Suggest removal
BaronInvest says...
Don't forget that these people have been trained and have all the experience to give the project a good start. Even if you think the GOV should not cover their income at this point it's important for the project that these people stay - and they won't without income.
As a foreign investor who wants to leave his money in your country i'm watching very closely how the government is handling this and what i see so far i don't like at all.
In my oppinion, if it's your interest to get the Bahamar open quickly you'll better pay everyone as looking for new staff, getting them here, training them, getting permits will take significant more time and money.
So i don't think it's a smart move to let people in management positions run out of cash, forcing them to leave the country.
You will need even more time to understand project and even new management staff will need more time to start working as they don't have someone who can simply introduce them the current process and workflows.
Posted 1 August 2015, 12:01 p.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment