Call for independent probe amid Rubis spill fears

By RICARDO WELLS

Tribune Staff Reporter

rwells@tribunemedia.net

OFFICIALS of the environmental advocacy group Save the Bays yesterday called for an independent investigation into reports of a feared fuel leak from the Rubis (Bahamas) service station in the Sandyport Olde Town Mall.

Save the Bays CEO Vanessa Haley-Benjamin said yesterday that due to the lack of transparency and failure to adopt best practices during the “now notorious Marathon fuel spill,” there is a great need for independent investigators to look into the new reports made by area residents and proprietors last week.

She alleged, however, the government has known about the reported leak for weeks and offered no public commentary until concerned residents began to voice their concerns on social media.

Mrs Haley-Benjamin said it appeared that both the government and the company have failed to learn lessons from the December 2012 Marathon incident involving another Rubis station.

She added that many affected Marathon residents were kept in the dark for more than two years, despite serious potential consequences for their health and safety resulting from prolonged exposure to an extremely hazardous cocktail of chemical compounds.

Both the government and Rubis kept their silence until forced to speak when Michael Pintard raised the matter in the Senate earlier this year, she said.

“The government apologised and promised to be more transparent going forward. Yet here we are just a few months later, facing reports of another possible fuel spill, and again outside pressure was needed to bring the matter to light,” Ms Haley-Benjamin said.

“More generally speaking, considering the serious and ongoing environmental damage caused by petrochemical pollution throughout New Providence and around The Bahamas, it was hoped that our political leaders would consider every potential case to be high priority.

“A critical part of doing so would be ensuring that investigations into possible spills, leaks and other polluting incidents are conducted by credible independent bodies. In this regard, we find it alarming that Rubis is being allowed to conduct its own probe into the Sandyport complaints, EMRAD’s separate review notwithstanding.”

Mrs Haley-Benjamin insisted that in other countries, experienced scientists and industry experts with “a reputation for thoroughness and objectivity” would have been contracted to conduct investigations.

“It is lamentable that in this area, as in so many others pertaining to environmental protection, The Bahamas continues to lag far behind. This case is yet another pointed example of why the country desperately needs a robust Freedom of Information Act to be passed immediately.”

While she applauded the news that the Environmental Remediation and Response Laboratory (EMRAD) is now investigating, she questioned why the government remained tightlipped until the matter was raised in a Facebook post.

Meanwhile, Managing Director of Rubis Gordon Craig insisted in an interview with The Tribune on Sunday that the company was doing everything to not only correct the matter, but find the source of the issue.

He stated that once notified, representatives from Rubis were dispatched to the Sanyport site, shutting down the station’s pumps and carrying out extensive testing at the site.

“There were no issues or leaks observed at the time,” said Mr Craig.

“We went through all the necessary protocols and concluded that whatever issues existed, it wasn’t as a result of Rubis. However, beyond that we will continue to monitor the situation in the coming days.”

Comments

birdiestrachan says...

Ms. Benjamin and this news report. neglected to say that measures were put in place to deal with the spill. even if the public was not notified. there was work being done to rectify the spill. they did not just sit on the situation and do nothing. I think the prominent well know QC is a part of this group. so what more can one expect. Now when the dredging was done in the Exuma Sea Park. all was well with these attention seeking folks.

Posted 16 June 2015, 1:28 p.m. Suggest removal

Sickened says...

Pray tell what measures were put in place in Sandy Port to either clean up or contain the spill? I live in the Sandy Port area and did not see any oil booms, absorption pads, skimmers... nothing to clean up the mess.

Posted 16 June 2015, 1:38 p.m. Suggest removal

EnoughIsEnough says...

birdiestrachan - "even if the public was not notified"??? Really? people swim in that canal, they paddle and kayak in that canal, they shop along the canalfront and dine at restaurants where the smell from the leak is oftentimes quite overpowering and nauseating. the absolute first step should have been to notify residents to stay out of the canals until investigations were complete. And you should not have the company potentially involved in the leak to be the one to investigate. We are relying on the word of Rubis to say that it wasn't them? Really? Have you not been following the issue with the oil spills at Clifton from the BEC plant? The Marathon issue? There is absolutely nothing in place to address the gas/oil that is in Sandyport and other than seeing a few Rubis folk walking around, nothing seems to have been done. The issue has been going on for at least a month with reports made to Rubis, the Ministry and the Sandyport Developers and no one acted or said a peep until comments were posted on the Raising AWareness of the Bahamas Landfill page on Facebook. When will we learn to do better?

Posted 16 June 2015, 1:51 p.m. Suggest removal

Well_mudda_take_sic says...

The exceptionally high incidence level of cancer experienced by residents of Sandyport also should have them very much concerned about the possibility of unusually high levels of cancer causing radon gas in their area. Most of the land in Sandport was once low lying mangrove type swamp land that the developers heavily dredged and filled in. Such areas are notorious for emitting unusually high levels of radon gas into the environment which can pose a very serious health threat to residents living in the immediate area as a result of their prolonged exposure to the gas. Rather than trusting the results of any extensive radon testing that may have been done for the developers at the beginning of the Sandyport development project, residents would be wise to get together and have their own independent extensive testing of the area done if they have not already done so.

Posted 17 June 2015, 8:46 a.m. Suggest removal

Reality_Check says...

Are you trying to give Rubis some kind of free pass here? While harmfully high concentrations of radon gas may indeed exist in areas of karst (limestone) topography, it is less common in such areas. Until now, I haven't heard anything about the residents of Sandyport encountering higher incidents of cancer.

Posted 17 June 2015, 9:40 a.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment