Wednesday, August 10, 2016
Branville McCartney’s offer to disaffected FNM supporters last week was a brilliant move, says Malcolm J Strachan . . .
Most Bahamians are today still trying to ‘catch themselves’ after a raucous week filled with convention shenanigans and political pomposity.
From calls for tube tying and threats of resignations, to actual resignations in the House of Assembly, it’s any wonder we can keep it together in this crazy town called Nassau. Our political class has effectively lost their collective minds - figuratively of course.
The question most people ask themselves once they’ve gone around the political mulberry bush is, where do we go from here? The Free National Movement (FNM) battle circa 2016 has come and gone in a whimper.
What was expected to be an all-out battle royal was nothing more than a whiff in the wind - with only the odd starfish to remind us of better days.
The torch that once shone so bright has lost a few flames ... and a few supporters along the way.
Following the unfortunately named ‘Because You Matter’ FNM convention, party supporters were left mortified. Where has their party gone, they asked? What is this foolishness on my TV, they questioned? Is it too late to get Papa back, they pleaded!
The questions went on and on without answer, until they saw at last there was no hope in putting humpty dumpty back together again. The FNM was irreparably broken. Its supporters were in shock, and in desperate need of therapy.
The doctor they didn’t want was the doctor they got, and this doctor, like his fish supplier, makes house calls.
But this was no laughing matter to many. For the greater risk involved was the yet to be met villain of the piece - the scourge of our 700 islands and cays, the Progressive Liberal Party (PLP).
Was it foolhardy to imagine that Dr Hubert Minnis could mount a successful campaign against such an enemy? How can this current FNM machine defeat such a foe? No doubt, the financial backers of the party would come running to lend their support to their newly-crowned prince once again. We think not.
They are, as they were before, still concerned about the leadership of the party - now more so than ever. So where do these backers go? Where do these dissatisfied FNM supporters go? Not to the PLP - so where?
In their eyes they have no home. Their party is finished.
As the Democratic National Alliance’s (DNA) leader Branville McCartney so aptly put it, the FNM “is dead”.
Now, normally we are not one to engage in the machinations of third party manoeuverings, but the more we listen to Mr McCartney, the more we fear the country, nay, the FNM, would not be where they were if this young man had stood his ground and remained with the FNM.
Last week, Branville offered a timely olive branch to FNMs who were upset and hurting, to join with him in rescuing the Bahamas from the PLP.
It was a bold move, and one that showed political maturity. While the other leaders in the party were busy scalping each other, here was a former FNM reaching out to that party’s base assuring them of a safe harbour. There’s one word for this type of political move - brilliance.
But, does Bran have what it takes to truly capitalise on this infighting within the FNM to give the PLP a run for their money?
Let us look at what he told the media last week.
“Last week, the Free National Movement attempted to hold a National Convention under the theme of Unity. What many witnessed for the first time, is what I had discovered seven years ago - the FNM that was built on the ideals of democracy, transparency, and accountability is dead.
“It has been replaced by the same incompetence and corruption that has come to define the Progressive Liberal Party.
“I take no pleasure in making these statements. To come to this point is a very painful reality for many Bahamians.
“But both of these parties are mere shadows of their former selves. The DNA truly believes that the people of this country are its most precious resource, above all natural or material resources.
“This is not the PLP that led us to majority rule. This is not the PLP that led us into Independence and gave us National Insurance. Likewise, this is not the FNM that opened up the airwaves, or provided critical infrastructure on our Family Islands.
“The vision that existed in those parties is long gone. But now, what we must decide as a people, is where do we go from here.
“For those who believe in democracy, who want a better future for our country, a future that provides real opportunities for Bahamians, we invite you to join with us in the Democratic National Alliance.”
Now, whether or not this will translate into a flood of supporters joining up with the DNA is yet to be seen, but what matters is that he made the offer in the first place.
Let’s remember, in 2012, the DNA showed just how powerful a small, fledgling political party can be. They were, by all accounts, the chief force that ensured the defeat of the then FNM Government by stealing away thousands of voters from their traditional base.
Independents and millennials were also attracted to the message of a new party, with new ideals - and a departure from the status quo.
That party has had four years to build on its track record.
It would be foolish for any political leader, be it Minnis, or Prime Minister Perry Christie, to count them out of 2017.
We have yet to make up our minds about the DNA for 2017. While the party still has its share of issues with quality candidates, it can hardly be worse than the lot we have in office today - or the crew in the FNM.
We have a smorgasbord of “has-beens” and “what’s their face again” candidates who wash up at the polls every five years for a walloping.
We believe Bahamians this time around, have a shock up their sleeve for all of them.
As Branville McCartney said in his speech last week, “As a country the issues that we are facing are far too serious for us to continue to accept the status quo. Bahamians deserve better than a “Dancer in Chief”, or a man who can’t dance at all.”
We agree with him. The real question is, do you?
• Comments and
responses to insight@tribunemedia.net
Comments
banker says...
The trouble with Branville McCartney is that he is a lightweight that lies. The most notable one that stuck in my craw was his assertion that he was democratically elected as leader of the DNA. Several disaffected early members state that it is an outright lie.
That goes to character. He is unfit to lead the country.
Posted 11 August 2016, 11:01 a.m. Suggest removal
OrdinaryMan says...
banker...i normally admire your astute comments, so allow me to query: you say, "...Several disaffected early members state that it is an outright lie."
Um,, how credible are these 'disaffected' early members...assuming they are not 'sour grapes' folks. Also, since ALL politicians have to lie to some degree, with some lies being relevant and others being irrelevant, do you personally know Branville enough to accurately judge his character?
Just wonderin'. Sir.
Posted 12 August 2016, 11:38 a.m. Suggest removal
athlete12 says...
Banker if you wont back Branville because he supposedly lied then I'm guessing you've never voted in the Bahamas because all of our leaders have lied , almost daily.
The fact is the Bahamas cannot go forward with the PLP or FNM at the helm. I'd rather take my chances with the new party on the block rather than two parties with ancient members(or younger ones who just want to ride the bus) who only will impose policies that will only help themselves and the rich. Our tax dollars are wasted while they cat fight. Given our proximity and relationship with the US and other first world countries and saddening to see where we are as country and society.
Remind the PLP and the FNM that it is we the people that rule.
Posted 11 August 2016, 12:38 p.m. Suggest removal
sheeprunner12 says...
Branville holds the outcome of the 2017 election in his hand again ........... Bran needs to find a way to draw the disaffected FNM MPs & senior officers to his side and make a deal with Greg Moss and other splinter groups .......... they must consolidate and separate their philosophical message from Christie and Minnis who are both leading this country into the national gutter ............ this is the only hope for our country in the next election
Posted 11 August 2016, 2:05 p.m. Suggest removal
Alex_Charles says...
Either Bran joins a coalition and sucks up his pride OR prepare for another PLP administration. Both the DNA and the FNM have completely failed to garner the support of the Bahamian people en mass, notably the largest voting block of under 35. Either suck it up Bran or STFU for another 5 years
Posted 11 August 2016, 2:48 p.m. Suggest removal
sheeprunner12 says...
The DNA won 8% of the 2012 popular vote .......... do not denigrate that feat ........ they may improve on that ........ Unfortunately we do not have a proportional representative system like Israel or Tanzania that will have given Bran access to a seat or two in Parliament ........ we have an ass- backwards parliamentary system that only rewards two political parties
Posted 11 August 2016, 3 p.m. Suggest removal
Honestman says...
I believe few Bahamians relish the prospect of five years with either Christie or Minnis at the helm. The PLP is corrupt to its core and cannot change just as a "leopard cannot change its spots". The FNM is no longer the party of responsible and efficient government - it has morphed into a lightweight and rudderless version of the PLP. Neither party is motivated to act in the best interests of the Nation and both are driven by vested interests. If ever there was a time for a credible third party to make its mark in Bahamian politics it is surely now. Branville McCartney is the face and the voice of the DNA but that is the problem. He is perceived as a "one man show". He mostly speaks in populist soundbites but he has no proven track record in government and at this point in time he has no "big hitters" in his party. Sure his party will mop up a very significant protest vote and might exceed the 8% of total vote earned last time round. However, he and everyone else with any savvy knows that this will not translate into more than a couple of seats in a PLP dominated HOA. The only solution is for an electoral pact between the opposition parties so that disaffected PLP voters have only one alternative choice in each constituency.
Posted 11 August 2016, 3:57 p.m. Suggest removal
banker says...
I'd rather take Christie than Bran.
But, Minnis has what it takes -- not to be a politician, but to generate policy that actually helps instead of hinders this country.
But quite frankly, it doesn't matter who is in charge. The country is screwed unless drastic measures are taken. And with the generations of defective human capital, it will take many years beyond our lifetimes to get to even a second world country.
Posted 11 August 2016, 9:44 p.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment