Waste-energy firm warns on ‘Bahamas reputation damage’

By NEIL HARTNELL

Tribune Business Editor

nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

The “increasingly frustrated” firm behind the $600-$650 million waste-to-energy plant proposal has warned the Government that its three-year wait for approval “risks damaging the reputation of the Bahamas”.

UK-based attorneys for Stellar Energy, the company in the ‘Letter of Intent’ controversy that engulfed former parliamentary secretary Renward Wells, warned the Attorney General that the treatment of their client ran counter to the Government’s goal of a swift investment approvals process.

Nabarro LLP, in a July 4, 2016, letter to Allyson Maynard-Gibson, said: “The delay in approval of the project would seem to be at odds with the stated goal of the Bahamas Investment Authority to limit the approval period to 60 days or less following presentation of a project for approval.

“Furthermore, as we hope you can appreciate, these ongoing delays and lack of appreciation from the relevant Ministries risk damaging the reputation of the Bahamas as a destination for foreign direct investment in relation to a critical and nationally important infrastructure project.”

The letter, which has been obtained by Tribune Business, appears to have been crafted as both a warning to the Government and last-ditch effort to avoid the legal action that Stellar Energy launched earlier this month.

The claim alleges Stellar was promised that a June 30, 2014, Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) would be executed by Deputy Prime Minister Philip Davis and issued to the company, allowing it to proceed with its planned project at the New Providence landfill. This has not happened.

“Our client has been awaiting the final approval of the project and issue of such documentation for over 36 months, and has now instructed us to write to you seeking the urgent issue of the same,” Nabarro said.

“As we hope you can appreciate, our client just wants to understand the current status of the approval process so that it can timetable and mobilise its international team to deliver the project without further delay and expense.”

Nabarro’s letter seeks to arrange a conference call with the Attorney General’s Office and Mrs Maynard-Gibson’s team, in a bid to “discuss a realistic timeline” for the approvals process and what is required from Stellar Energy.

The UK law firm says the documents provided to it by its client “raise a number of serious concerns regarding the approvals process to-date”, and that “no meaningful response” had been received in response to inquiries with numerous Bahamian government ministries.

“Our client is growing increasingly frustrated with the apparent delays in the approval process, which have now lasted over three years,” Nabarro wrote.

“The ongoing delays are negatively impacting their business, and also their contractual relationships with the project’s international; technical and financial partners who have all invested significant time and resources in the project.

“This lack of any response is causing our client to incur additional costs, and is placing a strain on its supply chain, which has committed significant resources to the project to-date.”

Tribune Business has also seen an August 14, 2015, letter sent to Stellar chief executive, Dr Fabrizio Zanaboni, from Phylicia Woods at the Bahamas Investment Authority, in which she says it is “preparing this matter to take before the National Economic Council”. But neither an approval, nor a rejection, has been forthcoming.

And David Davis, permanent secretary in the Ministry of Financial Services, said it was “impressed” by Stellar’s project and “would be minded to lend our support to the proposed public-private partnership (PPP)” in a June 8, 2015, letter to Dr Zanaboni.

Comments

Well_mudda_take_sic says...

Stellar Energy is only proceeding with its legal action because Minnis has invited them to do so with the understanding that they would be allowed to proceed with their waste project once he becomes PM. Minnis "got the goods" on what went down with the LOI from Wells himself, which is why he so willingly invited Wells into the FNM fold. The sleaze and slime here at the very top of both the PLP and FNM stinks to high heaven! Stellar Energy and the principals behind it (i.e. the corrupt bribing parties) need to be thoroughly investigated and exposed for their criminal conduct. This can be accomplished as a vital part of the discovery phase to a counter-action to the frivolous litigation they have had the audacity to commence in an effort to coerce the Bahamian people into accepting a project borne out of fraud perpetuated against them.

Posted 20 August 2016, 10:43 a.m. Suggest removal

Reality_Check says...

A letter of intent (LOI) is never a binding commitment until it has been duly approved and executed. No such LOI was ever entered into as it would have required written approval by the Minister of Finance and in all likelihood a parliamentary resolution of approval given the financial amount involved. Only then could it have been signed by one or more duly authorized signatories of the government. Wells signing the LOI with no authority to do so in any circumstance had no significance or consequence for Stellar Energy from the stand point of creating any kind of binding commitment. The same goes for any government correspondence discussing the feasibility or likelihood of the waste project coming into fruition. Whatever Stellar Energy and its principals may have foolishly done without having a binding commitment in hand from our government is their business. Their lawyers should have advised them that certain protocols are required to be followed by our government in approving and authorizing any such commitment as a matter of Bahamian law. They should therefore be suing their lawyers who appear not to have served them well, but as for suing our government (the Bahamian people), that's a whole different bowl of malarkey for which they should be laughed out of court!

Posted 20 August 2016, 12:41 p.m. Suggest removal

Well_mudda_take_sic says...

When Wells realized he was about to get shafted by those higher up than himself in the corrupt Christie-led PLP government, he went to Minnis and said: "I would be willing to come over to the FNM under certain conditions." Minnis naturally responded: "What are the conditions and what do you have that I can later use to my benefit?" Wells would have then handed over to Minnis an envelope of documents and said: "I pledge my loyalty to you and by the way this envelope contains the full story on the LOI matter as I know it, showing who knew what when and did what at what time." Minnis would have opened the envelope, quickly looked over its contents and said: "Welcome on board my ship; you have made a wise decision my boy and I expect much from you on the loyalty front." End of conversation. Now months later Minnis chooses to leak some of the documents to the press while making sure to hold back on leaking other more incriminating documents for later use. As Edison Key would say: "It's always better to keep some dry powder on hand for later use at the most opportune of times!"

Posted 20 August 2016, 4:06 p.m. Suggest removal

proudloudandfnm says...

Can't Stellar be denied based just on the fact that their CFO is a convicted criminal?

I say yes of course they can.... The dude was convicted over a year ago and Stellar has not fired him. Low ethical standards.

Posted 20 August 2016, 7:25 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment