Auditor warns of ‘breeding ground of improprieties’

By NEIL HARTNELL

and RASHAD ROLLE

THE Auditor General has warned of an “alarming amount of alleged theft” at the Post Office, with at least one of its practices branded “a breeding ground for improprieties”.

The audit of the Government’s 2013-2014 accounts portrays the Post Office as riddled with deficiencies, prompting the Auditor General, Terrance Bastian, to raise the possibility of bringing in police to investigate.

The Auditor General’s report, which was tabled in the House of Assembly yesterday, also called for the Post Office to be restructured and “immediate actions” taken where there is evidence of theft by staff.

The flaws and weaknesses identified by the Auditor General and his staff include The Postmaster’s bank account at Bank of the Bahamas in Freeport, which “continues to be unreconciled’’.

Funds deposited and disbursed from this account were regularly sent to Nassau via cheque, regardless of whether it was in surplus or overdrawn, a practice the Auditor General said required “explanation”.

He added: “It is our recommendation that this bank account is suspended until it is properly reconciled; its current state is a breeding ground for improprieties.”

The report also detailed at least two cases where money was either missing or “misappropriated” - almost $64,000 unaccounted for in Ragged Island and $1,259 “borrowed” by a cashier at the Cable Beach Post Office.

“The Postmaster General, along with the appropriate staff, should seek to minimise the alarming amount of alleged misappropriations which appear to be occurring within the Post Office,” the Auditor General concluded. “Where the elements of theft can be proven, these matters should be turned over to the Royal Bahamas Police Force for prosecution.

“The idea of transferring these employees from one department to another should be discontinued. The department must move towards ensuring that Government and the public funds are protected. Based on our findings, it appears that the Post Office Department is in need of restructuring. Where there is evidence of misappropriation by staff members, immediate actions should be taken to remedy the exorbitant loss of revenue.”

The Auditor General and his team were provided with documents to support $159,919 in Money Orders being issued from the Ragged Island Post Office. This included Money Order changes not paid into the Post Office, but the audit revealed that based on the documents provided, some $63,914 “was not brought to account”.

The Auditor General said that the former Ragged Island cashier, when interviewed, admitted that while she was in Ragged Island, she had misappropriated a “large” amount of funds. This was done via the remittance of Money Orders sent throughout the Bahamas without any funds first being collected before issuance, the report said. The cashier had not followed “established accounting procedures”.

“The interview with the former postal officer showed that she had received initial instructions from the senior clerk, who relayed certain instructions that Money Orders should be remitted in her name. Once these Money Orders were cashed, the amount was to be forwarded to the senior clerk’s persona account at the Royal Bank of Canada or the Bank of the Bahamas,” the Auditor General said.

“We noted that the total amount of telegraph Money Orders received or remitted by the individual for the period under review amounted to $329,287. We could not verify that the funds were first received before the Money Orders were processed.”

A further review of “this unusual practice” was necessary, the Auditor General said, “to ensure that this was not a pattern to allegedly defraud the Government. A further review was carried out and, by all indications, it showed that this practice appeared to have occurred before.”

The Auditor General called for a major training of Post Office staff throughout the Bahamas as well as the establishment of an internal control section.

He again decried a lack of accountability by unnamed public officials, saying: “Public offices are not being held accountable for their actions, which results in loss or wastage of government funds.”

Although he found many areas of the government’s finances to be satisfactory, he said obtaining access to audit information and documents remained difficult in some government departments and ministries.

He pointed frequently to errors of varying degrees of seriousness that affected several departments and ministries, including the Ministry of Financial Services and Investments (where the “expenditure function was … not in full compliance with government accounting procedures manual”), the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Immigration (which was “over budget on total expenditures due in part to overseas missions”), and the Customs Department (where numerous audits confirmed that incorrect rates of duty were applied in “many instances”).

Mr Bastian again declined to certify the final accounts of the government as being representative of the “true and fair view of the state of affairs for the year ended June 30, 2014,” arguing that internal control weaknesses concerning revenue and expenditure are such that he could not attest to the completeness and fairness of the “Cash and Bank Balances”.

For more details, see Business story HERE

Comments

spoitier says...

You think those employees wasn't stealing under the FNM?
This a tendency of a lot of Bahamians and bringing in the police could be just as futile because some of them does thief also.

Posted 4 February 2016, 3:14 p.m. Suggest removal

Cobalt says...

Changing the government won't accomplish anything related to theft. Sad truth is, Bahamians are just proned to dishonesty and stealing.

Posted 4 February 2016, 8:40 p.m. Suggest removal

SP says...

Don't blame all "Bahamians". The blame is on successive crooked politicians that appoint crooked followers in "privileged" key positions then protect the crooks from scrutiny. Systemic corruption is real and evidenced more and more each day. Yet NOBODY is ever fined or jailed!

Posted 5 February 2016, 7:36 a.m. Suggest removal

TruePeople says...

Point is the whole system is such that it encourages misbehavior. Entering into these workplaces, where the culture is dishonest from the top, the young ones are easily and quickly corrupted.

Bahamians may not be naturally dishonest and teefin'. but enough of them have some entitled mentality, that errything should be one free ride, and if yuh ein getting some kickback, den bey, take what you want because 'you deserve it'. That's the issue. Erryone hand out like you owe dem something. If you ein give dem outright, they hands gern in yuh pockets (or ya P.O.Box)

Posted 5 February 2016, 10:38 a.m. Suggest removal

TruePeople says...

surprise surprise. erryone teefin

Posted 4 February 2016, 1:39 p.m. Suggest removal

jus2cents says...

The Bahamian "Postal "Service" " is diabolical, it is a Joke... literally!

I tell people "PLEASE DO NOT POST ANYTHING TO ME EVER" it will come months later if at all. Oh the MANY Christmas presents that have gone missing :(

This is what you can do in a UK post Office - http://www.postoffice.co.uk/

As well as get your groceries, newspapers, wine, pension, pay all your household bills, get benefits, pay licences and taxes and buy cards, post parcels, get insurance, lottery tickets, Phone cards, gifts, etc. All done with ONE smiling helpful old lady that knows you & your whole family, their names as well as their dogs names.

Here you get a gang of surly old ladies, (no eye contact) in slippers who can't even be bothered to Buzz The Door to let you in! Everything is done SLOOOOOWLY & manually on carbon papers & Not Computers!!! What they think computers are just a phase!!????

I would fire them all, close (Trust me no one will notice) and restructure all the Post Offices.

Posted 4 February 2016, 2:02 p.m. Suggest removal

TruePeople says...

they'd teef the computers... when they is be teefin the carbon paper it's cheaper to replace

Posted 4 February 2016, 2:07 p.m. Suggest removal

sheeprunner12 says...

Come on guys ............... this is money laundering ........... what Glenys Hanna Martin gat to say about this?????????? ................ will she now cuss out the Auditor General like LBT????

Posted 4 February 2016, 2:38 p.m. Suggest removal

Voltaire says...

Hahahaha yeah "The thieves weren't actually licensed employees of the Post Office, we just let them come to work there every day by mistake."

Posted 4 February 2016, 2:58 p.m. Suggest removal

realfreethinker says...

Every month is another shit house of money missing. What is going on ?

Posted 4 February 2016, 3:51 p.m. Suggest removal

TalRussell says...

"The Auditor General concluded. “Where the elements of theft can be proven, these matters should be turned over to the Royal Bahamas Police Force for prosecution".
Comrades "should be turned over to the Royal Bahamas Police Force for prosecution" .
is covert for - give the PLP cabinet another chance whitewash another report, pointing to acts dishonesty by people employed by the nation's hardworking taxpayers'.

Posted 4 February 2016, 5:03 p.m. Suggest removal

SP says...

PLP and FNM, together, forever!

Posted 4 February 2016, 5:34 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment