EDITORIAL: TIME FOR AN OVERHAUL OF TOURISM POLICY

THE possibility of establishing normal relations between the USA and Cuba has always been seen as a potential threat to our tourism industry here in The Bahamas. If the restrictions on American visitors to the island were lifted, its attractions as a tourist destination are obvious because of its rarity value and its inherent historical interest as well as the same sun, sea and sand that we ourselves offer. So, despite President Trump’s recent move to reverse his predecessor’s relaxation of the travel rules, there is no room for complacency because tour group visits will still be permitted.

Since tourism is a mainstay of the Bahamian economy, we believe that the competition from Cuba and from other rivals in the Caribbean region, which is constantly growing as they improve their own tourism product, makes it important for the new government to take a hard overall look at what we offer visitors and how we can improve it. Likewise, it is important to re-examine the government’s role in promoting, supporting and regulating tourism, not least in light of the PLP government’s reprehensible involvement in the Baha Mar project and the alleged chicanery associated with it.

Such a review does not imply that the Ministry of Tourism itself is failing to do its job properly, though there have been setbacks recently like the Fyre Festival fiasco that resulted partly from lack of adequate official scrutiny and created damaging international publicity for The Bahamas. But with a new and vigorous minister in place, who is renowned for his no-nonsense approach, the time seems ripe for a wide ranging reassessment. It is important, in particular, to examine the balance between attracting foreign investment in the sector without permitting huge developments inimical to the environment (what is happening now in Bimini should be a cautionary tale) and developing other areas like local cultural attractions and ecotourism with its enormous potential which has been neglected over the years.

With so much on its plate, such a major review may not be at the top of the government’s agenda, but we were encouraged by the Prime Minister’s address last week to the annual meeting of the Bahamas Hotel and Tourism association in which he set out his government’s tourism strategy.

While recognising the vital contribution made by the existing multinational resorts, boutique hotels, fishing lodges, tour companies, water sports operators and others, Dr Minnis nonetheless stressed the need for further diversification to cover the country’s history and culture – its music and dance, arts, folklore and variety of sporting facilities – in order to show that we have more to offer the interested visitor than simply lying on a beach and soaking up the sun.

His plan to strengthen the links between foreign direct investment and home-grown businesses, thereby encouraging local entrepreneurship, seems to be based on what he has termed an ‘incentive framework’. This is surely to be welcomed, though we hope the government will apply any new financial incentives with due care lest the practice is allowed to drift into tax dollars being used as subsidies simply to prop up individual companies. More importantly, the government ought to be cutting red tape and limiting regulation so as to improve the ease of doing business across-the- board.

Admirable as the Prime Minister’s so-called ‘master plan’ appears to be, we urge him at the same time to take urgent action in relation to Bay Street which cruise ship visitors encounter as soon as they disembark. There has been much talk of revitalising the area but successive plans never seem to be implemented. In particular, East Bay Street has become an eyesore and an embarrassment. With so many false starts, the time has come for government to provide leadership and direction in order to stimulate action.

A visitor’s overall experience of our country is what counts if the word is to be spread that it really is ‘better in The Bahamas’, so the government also needs to look at the broader picture. It is encouraging that many practical aspects of local life work well; for example, our hotels, banks, supermarkets, medical and dental services, pharmacies, gas stations, restaurants and wine stores, to name just a few. But all these are run by the private sector. The electricity supply remains unreliable (despite being partially privatised) and it is now widely recognised that the provision of services is better managed by private businesses. One glaring example of public sector inadequacy is our woefully inefficient postal service which has deteriorated to an alarming extent in recent years and has now become a disgrace. The failings of the Post Office affect businesses and private citizens alike, including our visitors. The government should take immediate measures to manage it properly or, in the longer term, privatise it.

More generally, these are still early days for the new administration, and its overall performance so far has been more than satisfactory. But, unless it produces meaningful long-term results, the honeymoon will not last. In light of the almost daily revelations about the Christie government’s financial malfeasance, the public’s demand for accountability of its political leaders continues to grow.

Moving forward, people want transparency and efficiency in handling the country’s affairs. As our major industry, tourism in particular needs effective organization and management in order to achieve maximum benefit for the nation as a whole. We are confident that the dynamic new minister directly responsible will rise to the challenge.

Comments

OMG says...

The Post Office is an absolute joke. First of all don't subscribe to any periodical such as National Geographic or international newspaper because you will not see many arrive. I know for a fact that a personal subscription to a periodical stopped arriving after the first issue. Company traced delivery of my periodical every motnh to Nassau Post Office and there it disappeared. Don't even talk about letters, you may as well swim and hand deliver them.

Posted 24 June 2017, 8:31 a.m. Suggest removal

sheeprunner12 says...

If 75% of ALL of our tourists are cruise-ship tourists.......... why is it that they all go to Nassau, Freeport or private company cays?????? ......... Why is it that they do not let the tourists go to every Family Island??????? ........... Can you imagine what two cruise ships stopping off to every Family Island every week will do for the local island economies????? ........... Tenders and ferries take cruise tourists ashore throughout ALL of the Pacific Islands .......... Why cannot it be done in The Bahamas????? ............ Start with these small things that can help the other depressed islands (who have more attractions to offer than Nassau or Freeport)

Posted 24 June 2017, 12:35 p.m. Suggest removal

DDK says...

Idea!!!!!!

Posted 24 June 2017, 4:42 p.m. Suggest removal

ashley14 says...

I can tell you why, but you don't want to hear it.

Posted 25 June 2017, 10:35 a.m. Suggest removal

ashley14 says...

It would be great if they did, but they do have good reasons.

Posted 25 June 2017, 10:36 a.m. Suggest removal

sheeprunner12 says...

Ashley4 .......... If you live outside of The Bahamas, but you know why Bahamian registered cruise ships cannot stop off at Exuma, Cat Island, Long Island, Inagua etc ......... feel free to let us know ............. IT'S THE PEOPLES' TIME

Posted 25 June 2017, 11:19 a.m. Suggest removal

ashley14 says...

It's not that they cannot, they don't want to.

Posted 28 June 2017, 8:42 a.m. Suggest removal

DDK says...

Thank you for a very good and to the point editorial.

Posted 24 June 2017, 4:41 p.m. Suggest removal

CatIslandBoy says...

I'd like to hear the reasons too. Please?

Posted 26 June 2017, 8:36 p.m. Suggest removal

TheMadHatter says...

The Bahamas is just one big baby factory. Don't expect anything more.

Posted 27 June 2017, 6:24 p.m. Suggest removal

ashley14 says...

First anything I say is just my opinion and I don't want to offend anyone. Look at what the cruise lines are currently doing. They take the tourist to the private island, I think they are building or going to build a dock off shore. This keeps the tourists away from the local citizens. Why? Crime, Pushy sales tactics. I don't agree with this idea at all but a family coming in on holiday won't bring their children where they are being warned before they exited the ship to beware of the crime and to leave their valuables on board. Also most Americans want to go to established Resorts. I think it would be probably the best cruise I've ever taken to visit the out islands. Most Americans are looking for something else. I love the Bahamian culture and people, and when I visit I don't want to go to Paradise Island and stay in a gated Resort. That not what I do. Sunday morning I want to go over the hill to church. I want to eat in Bahamian Restaurants and get to know the people, but I don't think that's how most tourists think.

Posted 28 June 2017, 5:20 a.m. Suggest removal

ashley14 says...

If one negative thing happens to a tourist, it hurts the cruise lines sales for a period of time. People forget, but it takes a while. They really don't think about the crime here at home or how many millions of people go without incident. People see only what they choose to see. It's just the way it is and probably won't change.

Posted 28 June 2017, 5:24 a.m. Suggest removal

ashley14 says...

One last opinion of mine, good right. :) Cuba isn't a threat to Bahamas Tourism. I don't know any American's that have any desire to visit Cuba. We've been taught all of our live how bad Cuba's Communist Government is to their people. Our generation won't forget what all they have done, maybe in many, many years. They have and are changing our history books. The next generation won't have the knowledge that we do. I wouldn't worry about Cuba on the short term.

Posted 28 June 2017, 5:29 a.m. Suggest removal

ashley14 says...

It' been about two years ago that I came into Grand Bahama and Nassau on a cruise ship. In Grand Bahama the taxi's and buses took the tourist only thru the nice parts of town. I only knew this because I know the Island pretty well. I talked to the driver about the good ole days and shared some awesome memories. The government knows what attracts the tourists. This isn't new information. When we got to Nassau the cruise ship warned the tourists to beware of the crime in the area. Some tourist didn't even get off the ship. After that most tourists when looking at cruises wouldn't choose a cruise coming to that location. Not meant to be hurtful it's part of what is happening. The cruise lines solution I guess is to go somewhere else. By the way their private island is a joke. It isn't even a nice beach. They have set up a small straw market, and they feed you. They bring it all over on a small boat. It's not a true Island experience.

Posted 28 June 2017, 5:42 a.m. Suggest removal

Porcupine says...

I agree with the overall thrust of the editorial.
However, this idea of privatization as the panacea of all our ills needs to be put to rest.
A business is a business. The only thing privatization does is to raise prices. A group of qualified managers hired to do their job, whether for the public or private sector, can be effective. If we had politicians who could, for once, look out for the good of their country, instead of simply enriching themselves, we may get somewhere.
Look ar BTC. One of our very few cash cows. We privatized 49% of the profits, gave up our controlling interest, maintained the same management, for what?
Did anyone notice any better service once Cable and Wireless got a piece of the pie?
I didn't.
But, the deal was very profitable for those involved in the privatization.
Bonuses, stock options, all those at the top took their piece.
To me, these monies should have been plowed back into the capital requirements of modernizing and maintaining what is now an absolutely necessary service to the people and businesses of The Bahamas. Why was there a need to privatize if it was a profitable company that could help the country grow?
Why give up controlling interest?
How does this fit in with democracy?
It doesn't.
Likewise, good publicly owned companies can provide substantial revenue to drive further Bahamian development, for Bahamians, instead of lining the pockets of those who care only about the money, not us as a people.
Not to mention the increasing need for loans to finance infrastructure, public services and social services.
We have had it all wrong.
Look around the world.
Are these collapses of societies an accident?
I would maintain they are not.
Train our own people, encouraging our youth who have been educated abroad to come home. Promise them good jobs when they come home.
Own our own companies.
Keep our own national natural resources like aragonite in the public domain, etc.
Quit saying that privatization is the way to go.
It isn't. And, the results of this nonsense are all around us.
Start hanging some of our corrupt politicians who have to get a cut of everything and steal you and I blind.
Quit listening to these slick promoters of privatization like those at BTC.
We got screwed on that deal. What Mr. Williams, the CEO of BTC won't tell you is how he is making out like a bandit, while the average Bahamian can't scrape two nickels together. Just because someone says they are Bahamian and looking out for Bahamians, doesn't necessarily mean that they aren't looking out for themselves, first and foremost.
Privatization has not proven to be any more efficient at running a business than the public sector. They are just more greedy and it raises the costs for everyone so that a handful can get rich on the "deal". Yes, the "deal". Sound familiar?

Posted 28 June 2017, 10:02 a.m. Suggest removal

ashley14 says...

HOPE AND CHANGE! President Obama's favorite line! Give the youth in the Islands Hope and Change and you'll see everything change!

Posted 28 June 2017, 10:11 a.m. Suggest removal

sheeprunner12 says...

Ashley14 ............. it is so funny reading your opinions on how we do cruise tourism on this side of the world .......... as compared to the Pacific ......... It cannot be a colour thing because the Polynesians are black ......... Maybe it is a Negro thing ............. Cruise ships are not our friends

Posted 28 June 2017, 5:07 p.m. Suggest removal

ashley14 says...

sheeprunner12... you asked me what I thought. why take it to racism? that is not what I said at all. your 100% correct that cruise ships are not your friends. they have made it so cheap to travel that its hard to compete with and they are financially only worried about their pockets. I apologize if I offended you, that is not who I am.

Posted 29 June 2017, 6:38 a.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment