Doctor voices health fears over landfill fires

By NICO SCAVELLA

Tribune Staff Reporter

nscavella@tribunemedia.net

A BAHAMIAN physician on Friday called for an "urgent" resolution to the recurrent fires that have plagued the New Providence landfill, charging that residents inhaling "God knows what" on a consistent basis can "gravely" affect their susceptibility to developing chronic obstructive pulmonary disorders in the long term. 

Dr Arlington Lightbourne, owner of the Nassau Wellness Clinic, told The Tribune that he is "very concerned" about the effects the recurrent dump fires can have and in some cases has had on residents in the nearby communities, claiming that air pollution of this kind is "a huge risk factor" for cancer and other chronic disorders. 

He noted that the recurrent fires pose a "particular" risk to children and the elderly as he said those individuals have "diminished lung functions".

Dr Lightbourne also expressed concerns over the various carcinogens that may be contained in the smoke emanating from the site during a fire, adding that because "we don't know what's burning" there is no real way "to say what's going to happen in 10 to 15 years and what happens when somebody is diagnosed with some cancer that is likely linked to the recurrent exposure" to the fires. 

He called for government officials to either move residents from communities affected the most by the fires, relocate the dump, or "change the way we manage the dump".

On Sunday, a massive blaze broke out at the Harold Road site, blanketing nearby communities such as Jubilee Gardens in thick, black hazardous smoke and forcing residents in that community to evacuate their homes. 

Asides from the immediate threat Sunday's fire posed to residents however, Dr Lightbourne lamented the affects the toxic makeup of the smoke emanating from the dump site could have on those inhaling it, particularly for an extended period of time. 

As previously noted by local senior physicians, because all manner of waste is deposited on the dump - medical, agricultural, industrial and domestic and otherwise - residents are likely have no idea exactly what they are inhaling when the dump begins to burn. 

"I've been saying there are obviously short-term implications associated with increased risk of respiratory conditions and aggravation of respiratory conditions such as asthma," Dr Lightbourne said. "There is obviously the risk of developing chronic obstructive disorders. 

"But there's a particular risk to children and the elderly who have diminished lung functions, people who are sick in general who obviously have diminished lung functions. 

"My greatest concerns though are the long-term implications because we don't know what's burning. We take 25,000 breaths in a 24-hour period and you're being exposed to God knows what in that time. And who's to say what's going to happen in 10 to 15 years and what happens when somebody is diagnosed with some cancer that is likely linked to the recurrent exposure to the carcinogens in that dump, because it's not like its a one-time thing. 

He added: "This is a recurrent problem. And children and the elderly and anybody in that nearby vicinity are going to be gravely affected by it. Not everybody in the same way but there's no doubt indoor air pollution, air pollution in general is a huge risk factor for cancers amongst other things. So it's something that the community needs to be very concerned about. 

"We either need to move the people from the community, we need to move the dump or we need to change the way we manage the dump. But something has to be done urgently. To me it's one of the biggest issues affecting this country right now." 

Dr Lightbourne also told The Tribune that he has seen patients expressing health concerns due to the dump fires, adding to his apprehension to the effects of the recurrent blazes. 

"Of course, people are concerned about their health, and we do get patients who present with symptoms related to smoke inhalation and toxic inhalation and people who are just generally concerned about the long term implications of these issues on their health, especially on their children," he said. 

"We've had a few patients that have come and said some things and expressed that they were ill again. Not a very large number, but we've had some people. And again my concern is for the immediate effect but mostly for long term effects, and that's what concerns me as a physician."

When asked to give a list of some illnesses and/or ailments persons may begin to experience as a result of continue smoke inhalation, Dr Lightbourne said: "The main ones there are things like adult onset asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disorders like emphysema and chronic bronchitis and cancers. Cancers of the throat and the lung. Something called pulmonary fibrosis which is essentially scarring of the lung tissue because of exposure to something that's causing inflammation to the lungs, like smoke, like heat. 

"These are all possible evidenced-based complications that can be linked to these fires." 

On Wednesday, Environment Minister Kendred Dorsett said there is no definite date set for when Jubilee Gardens residents will be able to return to their homes. Initially, officials said people would have to wait five to seven days.

Comments

John says...

Any Jackass could see the amount of hurricane debris they was piling up on that site along with the regular garbage was leading to disaster. Especially since it was not properly managed.not a matter of 'if' ' but a matter of 'when'. Truth is time for Bahamians to stop playing partisan politics with national issues such as this and put heads together and try find some solution. We let foreign criminals come here with empty bags and promises too good to be true and hood wink and bamboozle an entire nation ago

Posted 10 March 2017, 9:50 p.m. Suggest removal

killemwitdakno says...

This happens every year around this time. It's dry. They do nothing to prevent it. Who's watching the damn place? No way it gets that big the first few hours.

Posted 11 March 2017, 12:29 a.m. Suggest removal

Well_mudda_take_sic says...

The foreign investors and foreign consultants are lured here by the Crooked Christie-led corrupt PLP government so that they can be either squeezed for bribes or fleeced out of a good portion of the funds they receive under lucrutative contracts, leaving us with an empty public treasury and/or additional national debt. It has become the standard 'business model' by which Crooked Christie and his elitist political friends and cronies have greatly enriched themselves!

Posted 11 March 2017, 3:03 a.m. Suggest removal

concernedcitizen says...

They also "over pay " the foreign consultants that are in on the game so our crooked politicians can have funds/homes/condos abroad ..Remember all the gaming consultants we brought in ,,just another way to loot our treasury

Posted 11 March 2017, 9:21 a.m. Suggest removal

Reality_Check says...

I must applaud Dr. Arlington Lightbourne for speaking out on the very real health risks associated with prolonged exposure to the toxic smoke from the dump fires. It is frankly very disappointing that many more of our country's physicians have not done likewise. Perry Christie, his cabinet ministers, his puppet AG and Leslie Miller are all literally responsible for the illnesses, serious ailments and pre-mature deaths (both past and future deaths) of thousands and thousands of Bahamians who have been repeatedly exposed over many years to highly toxic fumes from frequent dump fires. It is Christie's puppet AG - Allyson Maynard-Gibson - who is instrumental in preventing those individuals whose lives have been destroyed by these dump fires from seeking and obtaining legal redress in our courts. Some health and life insurers are already taking the position they should not be held liable for claims made as a result of sickness or death that may be attributed to repeated instances of the insured being exposed to such highly toxic fumes. Insurers aggressively avoid paying out claims and death benefits if they can find (in the fine print of the policies they issue) a convenient reason for not having to do so. Therefore, for those who have lived for many years in any of the communities affected most by the dump fires, chances are their life and/or health insurance policies may no longer be worth the paper they are written on.

Posted 11 March 2017, 3:47 a.m. Suggest removal

Porcupine says...

Should we literally "hold dey feet ta da fire"?
I say this administration should be put out to pasture.
As close to the fire as possible.

Posted 11 March 2017, 6:48 a.m. Suggest removal

John says...

The whole entire island is covered in smoke now except for the East

Posted 11 March 2017, 9:17 a.m. Suggest removal

Emac says...

Oh it's in the East now, as far as Winton!

Posted 11 March 2017, 2:32 p.m. Suggest removal

yari says...

We had the smoke out east. I could not breathe on Saturday, Sunday was not as bad and the smoke had visibility limited to a few feet.

Posted 13 March 2017, 4:30 p.m. Suggest removal

TalRussell says...

Comrade Dr. Lightbourne, residents becoming sick from Nassau's fires is not something we are just suddenly learning. It's been clear from the days "Dud" Maynard was given the garbage contract during the Pindling governing administration that residents still around in 2017 from back then can clearly “remembers” stories about how we Nassau dump does mess with residents health.
I mean, how many more millions will taxpayers be called upon to spend and borrow under promises from government that finally the politicians are committed to improve the dumps health hazards?
It's the same damn bunch of politicians in power and in opposition who are of the same mentality as those from the past who are making such new promises. Perry, Minnis and Bran, are all in some form or fashion connected to the political hipbones from the past days.

Posted 11 March 2017, 9:44 a.m. Suggest removal

Socrates says...

the more things change, the more they remain the same... remember Marathon? didn't give a s*#t then, couldn't give a s**t now...

Posted 13 March 2017, 12:13 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment