Wednesday, March 29, 2017
By RASHAD ROLLE
Tribune Staff Reporter
rrolle@tribunemedia.net
HER nose and mouth covered by a protective face mask, Iyanda Hilton wrapped herself in a warm blanket and rested alongside her mother in the Bone Marrow Centre at the Holtz Children’s Hospital in Miami, Florida.
On March 20, after 12 years of suffering, she was about to have a potentially life-changing bone marrow transplant that was years in the making.
After an acute chest syndrome in 2014 placed her in the Intensive Care Unit at Doctors Hospital for several days, her parents, Ian and Yolanda Hilton, realised she needed urgent attention and they pursued the transplant as the primary remedy for curing her sickle cell anemia.
The 12-year-old girl’s team of medical professionals greeted her anxious parents one-by-one on the morning of the planned procedure, offering comfort and words of encouragement.
But it all proved futile. Iyanda never received the transplant.
On March 20, when Sanus Health Corporation - a third-party administrator that processes claims for Colina Insurance Limited - sent the hospital a sheet pre-authorising the $500,000 treatment, it indicated that it would not pay for a preparatory drug called Compath.
According to Ms Hilton, the hospital responded that it would use an alternative drug instead and asked the insurance company if that would be covered.
“Sanus then told them they would send them a letter of some sort,” Ms Hilton claimed in an interview with The Tribune.
For eight hours the Hiltons waited in the Florida hospital for a letter that never arrived.
Rather than let Iyanda spend the day in the hospital at a cost of $4,000, the hospital instructed the family to leave the treatment centre and to return only when an update from the insurance company was received.
“The doctors and medical professionals lined the halls of the hospital as we left,” Ms Hilton told The Tribune yesterday, describing overwhelming feelings of embarrassment. “They told us they’ve never seen anything like this before.”
The frustrated mother returned to New Providence three days later for a meeting she said was arranged by Colina.
It was then that the parents received information that still leaves them angry and shocked: Iyanda’s treatment would not be covered by their insurance policy.
“Colina told me that there’s a cap of $250,000 for people with congenital diseases,” she claimed. “My question is, if this is the case, why did they give us all the prior authorisations every step of the way, allowing us to get to this point where we were literally in the treatment centre and my daughter had already been admitted?”
Insurance companies are not obliged to provide coverage outside the terms stipulated in their contracts with clients.
But Ms Hilton said Colina authorised her daughter’s treatment after extensive reviews, only to deny coverage to Iyanda on the very day her procedure was set to begin.
She said: “How could you do your due diligence, tell us all the way through that the treatment has been authorised, and then deny us the coverage minutes before the treatment was to begin?”
Documents obtained by The Tribune show that the insurance company appeared to provide prior authorisation for the treatment, although the company noted in the fine print that “authorisation is not a guarantee of payment”.
On March 17, a Jackson Memorial Hospital international patient co-ordinator sent an “urgent” email to a representative of Sanus Health seeking confirmation that the insurance company would authorise the procedure.
“Everything is scheduled for the admission (of Iyanda) on Monday,” the co-ordinator wrote.
Noting that Iyanda was advised to be at the hospital at 10am on March 20, the co-ordinator requested that the authorisation process for her be expedited so she would not be “held at (point of service) due to non-financial clearance”.
In a subsequent email sent an hour and a half later, the Sanus Health representative wrote back saying the case had been approved.
She included in the email an authorisation number for the case and said admission of Iyanda would be covered at 100 per cent, requiring just a $500 co-pay.
Why Iyanda was later denied coverage is unclear.
In a statement to The Tribune yesterday, Colina did not respond directly to questions about the issue.
“Colina Insurance Limited advises the media and the public that it is the company’s policy, and out of the utmost respect for its clients, to maintain the privacy of its insured,” the company said in a statement. “As such Colina will not disclose any personal information regarding the insured, his or her medical history, or medical coverage to the media.
“In all cases, the insured and the insurer are both bound by a policy agreement. Colina will continue to work with its clients to provide the best care and coverage within the confines of each policy agreement.”
The Hiltons have not given up hope that their daughter will be given treatment, and Iyanda remains in Miami while the family hopes to reverse the insurance company’s decision.
In the meantime, they have started a GoFundMe page for Iyanda’s treatment: www.gofundme.com/IyandaHilton.
Asked if they will seek legal remedies, Ms Hilton said she is uncertain.
“I don’t want to spend $1 on an attorney,” she said. “All the money I have or that persons could support us with in this effort needs to go towards my child. I don’t wish to fight with anybody. All I want is for my child is to receive the procedures she needs.”
Comments
Well_mudda_take_sic says...
The Greek who has a majority controlling interest in Colina through his family trusts has a standing policy that all health and life insurance claims above a certain amount be referred directly to his law firm for "extreme" vetting. His lackey lawyers within his law firm happily do their master's bidding, thereby ensuring Colina pays out the absolute minimum amount possible on claims arising from the health and life insurance policies that it issues. The Greek has been known to joke that Colina has a distinct advantage over its insured clientele when it comes to legal costs associated with disputes involving denied claims. It is a shame that the Greek must always be shamed into thinking about doing the right thing, but he nevertheless seems to prefer earning higher profits over being shamed.
Posted 29 March 2017, 12:36 p.m. Suggest removal
Sickened says...
I would have to also assume that they would be reluctant to pay out for life insurance as well. I would have to think that their license would be scrutinized by authorities after this EXTREMELY embarrassing and disturbing report.
Posted 29 March 2017, 3:29 p.m. Suggest removal
Greentea says...
you "would think" but we don't live in a normal society where "thinking" is valued, where embarrassment produces shame and where licenses in the face of a case of this are scrutinized independently. Insurance is nothing but a 'respectable' mafia style shakedown in the Bahamas. Whoever called this one in is a heartless money grubbing hack and needs to rot in the warm folds of the devil's rear.
Posted 29 March 2017, 4 p.m. Suggest removal
Cobalt says...
This story is grossly upsetting.
God help you if you get sick in the Bahamas.
Posted 29 March 2017, 3:59 p.m. Suggest removal
Stapedius says...
This is upsetting and quite frankly disgusting. No issue with the insurance company having it's policy. But why put the child and her family on this roller coaster? They spent money to travel and plan and in the end the insurance company skirts away with no penalty. I'm no fan of NHI, because I believe that government should not be in business. The government serves a regulatory function. Something which seems to be lost on our moronic politicians. Clico, Colina and the rest get away with too much nonsense and there is no recourse or compensation.
Posted 29 March 2017, 4:46 p.m. Suggest removal
WOW2016 says...
It is my prayer that this family gets a good lawyer and sue Colina not only for the cost of the treatment but the inconvenience and embarrassment (emotional stress). This company has raped and robbed the Bahamian people for too long. Always raising premiums and never wanting to pay out claims. Always having some song and dance. I cry shame. I hope a lawyer is reading who will take this case pro-bono. We are talking about a young life. There is always recourse. Someone, please come to the aid of this family.
Posted 29 March 2017, 5:17 p.m. Suggest removal
Sickened says...
In a civilized country Colina would be getting sued for 10 times what they should have, AND PROMISED TO, pay. If this poor child dies as a result of Colina's policy we should all cancel any business we may do with Colina and any affiliated firm or person.
Posted 30 March 2017, 9:14 a.m. Suggest removal
Honestman says...
Disgusting performance by COLINA.
Posted 30 March 2017, 8:24 a.m. Suggest removal
ashley14 says...
Praying for this family. This story needs to stay in the news, and a go fund me account should be started for this little girl. If made known wide spread in Fla. this money could probably be raised quickly. There are a lot of people with compassion for others still out there. It also would bring attention to how this family has been treated by the insurance company.
Posted 30 March 2017, 10:39 a.m. Suggest removal
JusticeforIyanda says...
www.gofundme.com/IyandaHilton.
Posted 30 March 2017, 11:04 a.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment