Friday, June 29, 2018
By RICARDO WELLS
Tribune Staff Reporter
rwells@tribunemedia.net
THE reported reclassification of foreign labourers at The Pointe has been condemned as “disingenuous” by Bahamas Contractors Association President Leonard Sands.
Mr Sands, a one-time candidate for the governing Free National Movement, yesterday said he had no intentions of “picking a fight” over the issue, but implored his former political contemporaries “to do right by the people” and ensure more Bahamians are employed at the site.
“If you are saying workers at The Pointe are now laying blocks and doing finish work, there is no way you can say Bahamians aren’t skilled in those fields,” he said.
“You are being disingenuous when you say that these persons are doing work Bahamians are known to do, all while hiding behind the argument that (foreign labourers) were being brought in to do tasks our people can’t.”
Mr Sands’ comments came yesterday in response to Immigration Minister Brent Symonette’s indication that foreign labourers at the project were reclassified as semi-skilled and skilled labourers in recent weeks.
Those comments by Mr Symonette were made, in part, to clarify comments made by Attorney General Carl Bethel in the Senate on Monday.
During the sitting, Mr Bethel said he observed foreigners doing jobs they were not needed for.
Mr Bethel told the Senate: “When the minister of labour first raised this issue of employment at The Pointe hotel, the answer that was given back is the kind of work being done was not the kind of work Bahamians were either skilled at or wished to do. That was my best understanding of it and that when they got to the stage of laying blocks and all the finishing work that was necessary, this is when more Bahamians would be taken on.”
Mr Bethel, who insisted he saw the labourers first-hand, added: “… I see that (foreign labourers) laying blocks there and I don’t see no Bahamians working there so that is unacceptable.”
He continued: “I immediately called my colleague and he promised to get cracking on it and I trust that good sense is going to prevail because there is no way on God’s good earth that we need to have any foreigners lay blocks in the Bahamas. If it’s one thing Bahamians can do, it’s lay blocks and it is time for that foolishness to stop. There is no way you can have a job in the Bahamas and Bahamians can’t work on it.”
In response on Tuesday, Mr Symonette explained: “I noticed this morning that I think the attorney general had made comments on the question on seeing people laying blocks.
“With regard to The Pointe, there have been applications processed in the initial phase. They were for labourers.
“The Ministry of Labour met with China State Construction and we sorted that issue out and the labourers have been reclassified in the appropriate work class section and paying the increased fees that relate to semi-skilled or skilled labourers.”
The heads of agreement between China Construction America, a subsidiary of China State Construction, and the government states 70 percent of the workers are supposed to be Bahamian and 30 percent should be foreign.
The Department of Labour found in May a disproportionate number of foreign workers to Bahamian workers at the downtown project.
At the time, there were 73 foreign workers and 24 Bahamians working on the site.
Despite this, Labour Minister Dion Foulkes said the developers were not in breach of the agreement.
Meanwhile, addressing the entire scope of the development yesterday Mr Sands stressed more communication with local contractors is needed.
“If there was communication with any minister and it was disclosed that the project had moved to the point that we are now hearing about, Bahamian workers should have been made aware of it.
“(The minister of labour) should have advised us that they were at a stage where they could engage Bahamians workers, I would have thought the minister would have reached out to us. He has my number.
“The BCA would have been more than happy to get things rolling in a direction where Bahamian contractors could get on that site and where Bahamian labourers could have been out there,” he added.
In both January and February, this newspaper observed workers on the site. Dozens of Chinese builders walked to the site every day from a building, which lodges the workers opposite the development, and no Bahamians were anywhere to be seen.
Comments
sealice says...
Of course any Bahamian could - first of all the average bahamian is taller and looks at least a hellalot stronger then the chingrets and secondly if the chingrets say we aren't qualified to do the work well then hell with it the chingrets gotta train all the Bahamians that are going to work on the site before they can move the first shovel of dirt...... if you wanna come and help the country please do.... building another hotel that will fail using all foreign labour sucking all the money out of the country does not....
Posted 29 June 2018, 11:25 a.m. Suggest removal
happyfly says...
They need to enshrine it in the constitution that NO ONE....no crooked corrupt politician, no self-serving developer or anyone else is allowed to hire more than 'X' percent on any construction project. It doesn't matter if it's 20% of 75% so long as everyone understands what it is and are playing by the same rules. The fact that the Chinese were able to negotiate zero Bahamians and the next developer has to hire 100% Bahamians is complete BS and this kind of inconsistent, arbitrary pandering to the most corrupt bidder is holding the entire country up
Posted 29 June 2018, 3:37 p.m. Suggest removal
BahamaLlama says...
Why can't Bahamians understand the free market?
You don't get to be protected from market forces; you have to compete to provide a BETTER and CHEAPER service. The laborers are cheaper, and almost certainly work harder - like the Haitians here employed by Bahamians.
There is absolutely NO justification whatsoever for a government to enforce equity quotas. That's an appallingly immoral philosophy for which the end result - taken to its eventual conclusion - ends up murderous. What are you going to do to enforce the quota? Arrest people? Take away the money they've earned? Ban more qualified or cheaper people?
Clearly the developers aren't impressed with the local market. Fix that before you suggest nanny government intervention.
Posted 29 June 2018, 5:10 p.m. Suggest removal
sheeprunner12 says...
Yes ........ the Bahamian worker can do the work ............ But, the Chinese get to demand what happens with their money and investments.
Lesson learnt .......... You can only control what you own .......... Bahamians do not own the tourist industry in our country ........ We are (for the most part) simply hired labour and disposable workers.
Posted 29 June 2018, 7:34 p.m. Suggest removal
realfreethinker says...
for all of y'all who talk about Bahamians can do the work. I challenge anyone of you to find 20 skilled "Bahamian" masons. In case you didn't notice the Jamaicans and Hatians dominate that field in the Bahamas.
Posted 30 June 2018, 8:54 a.m. Suggest removal
Chucky says...
Any Bahamian contractor or developer who given the opportunity to use the same Chinese labour over their current Bahamian labour would do so in a heartbeat.
It's Chinese money being spent on Chinese land. Who are we to say it's supposed to be our jobs.
Let a Bahamian buy the next project, then that company can staff with whoever lazy ass Bahamian they want
Posted 30 June 2018, 7 p.m. Suggest removal
sheeprunner12 says...
True ........... Perfect investment for the Numbers Cartel ....... before they get taxed into oblivion .............. BOL
Let them build a string of boutique hotels across the Out Islands and then we won't need the Americans, Jamaicans, French, Chinese etc. to control our Out Island tourist economy ........ smh
Posted 1 July 2018, 10:19 a.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment