Thursday, May 24, 2018
UPDATE: Delvin Major, head of the Air Accident Investigation Department at the Department of Civil Aviation, has confirmed that Bahamasair pilots took “evasive action” Tuesday afternoon in an incident involving a Silver Airways plane – SEE FULL STORY HERE
By Rashad Rolle
Tribune Staff Reporter
rrolle@tribunemedia.net
AVIATION officials are investigating reports a BahamasAir jet averted a mid-flight collision with a Silver Airway plane on Tuesday afternoon.
BahamasAir flight BHS137 departed Nassau for Marsh Harbour, Abaco, around 5pm when, according to a pastor onboard the jet, a startling incident occurred.
Air Traffic Control, BahamasAir and Air Accident Investigation Department officials all said yesterday they received no report of the alleged incident but that they would now investigate the claim.
Up to press time last night, The Tribune received no response to questions sent to Silver Airways around noon.
Chief investigator of air accidents Delvin Major said if such an incident did occur, the law demands that it be reported. He said such an incident would be “very serious.’
The pastor who spoke to The Tribune requested anonymity to do so.
He said: “Trust me, had it not been for the skilfulness of BahamasAir pilots, the situation could have been fatal beyond a shadow of a doubt. I really want the matter to be reported and investigated but hats off to those BahamasAir pilots.”
The pastor said some 15 minutes into the flight the pilot signalled for passengers to fasten their seatbelts, causing him to grow concerned because there was no weather outside that he believed would cause turbulence.
“We started to go into a bit of a control dive,” he said, adding the dive never became frantic. “When I looked to the right, I saw a plane. I noticed the plane wasn’t going passed us but was coming toward us. The plane came so close I was able to make out the colour but I knew it wasn’t a Sky Bahamas or a Pineapple Airways plane, I just knew the purple colour which Silver planes have.”
“I said to my dad, a plane just like Sky passed by us but it ain’ Sky. I said ‘boy that fly close.’”
The man said after other passengers disembarked he stayed behind and spoke to the First Officer onboard.
“He shook his head and said ‘Boy, that was Silver’.
“He said apparently Nassau, Miami gave them missed coordinates. Many of the passengers, basically all of them did not know what was going on but I’m very alert when I’m flying.
“One of the guys who was with me, he was in the front part of the plane. He said he heard when an alarm went off in the cockpit but he didn’t know what was going on. I assume that was the radar telling them another plane was in close vicinity.”
The pastor said he was “alarmed” by the incident.
“I think something like that, it should be noted and the matter should be looked into. You cannot make those kind of errors in aviation. The day could have caused triple times more mourning than in the Andros situation so I definitely feel like they should be cautioned and some questions should be asked.”
In addition to Chief Investigator Mr Major, The Tribune spoke to BahamasAir’s Director of Safety Ashley Cooper and Bahamas Air Navigation Services Department (BANSD) Manager Keith Major yesterday. No one could verify the incident.
The pilot during the flight, a female, was off from work yesterday. Officials expect to quiz her today.
Last night Sky Bahamas CEO Randy Butler said if the claim is true, he hopes someone in the cockpit comes forward and speaks about it to aviation officials.
“If that happened the way he describe that, a lot of systems and people failed,” he said. “That’s something like, let’s check that system before the next flight so we have safety notices right away.”
Comments
Required says...
If the pilot made the anouncement for the seat belts and then started a controlled descent, and then the passengers saw the other plane... the pilot wasn't avoiding the other plane, his actions were causing the incident.
Posted 24 May 2018, 9:48 a.m. Suggest removal
licks2 says...
I don't know much about flying but I tend to "see" it as you say. . .a rapid decent should have left the other plane above the jet. . .decent then the other plane was heading for the jet may suggest that the other plane was below the jet. . .the jet descended into the flight path of the other plane!
Posted 24 May 2018, 11:55 a.m. Suggest removal
Spectrum87 says...
Always not following proper protocols as soon as they hit The Bahamas Air space careless ! they must think think its the streets, on the ramp speeding up to the gate reckless. This too will also be swept under the mat.
Posted 24 May 2018, 12:11 p.m. Suggest removal
fullfilled says...
I am a commercial pilot flying Sky Bahamas into and out of Cat Island several times a year. I hhave noticed Bahamian airline pilots fly through clouds while flying VFR. That is against the rules. This has been going on for years. One does not dive into the path of another airliner. Hopefully an accident reporting or the aviation authority can get to the bottom of this. Will have to interview the Silver Air pilots to get their interpretation. The Bahamian controllers are a very cautious crowd and do not let planes get too close like we do in the U.S.
Posted 24 May 2018, 12:58 p.m. Suggest removal
proudloudandfnm says...
Obviously their TCA alarm went off so they took immediate evasive action. Silver's TCA went off at the same time and they took evasive action. Both dived narrowly missing one another. Were they below the line where Bahamas air traffic controls or were they above the line where US controls traffic. Seems to be an air traffic control issue.
Posted 24 May 2018, 1:13 p.m. Suggest removal
proudloudandfnm says...
Ok pilot freibd says TCA tells one plane to dive and the other to climb. This incident was just that close..
Posted 24 May 2018, 1:32 p.m. Suggest removal
DDK says...
Truly amazing that the incident was not reported as soon as both of the aircraft returned to their respective bases, if not sooner.
Posted 24 May 2018, 1:43 p.m. Suggest removal
avidreader says...
A lot of speculation here. The TCAS system in the cockpit is supposed to provide early warning of other traffic within a radius of 40 nautical miles and within an envelope of 9,500 feet of altitude above and below the aircraft.
Audible warnings of "traffic, traffic", "descend", "increase climb", "clear of conflict", etc., will be provided by the system.
After the mid air collision between the DHL cargo flight and the Russian airliner carrying children to a holiday in Spain occurred above the German/Swiss border in 2001 the ruling was made for the crews to obey the commands emanating from their TCAS and to ignore instructions from the ground controller. As to what happened on Tuesday, that has yet to be clarified.
Posted 24 May 2018, 5:23 p.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment