Tuesday, April 9, 2019
By RASHAD ROLLE
Tribune Staff Reporter
rrolle@tribunemedia.net
A NEAR mid-air collision between two planes at the Lynden Pindling International Airport in September resulted in the suspension of a pilot and an air traffic controller, a new report by the Air Accident Investigation Department details.
Two planes simultaneously departed the same runway around 7am on September 22, 2018. It is not clear how close the planes came to contact, but investigators said the seriousness of two planes heading towards one another from opposite ends of the same runway “cannot be understated”.
One of the planes, a C6-JEF Piper Aztec, was operated and owned by a 53-year-old private operator. It was headed to the Berry Islands with just the pilot onboard. The other aircraft, a Western Air turbo-prob aircraft, C6-KID, was headed to Grand Bahama with 25 passengers.
The chief cause of the near collision was the C6-JEF pilot’s defiance of an air traffic control order –– the pilot departed from the wrong runway and later told investigators he forgot to follow the correct instructions despite previously acknowledging them. The crew of the plane carrying 25 people did not realise another aircraft had taken off towards them until it had passed directly overhead. Even though the pilot of the C6-JEF failed to obey air traffic control orders, it is “still incumbent on all pilots entering an active runway to be cognizant and vigilant of traffic that may be crossing a runway, exiting a runway or in this case departing from a runway,” investigators emphasized.
The AAID said: “The poor decision making exercised by the pilot of aircraft C6-JEF in not following directions by ATC, despite advising he understood the instructions given, has been determined as the probable cause of the near mid-air collision; also contributing to this near mid-air collision was the actions of the air traffic controller by losing visual on the aircraft he issued instructions to, and the failure on the part of the crew of C6-KID for not observing that another aircraft was on the same runway at the same time before commencing their take-off roll; the AAID believes this loss of visual contact on the aircraft by the controller may have been as a result of distraction due to the ongoing shift change at the time, and the fact that the controller was manning two separate radio frequencies during a time of high traffic volume while using a system that required additional training and frequent data input so that all systems can function properly with adequate current information.
“The AAID also believes the failure to notice the aircraft by the crew of C6-KID may be the result of distractions or preoccupation with completing final checks while on the runway, before takeoff; pilot training, qualification and air traffic controller training, licensing and record keeping practices have been investigated and while not directly contributing to the incident, were noteworthy and required action.”
The AAID found that the air traffic controller had an expired medical certificate and no ATC licence. It found that the Bahamas Air Navigation Services Division (BANSD) lacked a documented process to track the medical status of air traffic controllers, that no ATC personnel had required ATC licences and that several ATC personnel were operating without the required current medical certificates.
On October 8, 2018, the BANSD formed a three-member internal review board to review the incident. The board concluded the primary reason for the incident was the wrong action taken by the pilot of CJ-JEF, but it also concluded that the controller contributed to the incident. The board drafted 14 recommendations to address “systemic internal deficiencies” within the air traffic system, but those sensitive recommendations were not included in the AAID report.
The AAID asked the Bahamas Civil Aviation Authority to re-examine the C6-JEF pilot “for his competence to hold a Bahamas issued pilot licence.” It also recommended that the pilot be re-assessed for medical fitness. The pilot was re-examined and while the results of his pilot test were satisfactory, his licence was suspended pending a medical assessment. There were issues concerning his medical capacity.
The AAID also recommended that controllers face more frequent and structured refresher classes, noting the controller involved in the incident underwent no refresher course since 2007. The controller was subsequently removed from active duty and underwent re-qualification training. He was then subjected to a period of supervised oversight. The AAID recommended that BANSD address its manpower shortage issues.
By the time the investigation report was finalised, the BANSD had still not ensured ATC personnel had required licences, nor was any process of record keeping or tracking provided to address identified shortcomings, the AAID said.
Comments
Well_mudda_take_sic says...
The AAID itself is possibly worthy of severe criticism for having taken so long to compile and release its final report on the systemic factors contributing to the incident. Unless immediate corrective action was taken with respect to the serious ATC deficiencies, as and when identified during the investigation, then the lives of passengers and crews flying into and out of LPIA over the last 6 months were unnecessarily put at grave risk. The ATC at LPIA seems to have gone the way of our General Post Office, and that's truly very scary!
Posted 9 April 2019, 8:43 a.m. Suggest removal
Gotoutintime says...
Flying in and out of Nassau these days is a serious crap-shoot--One day there is going to be a disaster!
Posted 9 April 2019, 9:05 a.m. Suggest removal
DDK says...
"The AAID found that the air traffic controller had an expired medical certificate and no ATC licence." Is that in itself not taking Bahamian slackness to a shocking level?
"By the time the investigation report was finalised, the BANSD had still not ensured ATC personnel had required licences, nor was any process of record keeping or tracking provided to address identified shortcomings, the AAID said." AND NOW, Mr. Minister of Transport????
Posted 9 April 2019, 10:27 a.m. Suggest removal
Well_mudda_take_sic says...
It seems both Renward Wells (Minister of Transportation) and D'Aguilar (Minister of Tourism and Aviation) are waiting on a serious accident involving the loss of lives (airline passengers\tourists\crew) before they come forward to explain what the government has already done and has yet to do in order to address the very serious matters contained in AAID's report. Not at all surprising given that these two cabinet ministers very much prefer devoting their time to wining and dining opportunities with foreign investors.
Posted 9 April 2019, 10:48 a.m. Suggest removal
DDK says...
Pretty sickening.........
Posted 9 April 2019, 4:08 p.m. Suggest removal
gbgal says...
Haven't these workers recently protested for increased wages and improved working conditions? While ignoring regulations and protocols? Let us pray...
Posted 9 April 2019, 10:53 a.m. Suggest removal
John says...
#The chief cause of the near collision was the C6-JEF pilot’s defiance of an air traffic control order –– the pilot departed from the wrong runway and later told investigators he forgot to follow the correct instructions despite previously acknowledging them.
The major cause of the mishap. No need to point fingers and play the facts. But at least define the word "DEFIANCE."
Posted 9 April 2019, 12:50 p.m. Suggest removal
Well_mudda_take_sic says...
You might not be concerned about unqualified, untrained and/or unlicensed ATC operators, but I can assure you most of the flying public and flight crews do not share your foolish bravado. Suggest you carefully read the article again in order to more fully appreciate the implications of the AAID's findings.
Posted 9 April 2019, 4:12 p.m. Suggest removal
John says...
"The chief cause of the near collision was the C6-JEF pilot’s defiance of an air traffic control order" – WHAT PART OF THIS YOU DON'T UNDERSTAND?
Posted 9 April 2019, 6:36 p.m. Suggest removal
Economist says...
And The Bahamas wants to control its airspace.
This is why most airlines are against us doing so.
Posted 9 April 2019, 2:24 p.m. Suggest removal
John says...
But in the US, someone stole an entire commercial aircraft, taxied down the runway, took off, then put on an air show that lasted over an hour and included flying the craft upside down..
.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_Hori…
Posted 9 April 2019, 3:38 p.m. Suggest removal
Well_mudda_take_sic says...
And Joe Blow committed murder in the U.S. last night so it must be okay for Tubby Bubba to commit murder in the Bahamas tonight. Your type of logic and tit for tat mentality leaves much to be desired John. LMAO
Posted 9 April 2019, 4:17 p.m. Suggest removal
John says...
Your rationale is again seeped in ignorance. The reason for the near miss was because the spoiled, little white pilot didn't think he needed to follow instructions from lll black air traffic controllers in da islands. So he became defiant , arrogant even, and decided to take off from the wrong end of the runway despite being ordered not to do so, almost crashing and causing numerous deaths of innocent people and now you try to paint your usual different and distorted picture.
Posted 9 April 2019, 6:31 p.m. Suggest removal
Dawes says...
Whilst i agree it sounds like that pilot is to blame and he should be banned for life, how do you know he is white? Are you just assuming that he is to fit your own prejudices? There are plenty pilots who are black or do you not think that possible,
Posted 10 April 2019, 9:54 a.m. Suggest removal
bogart says...
AS AIRLIFTS INCREASE...MORE AIR TRAFFIC....BIGGER AIRCRAFT...FASTER AIRCRAFTS....WAY PAST DUE .......TO ELIMINATE SLACKNESS..NOTCERTIFIED...AIRCRAFTS ...ROGUE PILOTS...HACKERS.....!!!!!!!!!!....
Posted 9 April 2019, 5:42 p.m. Suggest removal
John says...
self-flying planes, pilotless, robot air traffic controllers powered by artificial intelligence and see what happens with Boeing jets. One more fatal crash and Boeing will be bankrupt and probably out of business at least where the 737 max is concerned. Human error and human defiance. Human pilots fighting computers in the cockpit and the end result is tragic loss of life.
Posted 9 April 2019, 6:34 p.m. Suggest removal
Jetflt says...
INEXCUSABLE - by both the pilot of the twin Aztec and the ATC controller!!! No valid medical certs and no licenses for controllers. Imagine the lawsuits had those aircraft collided.
Posted 10 April 2019, 7:38 a.m. Suggest removal
atc says...
It's amazing hows there's just so much to say with very little known facts, based on the content of the comments read. For decades controllers have worked without licenses and or medicals, is it right, OF COURSE NOT! Certainly this is an indictment on the management aspect of the operation and not the fault of any one controller. When you are sick they want you to come to work, so figure it out!
I'm so tired of making the numbers work, pushing the envelope and going above and beyond for aviation tourism to work. Seems the easiest way to escape any situation is to cast the blame on those involved. How about we start by fixing the systematic underlying issues that have been plaguing this industry for decades. The airport is no longer able to handle the movements efficiently and effectively.
Posted 11 April 2019, 12:52 a.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment