Family desperate for body of woman, 29, to be returned to South Africa

By KHRISNA RUSSELL

Deputy Chief Reporter

krussell@tribunemedia.net

THE family of a South African woman who died in this county is said to be distraught and desperate to have her body repatriated home.

However, their efforts have so far proven fruitless.

The problem is 29-year-old Nobuhle Bhengu, pictured right, a MSC crew member, died in February from the highly infectious tuberculosis disease, a source intimately involved in the matter told The Tribune yesterday.

This was confirmed following an autopsy and health officials deemed it not prudent to embalm or transport the deceased woman without creating a public health risk.

Under such circumstances, a recommendation was made that cremation be carried out.

Health Minister Dr Duane Sands would not confirm any of these details yesterday, but said: “Health and foreign affairs (officials) have been engaged, transparent and sympathetic with the family.”

She had battled what appeared to be a misdiagnosed illness while on board the MSC Seaside and was advised to seek medical attention here at a local facility while the vessel was docked. Bhengu was consequently admitted to hospital for several days and died.

There is now a battle against the clock.

Her sister Mbali told South African media outlet News24 the death has affected her family, and that their grandmother had been admitted to hospital, seemingly failing to deal with the fact that she may never see her granddaughter again.

She said: “We are told that they want to cremate her, and that is really painful to hear knowing that you may never have a chance to say our last goodbyes.”

Mbali said when her sister left for her cruise assignment in July last year, she was healthy and was given a medical fitness certificate by a doctor.

“She told me that she fell sick in January, but said they only took her to the hospital in the Bahamas on February 8, where she died four days later.”

She said The Bahamas government told her family that it cannot repatriate her body because she was infected with TB, and it feared that the virus might spread to other people during the repatriation process.

“There has been no death certificate given to us, and now we ask ourselves questions as to whether there could be some foul play by the hospital, and would like to destroy some evidence by burning her body,” said Mbali. “Please bring our sister back, we loved her, and we just want her to be buried here at home,” she further told News24.

She said that one of her brothers has since come to The Bahamas, but has not been allowed to view the body, nor has he been told when he can view it.

“We don’t know if indeed it is her who died because they won’t even allow our family members to view her,” Mbali added.

MSC Cruises said they were “deeply saddened” by her death and expressed deepest condolences to her family and friends, the SA new station said.

“As soon as we became aware she had passed, we worked closely with the competent authorities in the Bahamas to facilitate any applicable procedures, and provided support to her family throughout the process.

“We have arranged flights for some close family members to grieve her loss and pay their respects,” the company said in a statement.

MSC said out of respect for the deceased and her family, and to honour her medical privacy, the company was unable to disclose any further details.

A woman claiming to have been Bhengu’s roommate on the ship has said on social media she went to onboard doctors for a month with no consistent treatment before she was too weak to walk for longer than five minutes. The woman further claimed Bhengu did not have TB, but was diagnosed with hemolytic anemia instead by ship doctors.

The SA high commissioner in Kingston, Jamaica, Lumka Yengeni, has requested the intervention of the Bahamian government through its foreign ministry, to put the cremation on hold.

A letter circulating on Facebook from Mr Yengeni to the funeral home allegedly holding Bhengu remains on March 5 has asked that nothing be done until there is a formal response from the Bahamas government.

“This letter serves to inform you that the South African High Commission in Kingston, Jamaica, with non-resident accreditation to the Bahamas has requested the intervention of the government of the Bahamas through its foreign ministry to put on hold the cremation of the mortal remains of Ms Nobuhle Ntombenhle Bhengu, which was a decision taken without the consent of the next of kin,” the letter read.

“The High Commission further wishes to convey that until a response has been received from the government of the Bahamas, you may not proceed with the cremation of the mortal remains of Ms Nobuhle Ntombenhle Bhengu.”

Comments

Giordano says...

It could be something wrong in terms of medical contradictions in this case,on one side at the cruise ship,medical doctors diagnosed hemolytic anemia and at land,in hospital,expressed that patient was misdiagnosed and TB came up instead,roommate says something important and with all of these medical malpractice taking place in The Bahamas,God be with the victim's family. According to this newspaper report,no body show to the family,no death certificate given to them and the clock ticking with a threat of cremation to erase any evidence of wrongdoing,according to the patient's family,
by local medical providers.
I smell a rat. Something is really wrong and somebody got to pay for it.

Posted 12 March 2019, 9:47 a.m. Suggest removal

Well_mudda_take_sic says...

Whatever is done here should not be at the cost of Bahamian taxpayers, except for the cost of cremation if need be. Our government should simply give the family members of the deceased and the South African government adequate notice that the body will be cremated by a date certain. Anyone know if the ship she was on at the time of the purported misdiagnosis of her illness is Bahamian registered?

Posted 12 March 2019, 11:22 a.m. Suggest removal

licks2 says...

So the Bahamas government maybe hiding something . . . or the ship did a skulduggery by not diagnosing TB? Now we must take the word of a ship worker. . .who can be innocently duped by the ship doctor. . .a ship who could not announced that a worker on board ship was diagnosed with TB. . .which would have resulted in ship board quarantine with no nation allowing docking for that cruise. . .nearly six thousand possible cases of TB infections. . .a disaster costing the company billions!!! That outcry would effectually shut down the whole operation for that shipping line. . . it would result in a world wide effort to contain the outbreak!! They may have "dumped her off" in the Bahamas to save themselves plenty problems and money.

The Bahamas cannot, according to international accords signed, allow that corps to re-enter the general population. . .the international protocol is to burn the body immediately!!

Whether the Bahamas is hiding anything is as simple as a mantoux test . . . it cannot tell what type the person has. . .but it can register positive for the virus. . .which don't develop in just 4 days. . .so if the test is positive, she brought it from the ship!!

So you Mr. who think the Bahamas hiding something. . .go do ya research and stop talking nonsense. . .

Posted 12 March 2019, 12:13 p.m. Suggest removal

geostorm says...

thank you @licks2! Sometimes we say the most ignorant things! Why would the Bahamas need to hide anything? In fact we deal with TB better than most countries in the world. With the number of illegal Haitian immigrants entering our shores and the fact that our prevalence rate is zero to none, that says a lot about our standards. The ship as @licks2 has said, has the most to lose.

If the corpse has to be burned then so be it. That's the standard. It's sad that the family has to endure this, but the Bahamas has to do what is necessary. One thing I know for sure, if its one thing we as a country know how to do well it is: prevent, diagnose and treat communicable diseases!

Posted 12 March 2019, 2:42 p.m. Suggest removal

ohdrap4 says...

it is sad those days that many govt institutions are not trusted in social media.

not that the africans care, they get on the plane with ebola and take it to other countries.

plus taking a body like taht will likely cost 30,000, why not just cremate?

Posted 12 March 2019, 3:36 p.m. Suggest removal

licks2 says...

The money is not the problem here. . .the ship company will pay for her family to come here for a funeral. . .they don't want to connect anything to their ship because of the "trouble" they will get into. . .EVERY PORT THEY WENT TO IN THE LAST MONTH OR SO WILL PENALIZE THEM. . . this is more serious. . .they want that body gone quick before that information get in the wrong ears. . .

Posted 12 March 2019, 6 p.m. Suggest removal

rosiepi says...

Having just read comments mocking a report by US Human Rights concerning corruption in The Bahamas to this, my head is reeling; for this appears to be a deliberate intervention by the gov't to aid a Bahamian co. in order to circumvent international (national?) laws, the ethical concerns arising from it's cavalier exposure of it's customers to employees infected with Tuberculosis!
The fact that there is no mention of any public health concerns, much less an investigation should be intolerable, instead it's just business as usual.
'Two students tested positive for TB in local schools'

Posted 14 March 2019, 4:07 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment