Electricity theft ‘fraud victims’ face big bills

By NEIL HARTNELL

Tribune Business Editor

nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

Multiple Grand Bahama businesses and residents could be “victims of a fraud” that may have cost the island’s sole electricity provider millions of dollars, it was revealed yesterday.

Grand Bahama Power Company, describing the alleged “energy saving devices” at the centre of its probe as “fake”, said the electricity cost reductions at premises where they had been installed were only achieved by bypassing or tampering with the meter.

And GB Power’s regulator, speaking out for the first time last night, said its own investigation had revealed that all the work and installations performed by the company selling these devices “was unpermitted” and “executed outside the scope of their licence”.

The Grand Bahama Port Authority (GBPA) urged homeowners and businesses to contact its Building and Development Services department if any so-called “energy cost saving devices” had been installed at their location so it could ensure the work was permitted and compliant with the building code.

Freeport’s quasi-governmental authority confirmed that GB Power contacted it after a recent meter audit revealed “a number of suspected electricity diversions at several businesses within the Port area”.

“As a result we immediately began our own independent investigation into this matter, which is currently ongoing,” the GBPA said. “Thus far, we can confirm that all of the work performed by the licensee [of the GBPA] was unpermitted, and was executed outside the scope of the licence.”

The controversy resulted in GB Power cutting supply to the Cooper family’s fast food franchises for almost an entire week (they were restored last night), while Sav Mor Drugs, the largest pharmaceutical services provider on Grand Bahama, was another to experience similar treatment and be forced to run on generators while the utility carried out its investigation.

Tribune Business knows who installed the “device” at the Coopers’ KFC, Burger King and Pollo Tropical franchises, but has chosen to withhold his name for the moment as numerous sources said he has “gone to ground” and cannot be located.

However, many of his clients are now faced with having to pay GB Power significant sums in compensation for electricity which they have used but not paid for as a result of his actions. While the businesses and homeowners involved may be blameless, Tribune Business was told that - under the Electricity Act and Freeport’s bye-laws - responsibility for paying up falls on them.

GB Power, in its statement yesterday, said some of the so-called “devices” were simply boxes containing wiring that did nothing at all, while purported capacitors were just boxes filled with sand and dirt. It produced photographic evidence of what it had uncovered.

“This makes the fraud even more unethical,” one energy source, speaking on condition of anonymity, told Tribune Business, “because these people were being sold a bag of fruit juice, magic fairy dust. There’s not even any electrics in it.”

Asked how much this could have cost GB Power, in terms of amount of unbilled electricity and the dollar value, the source said: “I would say it amounts to the millions, across the spectrum, especially if you have high-end people and wealthy second home owners using it in their homes.

“They’ve [the installers] been bypassing the meter box, and are in a heap of trouble. The businesses and residences could claim and feign ignorance, but they’re still going to be liable for the loss suffered by the Power Company because they were the beneficial recipients, in effect, of stolen goods.”

Impacted businesses and residents will now likely have to negotiate financial settlements with GB Power to compensate the utility for electricity which was consumed but never paid for, creating an unwanted burden for many in an economy that is still trying to recover.

Tribune Business’s source revealed they, too, had been offered “energy saving devices” in the past but, realising they did very little, rejected their installation. “Our savings would have been 0.1 percent per month,” they added. “No way on God’s name was I going to spend $20,000 to save $80 per month.”

Another Freeport contact, also speaking on condition of anonymity, said they also turned down such a device. “I didn’t want to touch it,” they said. “It didn’t make sense to me. A kilowatt is a kilowatt. I’m sitting her smiling, not having to look over my shoulder at GB Power.”

Tribune Business reported yesterday that purported “devices” at the heart of the GB Power and GBPA probes have been installed widely throughout Grand Bahama and Nassau, as well as some Family Islands, in a desperate bid by some companies and homeowners to reduce energy costs.

While they had been promoted as helping to produce a significant reduction in electricity bills, this is not what even genuine capacitor banks are designed to produce. These are intended to enable motors and electrical equipment to run more smoothly and efficiently, but do not cut the amount of energy consumed.

Tribune Business sources suggested that, in order to produce the promised savings, some installers had wired the devices such that they bypassed a “leg” of the electricity meter box. This, they explained, meant that not all energy consumption by a home or business was recorded by the utility - resulting in underbillings and losses to it.

GB Power yesterday confirmed this newspaper’s analysis, revealing: “These businesses are a victim of fraud, and were in fact either connected directly to GB Power’s power system via a meter bypass, or the meters were tampered with to under-read actual usage.

“To date, at every location inspected by GB Power and the [police] in the presence of the owners, it has been shown that all ‘devices’ are simply boxes consisting of bogus wiring with red or green lights, some with small unconnected LCD screens and sand-filled canisters pretending to be ‘capacitors’ in some instances.

“These fake boxes do nothing but act as a smokescreen for the dangerous diversion of GB Power’s electricity supply and bypass of our meter infrastructure. All customers with these fake boxes installed throughout the island have been abstracting GB Power’s electricity supply without paying for the electricity consumed.”

GB Power said “the number of such fake devices and non-compliant installations are unknown to us” presently, but warned that such practices were dangerous for all parties.

Comments

Sickened says...

Pirating is back!!!

Posted 21 March 2019, 3:11 p.m. Suggest removal

Clamshell says...

I am frequently critical of the reporting here, but not this time. It may have taken a week but finally we have a clear story on how this scam worked. Thank you, Mr. Hartnell. More of this sort of explanatory/investigative work would be welcome. Good job.

Posted 21 March 2019, 3:22 p.m. Suggest removal

Well_mudda_take_sic says...

Knowing Hartnell, he has more likely than not failed to disclose that The Tribune doesn't pay for all of the electricity that it consumes. LMAO

Posted 21 March 2019, 10:30 p.m. Suggest removal

TalRussell says...

Yes, yes and yes, my interpenetration criminal law is that if the comrade policeman's shows up my place business or residence, and I am unwittingly found be in possession stolen goods/property - the law allows them seise the goods/property in question, but other than that - they cannot demand I back-pay for their true original value, nor charge me a rental fee for period time I used them, yes, no? Power came and power (evidence) gone- disappeared - say what power you talking about, yes, no?

.

Posted 21 March 2019, 5:30 p.m. Suggest removal

ohdrap4 says...

your interpretation? Are you a judge? lol

I remember being in court years ago and Water and Sewage was suing to get some bills.

Who is Mary Jane?
--My mother mam.
Why is she not here?
--She is dead, and the bill is in her name, she cannot pay the bill
Do you and others still live in the home?
--Yes
Do you realize you have to pay the bill?
--My mother is dead.

Anyway the lawyer was one who rose high to politics many years later, and his name was on the list of those who did not pay the bills. May his mother RIP.

Posted 22 March 2019, 8:02 a.m. Suggest removal

Well_mudda_take_sic says...

All other things being unchanged, if my GBPC or BPL billings were suddenly reduced by 50% or more I would instantly know that I was somehow stealing electricity. That's just plain common sense. Try as they may with a straight face, there's just no way the owners of the businesses and residences involved could claim and feign ignorance.

Posted 21 March 2019, 10:45 p.m. Suggest removal

ThisIsOurs says...

I'm not so sure. You may know a little about power generation to know it's impossible but this scheme probably worked like a bogus MLM. One unwitting person is encouraged to install it, maybe for free, and then starts telling friends and coworkers how their electricity bill dropped. A few more people install and they say, yeah it's true, see my bill? So you have word of mouth and actual evidence driving sales and not hard core marketing. The network builds and people swear by the scam. Could a couple people in there realize what was going on? Maybe, but Im sure the majority were fooled.

Posted 23 March 2019, 5:38 a.m. Suggest removal

Well_mudda_take_sic says...

Five very simple questions:

(1) Was the electricity stolen?

(2) Who commissioned and paid for the act that allowed the electricity to be stolen?

(3) Who received the benefit of the stolen electricity?

(4) Who is liable for having received the benefit of the value of the stolen electricity?

The answers to these questions are all that really matter at the end of the day. Whether either the recipient or supplier of the stolen electricity ought to have known about the ongoing theft is quite irrelevant to the findings and consequences for it under the law.

Posted 23 March 2019, 7:10 p.m. Suggest removal

ThisIsOurs says...

Yeah the consumer is screwed. Imagine if you increased usage because the bill was so low...yikes

I'd really like to know how long this was going on and to understand why the individual thought they'd never be caught.

Also why is it that when we know someone committed an illegal act we don't print the name? It's not like you have some doubt if is was Tom or John. John showed up to people's house , John took money, hooked up all the bogus wiring. There's no doubt who did it and that it's fraud.

Posted 24 March 2019, 3:53 a.m. Suggest removal

Well_mudda_take_sic says...

The fifth question: Why hasn't the culprit who illegally profited from the installation of the fake devices to conceal the theft of electricity by metre bypassing and/or tampering been apprehended and arraigned in court yet? Is he politically well connected? LMAO

Posted 24 March 2019, 12:15 p.m. Suggest removal

totherisingsun says...

1. If the majority of devices had nothing in them how was power being illegally taken?

2. Has an investigaion been done on bec billing practices? That may have greater repercussions.

Posted 25 March 2019, 7:05 a.m. Suggest removal

ThisIsOurs says...

They bypassed the meter so usage wasn't being recorded = "illegal"

Posted 25 March 2019, 7:19 a.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment