Friday, April 17, 2020
By EARYEL BOWLEG
ebowleg@tribunemedia.net
A LOCAL environmental group has said the era of “flags of convenience” is over amid the COVID-19 pandemic, adding the government needs to rethink its relationship with the cruise industry.
The group also accused the government of taking no responsibility for the health, safety and welfare of people onboard Bahamian flagged ships and claimed this may have contributed to the spread of the coronavirus.
ReEarth, in a statement on its Facebook page, said much of the world now believes the Bahamas turns a blind eye to the cruise industry’s shortcomings at the expense of the health and safety of the crew, passengers and the environment in exchange for revenue.
This comes after the US Coast Guard told Bahamian-flagged ships to seek aid from this country first even if the ships are owned by Miami-based companies such as Carnival Corp, Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings and Royal Caribbean Ltd.
“You broke it, you own it. That seems to be the Coast Guard’s understandable sentiment,” reEarth noted.
The group also said: “Indeed, there would be push-back from the cruise industry against the governments of island nations attempting to change the status quo. COVID-19 acutely illustrates why now is the time to meet that push back head-on.
“We cannot escape the fact that in exchange for the sale of ‘flags of convenience,’ the Bahamas has some degree of legal responsibility for every man, woman and child aboard Bahamian vessels floating around randomly in our waters like plague ships of old.
“This is a serious responsibility. If the responsibility is ours, then we need to equip ourselves to meet our oversight duties in a meaningful, effective and timely way. As a cruise-port country, the message of the COVID-19 pandemic for us is clear: the era of flags of convenience is over. And we need to make changes in concert with our sister cruise port countries in the region, so that the cruise ships’ usual strategy of playing us off against each other is made obsolete.”
The International Transport Workers’ Federation recently took The Bahamas and Bermuda to task for what is described as “a shameful and unprecedented abdication of duty as flag states”.
Dave Heindel, chair of the ITF seafarers’ section, said: “Flag states have sovereignty over their vessels, but for the coronavirus-affected cruise ships responsibility has fallen on the port states, national governments of the passengers and crew or even a third country. For instance, the Braemar was refused to dock in its own territory, with the vessel sent to Cuba after its government authorised the offloading of passengers and crew."
MS Braemar sails under the Bahamas flag and made news last month after the Bahamian government did not permit the ship that had five people on board with COVID-19 to dock in the country. Eventually, the Cuban government allowed the ship to dock in Cuba.
Earlier this month, the government signalled that it will not accept people from ships stranded in Bahamian waters despite the US Coast Guard bulletin stating that foreign-flagged vessels should seek help from countries in which they are registered.
In a carefully worded statement, Transport Minister Renward Wells said the country would help people sheltering-in-place aboard cruise ships in its waters.
Mr Wells said in a statement: “The Bahamas has taken note of the United States Coast Guard Marine Safety Information Bulletin…giving guidance to foreign passenger vessels located in the Seventh District Area of Responsibility. The bulletin makes reference to Bahamas-registered vessels in the context of limited medical facilities ashore in Miami and vicinity.
“We in the Bahamas have had a long standing and ongoing relationship with the US Coast Guard based on mutual interest and respect. The Bahamas is one of the first countries to have cooperated closely with the Coast Guard in combating human trafficking, narcotic trafficking and other illicit activities.”
Mr Wells noted each party faces a unique challenge caused by the global pandemic and are “first and foremost” responsible for protecting their respective populations while doing its best to support people sheltering-in-place on board ships.
“We continue to work closely with the cruise industry,” he said earlier this month, noting this country’s flag represents more ships than any other registry in the world.
Comments
ThisIsOurs says...
"*this country’s flag represents more ships than any other registry in the world.*"
Noting the waste dumping "*serial recidivist*" reputation of the industry, and the lengths, according to the Miami court, they went to bypass regulations, theres a reason they choose the Bananas. Florida right there...
Posted 17 April 2020, 7:43 a.m. Suggest removal
Bonefishpete says...
Can't have it both ways.
Posted 17 April 2020, 7:58 a.m. Suggest removal
shonkai says...
Time to rethink all those new cruise port projects. Try to get some more sustainable tourism and tourists. Or surrender to the oil companies.
Posted 17 April 2020, 9:46 a.m. Suggest removal
Well_mudda_take_sic says...
There's no oil anywhere in The Bahamas. That was long ago determined by both Exxon-Mobile and Chevron. And the only people who would have anyone believe otherwise are pump, burn and dump stock promoters (con artists), like those currently hyping BPC, who will keep burning gullible investors for as long as they can before eventually dumping all of them when there's no more foolish money to be had.
Posted 17 April 2020, 11:13 a.m. Suggest removal
Hoda says...
While I respect environmentalists position on some things and yes the cruise ships probably played us like a fiddle - however, what other industry where the corporation head sit outside the jurisdiction or region don't do that?
Covid has already killed the industry and the probably any projects they were gonna take on. The major lines have already reported that up to 55% of Passengers who were booked for the foreseeable future have opted to take their money back instead of putting it towards a trip after the all clear - with their offer of credit towards upgrades, etc.
So now that we have carried on for the past year about cruise ships this and who shouldn't do this and who shouldn't have that, who getting this and who getting that, well now its nothing to get and its no one will have anything! The country can now creep into clean, pristine stagnation.
Posted 17 April 2020, 10:47 a.m. Suggest removal
Well_mudda_take_sic says...
@Hoda: The only one who 'got his' from the cruise ship companies is the very one you idolize and worship so much: Minnis!
The rest of us certainly got nothing but a royal shafting from Minnis's willingness to put all of our country's very fragile economic eggs in the cruise ship industry's most greedy, corrupt, pollution packed and pathogen infested basket.
And let's not forget that marsh mallow headed side-kick D'Aguilar who couldn't do enough for the cruise ship companies to curry political favour with Minnis. Come to think of it, Carl Bethel also falls into the same bucket of fools who couldn't do enough for the cruise ship companies in an effort to kiss Minnis's butt for his supper.
Posted 17 April 2020, 11:28 a.m. Suggest removal
DDK says...
Get the monster ships out and KEEP THEM OUT!
Posted 17 April 2020, 11:12 a.m. Suggest removal
DDK says...
We should allow SMALL, environmentally friendly vessels to cruise our islands, not those nasty mammoth floating garbage disposers and reef wreckers.
Posted 17 April 2020, 11:24 a.m. Suggest removal
Well_mudda_take_sic says...
And those small environmentally friendly vessels should all be exclusively reserved for Bahamian ownership as oppose to ownership by greedy foreign interests who are only too quick to beg us for outrageously generous concessions while repatriating all of their very handsome profits to their home countries. Minnis, D'Aguilar and Bethel must all be either dumb as _ _ _ _ _ _ _ or corrupt as _ _ _ _ _ _ _ !
Posted 17 April 2020, 11:40 a.m. Suggest removal
ThisIsOurs says...
what the dashes for :-| I can't read good
Posted 17 April 2020, 11:51 a.m. Suggest removal
TalRussell says...
**Ma Comrades, ninety percent of world trade is currently carried by almost fifty thousand ships so don't be quick throw out revenue streams...eventually colony will hope remains in place when it's time pull out to the other side deadly pandemic!**
Ninety nine percent ships flying colony's Flag of Convenience FOC have and will never enter into colony's legal waters. Besides, **babies born onboard ships at sea** may one day present more vexing **Citizenship** problem for colony's government. Nod once for yeah to more babies, twice for no more at sea citizens?
Posted 17 April 2020, 1:07 p.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment