'Substantial appetite' anticipated for visa despite Barbados lag

By NEIL HARTNELL

Tribune Business Editor

nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

The Economic Recovery Committee’s co-chair yesterday predicted there will be “substantial appetite” for The Bahamas’ proposed annual work/study visa even though it lags rivals such as Barbados.

Marlon Johnson, who is also the Ministry of Finance’s acting financial secretary, argued that while its southern Caribbean competitor had the advantage of being first into this space The Bahamas’ traditional advantages of US proximity and Internet access would leave it well-positioned to attract its target market.

He spoke out after the committee, in a statement, said the Minnis Cabinet had given approval to the concept of The Bahamas’ Extended Stay Visa Programme for persons wishing to work or study from this nation for a year as part of wider COVID-19 economic recovery strategy.

The initiative, though, mirrors the Barbados Welcome Stamp proposal that was unveiled by that Caribbean nation in early July amid much global media publicity and interest. That product was designed to allow tourists to stay in Barbados for 12 months, working remotely from hotels, condos, rental villas and other accommodations. Work spaces would also be made available.

The move represented Barbados’ response to the loss of its traditional leisure tourism market due to the COVID-19 pandemic, and it has gained several months’ head-start on The Bahamas as the committee’s release made clear that this nation’s product will only be launched once the borders re-open to international commerce - a date that has yet to be determined amid the latest lockdown.

Mr Johnson told Tribune Business that the committee’s proposed visa effectively represented an extension of The Bahamas’ existing annual residency permit, with the aim being to make the application and approval process much simpler, quicker and efficient.

Acknowledging that it effectively represented low-hanging fruit, or a “ready opportunity”, he added that foreign workers and students who qualify for the permit will NOT be allowed to participate in the domestic economy as a condition of its granting. Students must be registered with, and studying online, at a foreign university, while workers must be employed - and paid by - an overseas company.

Such restrictions are designed to reassure Bahamians that local jobs will be protected, especially with an unemployment rate approaching 50 percent due to COVID-19. The visa is effectively aiming to attract a different type of visitor, with the hope that ultimately these persons - and their employers - re-domicile to The Bahamas permanently rather than just providing a short-term post-COVID boost.

Asked whether The Bahamas had taken too long, and will now have to play catch-up to Barbados, Mr Johnson replied: “The important thing to remember is we have always had a residency visa. That’s something we have, and which people apply for from time to time. We’re now extending it and looking to simplify it. This is really a revamp of that.

“As far as timing is concerned, there’s substantial appetite. We’re next to the US and Canada, and a destination in demand with multiple islands. It will be interesting to see the appetite generated, and people working and studying overseas. We think there will be substantial appetite. The advantages that The Bahamas has today remain.

“The first mover always has an advantage, but you’re dealing with a vast market of 300m individuals in North America and that does not include Europe. There’s room for several players, and the attraction of The Bahamas is its proximity, level of infrastructure development, quality of Internet service. Those things augur well for the type of businesses and jobs we want to attract.”

Mr Johnson told Tribune Business that “more marketing” resources will be placed behind the proposed visa to promote it and ensure its target market is made aware. He added that meetings were planned with the Ministry of Tourism, private sector stakeholders and other government agencies on this issue once the product was “more clearly defined”.

The Committee’s release made clear the visa’s specifics, and details of the application process, are still being determined. It said responses to applications will be provided “in a matter of days”, which is likely to raise scepticism among some observers, with persons able to apply online.

Mr Johnson said the Government-appointed committee will also seek to “refine” the projected economic impact from the visa, which is designed to inject spending by successful applicants into the domestic economy via landlords (rent); car rentals; retailers; restaurants and a host of other sectors.

Kenwood Kerr, Mr Johnson’s fellow Committee co-chair, said: “If we get to 1,000 successful applicants and they spend $30,000 on average within the economy on rent, food, and entertainment, that is equal to a much needed $30m injection into the economy.

“Moreover, our marketing will showcase our Family Islands where the potential impact on those smaller island economies will be even more pronounced.” Mr Johnson said Mr Kerr’s estimates are “conservative”, with the Committee expecting the visa will be “a net add” for a depressed Bahamian economy that needs all the help it can get.

“We think it will be an excellent value-added to our existing range of products,” Mr Johnson told Tribune Business. “The key thing is we think it opens opportunities for boutique firms to move their entire operation to The Bahamas, and that will be an element of marketing to see if firms, or units of firms, want to live in The Bahamas and do work remotely.

“We have the Internet infrastructure people expect, and all the infrastructure amenities people would expect to have. We have the Family Islands for people wanting to get off the beaten path. We believe we have a very interesting proposition to present to the global marketplace so it will be interesting to see how it plays out.

“The approach is how do we maximise and leverage what we have in The Bahamas to get persons here, and add value for them and add value for The Bahamas.”

He added that the Committee had not directly linked the visa to the Commercial Enterprises Act, which was intended to liberalise the Immigration regime by allowing high-level executives and managers of firms relocating to The Bahamas in targeted industries to enter the country without first obtaining approved work permits.

And the visa’s emphasis on remote working could also tie into efforts to revive the Government’s Grand Bahama “technology hub” initiative, which appeared to have stalled even prior to COVID-19.

“Given the move to remote work and study from home protocols in response to COVID-19, the Committee saw an opportunity to recast the programme - and to expand it to accommodate university students whose schools will be offering remote learning for the upcoming academic year,” said Mr Kerr.

Mr Johnson added: “In addition to the visa initiative, the Committee will be providing recommendations to the Government regarding the next phase of the reopening of the economy.

“It will also submit an interim report by the ‘Orange Economy’ sub-committee, with recommendations on how the Government can boost the viability of the creative and cultural arts as a direct contributor to the economy.”

Comments

Proguing says...

Good, but should we not be leading in innovation instead of copying our competitors?

Posted 14 August 2020, 3:18 p.m. Suggest removal

observer2 says...

Nothing to do with innovation, or restarting the economy or even feeding hungry Bahamians.

The prime beneficiaries of this new policy are the ERC constituency (lawyers/residency fees, government/taxes).

Please don’t look to the ERC for salvation.

It really looks bad that the first recommendation of the ERC doesn’t benefit the average Bahamian. The optics are horrible. But I guess these days the government doesn’t even care about optics when the society/economy is imploding. Every man for himself. God help us all.

Posted 14 August 2020, 3:34 p.m. Suggest removal

moncurcool says...

Do these people really believe that persons would rather than work remotely from their own homes, pay money to fly then rent a place forum to one year to work remotely from the Bahamas? A student would fly here to study online from the Bahamas? If this is the indication of the suggestions coming from this so called economic recovery committee, then we about to get nothing.

Posted 14 August 2020, 4:30 p.m. Suggest removal

trueBahamian says...

Did I miss something? Isn't the US in a recession and having a huge unemployment problem? Also, why would someone pay two, three or four times.what they pay at home to go to a location where you're not guaranteed to have power during your years stay? If this was such a great idea that is an extension of something we have already, why wasn't it done before?

What is the projected income from this idea? Saying let's say a person spends $30k and we get 1,000 people then we have $30 million is nonsense. It's like saying if I have a cat and a spider, I have a new creature a cat-spider. I expect the Financial Secretary to give facts and figures, not fairytale numbers. Is he serious? This is a disgrace. Can someone with any understanding of numbers show that this was actually properly thought out and that some research was done.

I know the national average is a "D" but we shouldn't publish evidence of it.

Posted 14 August 2020, 7:22 p.m. Suggest removal

BONEFISH says...

That idea was simply copied from Barbados.No research and no analysis done.There is similar legislation already here,I am told.They also pulled a pie in the sky number for the revenues.

Other countries in the caribbean also offer economic citizenships. One of the questions that was not obviously asked,what would a person gain by working or studying online here? Utilities here are unreliable and expensive.

The acting financial secretary is merely a public relations man.No real analysis or work goes into his public statements.He has to this day not answered the questions posed to him about the vat tax increase by a former senor FNM cabinet minister.Smoke and mirrors.

Posted 14 August 2020, 8:42 p.m. Suggest removal

trueBahamian says...

This is scary. We are in serious trouble. We are in the midst of an economic crisis and we have one dumb idea that can't work that was a suggestion from the population, not even from the committee. Ae will lose potentially over 1 billion in tourism revenue and we have the Financial Secretary said if someone spends $30,000.00 and you a thousand people like that, we have $30 million. This is unbelievable. Where did they find this guy? Can we get smart people who understand economics or at least know what the word "data" means?

Why on earth are we always getting a committee stacked with incompetence and yes men/women? Can someone come up with real plans please?

Posted 14 August 2020, 9:14 p.m. Suggest removal

trueBahamian says...

This committee is a waste of time as expected. The PM should resign. If this is the extent of the recovery conversation, we can all figure out, the government has no clue. Keep in mind this one idea, which is terrible, was actually pitched by someone not on the committee. So, we have about 14 people on a committee with zero ideas. This is the extent of our plans for an economic recovery. We can all figure out they will be paid for this crap or get favors later or both.

This is extremely disturbing. Do the rest of my fellow countrymen not see that our situation is dire. We have a government that's grossly unequipped to handle any national emergency. It's grossly deficient in intellectual talent. It's a roving band of yes men/women and friends. This is textbook banana republic bs. On the other side of the political divide, we have more of the same. Is it time for those of us that can leave this rock to leave?

Posted 15 August 2020, 5:43 a.m. Suggest removal

trueBahamian says...

Something is odd here. How many times in the history of this country have we seen the Financial Secretary from the Ministry of Finance in the media? Is Mr. Johnson the unofficial Minister of Finance? Is there a power struggle here?

We (the people) are paying for a government but are getting tickets for the circus.

Posted 15 August 2020, 6:07 a.m. Suggest removal

The_Oracle says...

The ERC is formed with the same "go to" people being appointed endlessly from the same limited pool, but we expect innovation and new ideas?
Unreliable and expensive utilities, Crime, High cost of living,
For a year? At what Cost? What is the renewal policy? Sit in Limbo praying they can stay if they wanted to?
Bank accounts? Drivers Licenses? Sub standard Healthcare? High cost of Travel back and forth?
Toes in the Sand at the "office"is a marvelous pitch, made 5 years ago in the Bahamas.
Our successive Government don't get that we are on average 10 years behind the U.S.
15 behind the EU in so many areas of economic/technical/social life.

Posted 17 August 2020, 9:54 a.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment