Thursday, December 10, 2020
* PM's top advisor confirms local investor group approval
* Principals were 'optimistic' after 'doing all we should'
* Original proposal called for up to 1,200 full-time jobs
By NEIL HARTNELL
Tribune Business Editor
nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
The Government has given the go-ahead to a Bahamian investor group aiming to generate $1.5bn in revenues by transforming Nassau's key heritage sites, a top official revealed yesterday.
Joshua Sears, the Prime Minister's senior policy advisor, told Tribune Business that the Cabinet's National Economic Council (NEC) had earlier this month given its blessing to the Public-Private Investments (PPIL) group's multi-million dollar proposal to restore and revive sites that include Nassau’s three forts, the Queen’s Staircase (66 Steps) and Water Tower, and the Pompey Museum.
"What I can say to you is that the NEC has approved the project, and the operational aspect is now subject to continued interaction between the Antiquities, Monuments and Museums Corporation (AMMC) and the group," Mr Sears said.
"That'll be the next step. There's been several meetings but it was finally approved about a week ago." With the Government becoming ever more cash-strapped due to the COVID-19 pandemic, Mr Sears said the hope was that outsourcing these locations to private sector management, capital and maintenance will unlock their true value for heritage/cultural tourism and Bahamians alike.
"When the proposal was submitted it was thought that these historical sites required an injection of private capital," he explained. "The Water Tower, in particular, required substantial investment.
"The overall idea was to improve the sites and make them more attractive and viable to the tourism product, and make the environs of the city of Nassau attractive to Bahamians and visitors alike. It's a very important part of our cultural history."
PPIL, which is headed by Dr Nigel Lewis, as its chairman, and businessman Olvin Rees, now have to finalise the details of an operations and management agreement for the historic sites they will be charged with restoring for the benefit of Bahamians, the wider economy and job creation.
The group already has a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) in place with the AMMC, and Mr Rees told this newspaper last summer that it projected the venture could generate $1.5bn in gross revenues over the duration of a 25-year lease along with several hundred jobs.
Both he and Dr Lewis recently told Tribune Business, prior to this newspaper's interview with Mr Sears, that PPIL felt confident it had fulfilled everything required of it and was now just awaiting the Government's approval to advance to the the operations and management agreement.
"We're still waiting on the final signing of the management agreement from the Government," Mr Rees had said. "We haven't heard from them yet. Hopefully some time in the New Year we may hear something.
"We're waiting for everything to be finalised. It hasn't changed. The Government has got other priorities right now. We couldn't do anything with it previously; the pandemic, cruise ships pulling out and tourism going to zero."
Dr Lewis gave a similar outlook, telling this newspaper: "We are waiting to get some word from the Government. I believe we have done everything we should have done. It's now in the Government's hands. We're just waiting for them to tell us when they are ready, and we are very optimistic. We have been waiting, that's all I can say to you at this time."
Besides Fort Charlotte, Fort Fincastle and Fort Montague, and the Queen’s Staircase and Water Tower, PPIL was - prior to COVID-19 striking - also hoping to take over operational responsibility for the Botanical Gardens, Pompey Museum and the National Public Library.
Its aim, via a public-private partnership (PPP) arrangement with the Government, was to make all the locations financially self-sustainable by overhauling their appearance, enhancing the visitor experience and “pre-selling” tour packages to both cruise ship passengers and hotel tourists, reversing perceptions that Nassau is “boring” with little of interest to do amid “run down” attractions.
Documents obtained by Tribune Business reveal that PPIL aimed to provide 500 direct permanent jobs, and between 500 to 750 indirect jobs, via the proposed project before COVID-19 intervened to delay progress towards an operations and management agreement.
The papers seen by this newspaper show that the project has now been more than three years in the making, with PPIL quick off the mark to formally approach the Minnis administration with its proposal within three months of it taking office on May 10, 2017.
An August 8, 2017, letter from Dr Lewis to the NEC, which references "earlier and ongoing discussions with various members of the Council", likely meaning individual Cabinet ministers and officials, initially sought a 30-year lease concession to manage and operate sites that also included Government House, Heroes Park and Centreville (Collins) House.
Richenda King, the AMMC's chairman, yesterday confirmed that Government House was not included in the potential sites that PPIL would potentially assume responsibility for although she declined further comment, instead referring Tribune Business to the Prime Minister's Office.
Dr Lewis' letter, meanwhile, also suggested the group was interested in developing "guided tours through historical Adelaide, Fox Hill and Gambier Villages" while training local residents to manage and operate them, and creating "an educational heritage experience for all Bahamians".
"We seek to establish a sustainable world-class heritage experience for tourists and locals (generations of Bahamians) alike, with the full participation of all key stakeholders," Dr Lewis wrote, committing PPIL to an initial $30m investment and the creation of "multiple entrepreneurial opportunities".
"This has immediate and long-term positive implications for the Government as it seeks to rebrand The Bahamas as a destination, while controlling and constraining its capital budgetary expenditures," he added.
A draft operations and management agreement between the AMMC and PPIL, which is unsigned and dated from February 2019, states that the investor group will "seek to provide 350 temporary jobs, 500 direct permanent jobs, 500-700 indirect permanent jobs and multiple entrepreneurial opportunities, the economic impact of which is estimated at $1.2bn over 25 years".
It is uncertain whether these details have, or will, change, with the draft also detailing a 'sliding scale' profit sharing agreement where AMMC will receive a 20 percent share at $2m and 45 percent anywhere above $4m.
"PPIL Group views the development of an effective heritage tourism model as critical to any attempt to diversify our economy and strengthen its core tourism product," the group said in its accompanying business plan.
"This strategy speaks to the development of a 'signature' heritage tourism programme to be featured as a cultural focal point for ongoing efforts to preserve The Bahamas' unique footing as the 'cultural and geographical jewel of the Caribbean'."
Few would argue that the sites targeted by PPIL are in serious need of improved management and upgrading. If this can be accomplished, they can play a significant role in restructuring and enhancing the Bahamian tourism product post-COVID-19, while also monetising Bahamian history and taking the country into the higher margin cultural/heritage tourism niche.
The documents seen by Tribune Business also include a draft MoU between PPIL and the Public Parks and Beaches Authority for the Botanical Gardens and Heroes Park. It is unclear, though, whether this was signed or if the two assets are still included in the deal. Shanendon Cartwright, the Authority's chairman, could not be reached for comment yesterday.
PPIL's business plan, which is dated, named Vincent Vanderpool-Wallace, former minister of tourism in the last Ingraham administration, and Michael Maura, then head of BISX-listed Arawak Port Development Company (APD), as members of the investor group.
However Mr Maura, who now heads Nassau Cruise Port, and Mr Vanderpool-Wallace both confirmed that they only had marginal and temporary connections to PPIL's plan and are no longer involved. The latter said he backed away because his involvement could have created a "conflict" with another project he was involved with.
Comments
tribanon says...
Few would argue against the need to privatize the entire Office of The PM to a group capable of stamping out massive corruption and overseeing the governing of our country in a sensible way. lol
Posted 10 December 2020, 1:54 p.m. Suggest removal
skeptic says...
Yea, right. Privatization is just SOOOO clean and uncorrupt. Lol. What planet have you been living on? Do you ever read newspapers from beyond this rock? Privatization (and frankly capitalism in general) is the elixir of corruption. In the UK, they sold off the railways to typical "private" gangsters who predictably squeezed out all the profit, didn't reinvest and destroyed a once-great public asset. The public now clamours for renationalization of that and much more.
Posted 11 December 2020, 6:32 a.m. Suggest removal
tribanon says...
You're obviously too young to remember what the UK was like before Margaret Thatcher came along. And the same goes for younger Brits who may be agitating for the nationalization of this, that and the other. All too many of them have been educated, or should I say indoctrinated, to believe big government is the answer to all of their concerns.
Posted 11 December 2020, 10:12 a.m. Suggest removal
TalRussell says...
What else have comrade Joshua, and **his privateers** been meetin' **secret sessions** to sign away **on top** we Nassau Town's, key heritage sites. **But One more cement block of the wall** being constructed surround we chief out island. **Shakehead** a quick once for upyeahvote, a slow twice for not?
Posted 10 December 2020, 2:02 p.m. Suggest removal
shonkai says...
Can't wait for the Dec 31, 2045 headline saying "**Heritage Plan from 2020 misses target by 1.49 Billion**" next to the one that says "**Tourists still afraid to leave the Ships**".
Posted 10 December 2020, 2:17 p.m. Suggest removal
TalRussell says...
My Comrade Shonkai, talk has it that Comrade Sister Ms.Yang, being sought to become the privateers public voice generate $1.5bn in revenues. Just can't make this kinds stuff up. Just, **can't.**
Posted 10 December 2020, 2:36 p.m. Suggest removal
Clamshell says...
“ ... headline saying "Heritage Plan from 2020 misses target by 1.49 Billion" ... LMAO! 🤣🤣
Posted 10 December 2020, 2:51 p.m. Suggest removal
TalRussell says...
Brungs back the mid-'80s memories of televangelist Jim Bakker and his wife Tammy Faye's **Heritage USA.**
Is it possible for the privateers group to be offering **pay in advance lifetime partnership passes to all of Nassau Town's Heritage Sites?** Just can't make this kinda stuff up. Just, **can't,**
Posted 10 December 2020, 3:01 p.m. Suggest removal
themessenger says...
Y'all ain't nothing more than a bunch of damned black crabs.
You would rather see our heritage sites continue to decay and crumble before allowing a private group of BAHAMIANS to restore them from the public latrines and garbage receptacles which they have become and develop a working plan for them. Yes, there will be some profit in it for them, but you first have to spend money, which the government doesn't have any of, to make money.
Heritage sites the world over are privately run and maintained in this fashion which is why this is needed here, private investors unlike governments tend to look after their investments.
Don't let there be a couple of white folks in the group, all you'll hear is hollering then, Toby Smith and the Hog island lighthouse a typical case in point!
Posted 10 December 2020, 3:54 p.m. Suggest removal
TalRussell says...
My Comrade will get no argument on your point that our heritage sites have fallen into decay.
Posted 10 December 2020, 4:05 p.m. Suggest removal
ThisIsOurs says...
I'm supportive of any Bahamian of legitimate means launching successful business ventures. I think what you see in the comments is a people who've been let down over and over again and have seen deal after deal struck to hide private selfish selfserving nation-damaging parliamentary business interests.
If these guys are legit more power to them. We need attractions for tourists and locals.
As to Toby Smith, he Bahamian more power to him to
I HOPE this isnt like the other deal where the company wanted to own all govt buildings. Too often we see private locsl and fireign interests taking advantage of the unsophisticated business acumen in govt to strike these borderline country hijacking deals
Posted 12 December 2020, 12:01 p.m. Suggest removal
tribanon says...
This sounds like a very risky business venture given that Maxine Waters is still pressing for a Bahamas chapter of BLM to be established. And we all know BLM members don't like the wrong kind of heritage. Is that big white statue of Christopher Columbus still standing in front of Government House?
Posted 10 December 2020, 4:56 p.m. Suggest removal
themessenger says...
Maxine Waters can go jump in the harbour!
What can she do that our own homegrown lunatics and radical priests haven't suggested already?
Preserve our Heritage by sanitizing all portions of our history that doesn't conform with the BLM zealots. Does this mean we should also remove the statues of our black patriots like Sir Milo and Pindling because some of the white people don't like them? Where does the stupidity stop?
Posted 11 December 2020, 8:27 a.m. Suggest removal
birdiestrachan says...
why were Mr sears an advisor to the Government and Mike Maura who is a member of
one of the eleven Families that own 40% of the shares at the Arawak Port. is also involved
in the cruise Port. now they say they drop out Really?
.
At one stage even the Government house was a part of this deal.
A thirty-year lease. Is a long time.
And they talk about all for me. Bahamians should pay close attention to this deal
it may have been made in hell among the demons..
It is the peoples time all right for the rich to get richer under the FNM Government
Posted 10 December 2020, 9:52 p.m. Suggest removal
happyfly says...
This has "China Debt Trap" written ALLLLLLLLLL over it.
Let see. $15 dollars for a pass to downtown historical attractions = $1.5billion dollars getting paid back at $1.50c (profit) per cruise ship passenger x one BILLION cruise ship passengers.....PLEASE ?!!! Of course, the reason we have a foreign investment approval process is to ensure that all the details are made available to the public...in their best interests.....the publics........
Posted 11 December 2020, 8:19 a.m. Suggest removal
BONEFISH says...
This project just shows how the Bahamas operates. This venture was being developed during the last government.
After the government changed in May 2017, big time FNM supporters were brought into the project and placed in the forefront.
This project ties into the cruise port development. One of the complaints from surveys of cruise passengers, there was a lack of on shore attractions on New Providence. Also many historical sites like Blackboard's Tower and the Water Tower were not properly maintained.
Like some one said to me, there is more to Bahamian tourism besides sun, sand and sea. This is an attempt to capitalize on the Bahamas historical sites to generate income for the country and funds for their continual maintenance.
Posted 11 December 2020, 9:43 a.m. Suggest removal
Dawes says...
Hopefully this works as what we have now is an embarrassment. It is obvious Government is unable to maintain these sites, so maybe this new group can. Good luck to them. As a note it has been both PLP and FNM that have not been able to maintain these so both can Carry themselves before either side complains.
Posted 11 December 2020, 9:57 a.m. Suggest removal
JokeyJack says...
""We're waiting for everything to be finalised. It hasn't changed. The Government has got other priorities right now. We couldn't do anything with it previously; the pandemic, cruise ships pulling out and tourism going to zero."
So are you suggesting that the government can't walk and chew gum at the same time?
Also, the further waiting that is required should not be a problem because every Bahamian has a Ph.D. in Waitology.
Posted 11 December 2020, 11 a.m. Suggest removal
ThisIsOurs says...
this deal aside, the real question is what is the vision, what is the strategy? Will the Bahamas own anything in the bahamas at the end of the day? islands, govt buildings, museums, airports, ports, infrastructure, hospitals, junkanoo, bay street? Or will every govt that comes to power bite off another little piece for a few dollars?
Posted 12 December 2020, 12:22 p.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment