EDITORIAL: The injustices on our doorstep

THE world is watching the United States at present, as it convulses with protests, riots and looting, all sparked by a police officer kneeling on George Floyd’s neck until he died.

This incident – a white officer killing a black man – is far from an isolated one. Racism isn’t getting worse, it’s just getting filmed. The convenience of the camera on the phone is letting the world see these incidents – just as it has recorded incidents during the police response to the protests that followed.

Shortly before the death of George Floyd, another video went viral, showing a white woman calling the police in an hysterical tone of voice, saying an African American was present and she needed help. She was not being threatened – and the way George Floyd was treated showed what could have been for the black man she called the police on.

The issues in the US have attracted worldwide attention – as issues in America so often do, dominant as it is in terms of media and social networks. When we feel anger about the injustices there, however, we should feel no less anger about the injustices in our own country.

In Tuesday’s Tribune, columnist Felicity Darville looked to historic issues here at home - the Burma Road Riot in The Bahamas. Today, fellow columnist Alicia Wallace looks at issues here today.

Does racism exist in The Bahamas? Some would say no, given the majority black population and the series of black people in positions of power in the country, all the way up to Prime Minister. But we would be foolish to pretend racism is not a part of our existence here.

When we talk about institutional racism, we talk about a racism that is rooted in the structures of our society. It makes no difference if an individual police officer is white or black if they are following orders that come from a structure that works against black people. Do our structures work that way? Take a look inside the walls of Fox Hill prison and tell us which sector of society is most represented there.

More than that, take a look at the court cases routinely featured in The Tribune, and the series of young black men hauled before the courts. Look further, to the society we have created that leads those men into a life of crime. Are we really so different than the US?

Even recently, take a look at the differences in sentences handed out for curfew violations. Mostly, it’s a fine of $400 or so, unless you’re a young black man selling coconuts and then you get fined $700. And what of the Filipino woman, fined $2,000 for jogging? Was that sentencing equitable compared to other cases?

The Tribune has regularly reported on cases of alleged police brutality – from the case of Osworth Rolle, unlawfully killed by police more than three years ago, to the three people who said they were tortured by police in Eleuthera, and whose complaint to the force was allowed to run out of time without action. Or the officers caught on video here – beating people during Junkanoo on New Year’s Day. We could mention more – the teenager slammed on the ground at Kendal GL Isaacs Gymnasium, the two young women reportedly assaulted by police in Exuma, the video of an officer slapping a man on a beach, the man limping from custody to an ambulance after allegedly being shocked with a taser and beaten.

We may not have the protests tearing apart the US at present – but we have more than our share of inequality, and plenty of injustice to go with it.

So as we look at what is going wrong elsewhere, we must ask ourselves what we can do to eradicate injustice here too. We have fought some of these same battles in our own past – and the leaders who battle against injustice are renowned in our country. That prompts the same question Felicity Darville posed in her column this week – “Who’s going to fill their shoes?”

THE world is watching the United States at present, as it convulses with protests, riots and looting, all sparked by a police officer kneeling on George Floyd’s neck until he died.

This incident – a white officer killing a black man – is far from an isolated one. Racism isn’t getting worse, it’s just getting filmed. The convenience of the camera on the phone is letting the world see these incidents – just as it has recorded incidents during the police response to the protests that followed.

Shortly before the death of George Floyd, another video went viral, showing a white woman calling the police in an hysterical tone of voice, saying an African American was present and she needed help. She was not being threatened – and the way George Floyd was treated showed what could have been for the black man she called the police on.

The issues in the US have attracted worldwide attention – as issues in America so often do, dominant as it is in terms of media and social networks. When we feel anger about the injustices there, however, we should feel no less anger about the injustices in our own country.

In Tuesday’s Tribune, columnist Felicity Darville looked to historic issues here at home - the Burma Road Riot in The Bahamas. Today, fellow columnist Alicia Wallace looks at issues here today.

Does racism exist in The Bahamas? Some would say no, given the majority black population and the series of black people in positions of power in the country, all the way up to Prime Minister. But we would be foolish to pretend racism is not a part of our existence here.

When we talk about institutional racism, we talk about a racism that is rooted in the structures of our society. It makes no difference if an individual police officer is white or black if they are following orders that come from a structure that works against black people. Do our structures work that way? Take a look inside the walls of Fox Hill prison and tell us which sector of society is most represented there.

More than that, take a look at the court cases routinely featured in The Tribune, and the series of young black men hauled before the courts. Look further, to the society we have created that leads those men into a life of crime. Are we really so different than the US?

Even recently, take a look at the differences in sentences handed out for curfew violations. Mostly, it’s a fine of $400 or so, unless you’re a young black man selling coconuts and then you get fined $700. And what of the Filipino woman, fined $2,000 for jogging? Was that sentencing equitable compared to other cases?

The Tribune has regularly reported on cases of alleged police brutality – from the case of Osworth Rolle, unlawfully killed by police more than three years ago, to the three people who said they were tortured by police in Eleuthera, and whose complaint to the force was allowed to run out of time without action. Or the officers caught on video here – beating people during Junkanoo on New Year’s Day. We could mention more – the teenager slammed on the ground at Kendal GL Isaacs Gymnasium, the two young women reportedly assaulted by police in Exuma, the video of an officer slapping a man on a beach, the man limping from custody to an ambulance after allegedly being shocked with a taser and beaten.

We may not have the protests tearing apart the US at present – but we have more than our share of inequality, and plenty of injustice to go with it.

So as we look at what is going wrong elsewhere, we must ask ourselves what we can do to eradicate injustice here too. We have fought some of these same battles in our own past – and the leaders who battle against injustice are renowned in our country. That prompts the same question Felicity Darville posed in her column this week – “Who’s going to fill their shoes?”

An unwelcome guest

As we edge closer to reopening the country and welcoming back visitors, there is one particular arrival that we could do without.

The cane toad has returned to The Bahamas. Invasive. Toxic. Unwanted. A few years ago, in 2013, the toad was spotted and, at the time, seemingly dealt with.

Seemingly, it had disappeared. Now, it is back. Speaking of things that had seemingly disappeared but are now back, Environment Minister Romi Ferreira is ready to take on the toad.

The Bahamas is a wonderful, welcoming place. But this particular visitor can hop off.

Comments

xtreme2x says...

MR COMMISSIONER OF POLICE, WHY IS IT TAKING FOREVER FOR THE POLICE TO START WEARING THE CAMERA?

Posted 3 June 2020, 9:23 p.m. Suggest removal

Giordano says...

Why the RBPF is actually neglecting Police patrolling in the ghetto and not in the more fortunate communities who can afford private security companies?
Why the lack of a contingency plan, from the stance of public safety, hence the high rate of
people without job?
Why is it that the local leadership is making the entire Bahamian Society a hazard, for so long ?
Why this current elected government prioritizes the P.M.'s pledge above the National Pledge ?
Why this government is unable to show the first planted Mangrove tree with the loan of $40.00 MILLIONS taken,last year's hurricane season from the BID to create a green barrier to decrease damages to the land cause by flood and bad weather ?
Why the RBPF is not giving back to law abiding citizens, in the middle of this Curfew, the confidence, the dignity & the respect by just driving by, flashing lights of police patrolling cars, consistently, in all neighborhoods of N.P. especially in late nights hour ?
Where is the VAT MONEY going ? And how much is it collected every single day ? Before and during this Pandemic time ?

Posted 4 June 2020, 3:20 a.m. Suggest removal

birdiestrachan says...

Thirty 30 persons were killed by Police in 2019. A small nation

They Police Force of which Dames is the minister seems to take great delight in
arresting poor black young men,

The Bahamas has to keep silent. because they, themselves are guilty

Posted 4 June 2020, 10:20 a.m. Suggest removal

Proguing says...

"They Police Force of which Dames is the minister seems to take great delight in arresting poor black young men"

And I thought that they were dangerous criminals...

I think that we should first take a closer look at reducing the high crime rate in this country. Only 2 murders in the Cayman islands in 2017. That's about the same as in Long Island!

Posted 4 June 2020, 11:10 a.m. Suggest removal

bahamianson says...

Birdie, agreed, that is all I am saying. If those 30 people were killed by white police officers in the Bahamas, it would have been a bigger issue here. I am not making lite of Mr. Floyde's death if they had a racist intent, they should face justice.

Posted 4 June 2020, 11:38 a.m. Suggest removal

JokeyJack says...

So, by my simple "back of the envelope" calculations, if you are jogging along to quickly deliver a coconut to a customer (who already has their gin) - and it's after curfew - you could potentially face a fine of $3,100 ?

Posted 4 June 2020, 12:20 p.m. Suggest removal

sheeprunner12 says...

Anyone saw the videos of the recent Kemp Road people standoff vs Police or the Fox Hill & Nassau Village uprisings a few years ago??? ………… Not all Nassau communities are police-friendly …………. It is just not really exposed or reported - or it is covered up by the farce of Urban Renewal

Posted 4 June 2020, 1:42 p.m. Suggest removal

WETHEPEOPLE says...

Like they said, the revolution would be televised

Posted 4 June 2020, 3:02 p.m. Suggest removal

tribanon says...

We black folks got most of them white folks all huddled up and shaking scared in their gated communities, but we still the ones suffering from institutional racism. Now put that in your pipe and smoke it. LOL

Posted 4 June 2020, 5:22 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment