COVID testing: '11th hour' u-turn blasted

* Coalition stunned by '180 degree' reversal

* Came after 3m kits distributed to entry ports

* Principal: 'This why I don't like work for Gov't'

By NEIL HARTNELL

Tribune Business Editor

nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

A Bahamian non-profit has blasted the Government's "180 degree turn at the 11th hour" for "sidelining" their agreement to provide three million COVID-19 test kits to facilitate tourism's re-opening.

Robert Myers, a principal with the Living with COVID Coalition (LWCC), told Tribune Business the Minnis administration's last-minute decision to abandon rapid antigen testing for all border arrivals occurred after the group had already distributed the kits "throughout The Bahamas" to all ports of entry.

Revealing that the Coalition was only informed of the policy switch last Thursday, less than 72 hours before tourism's "reopening" yesterday, Mr Myers said the reversal represented a waste of time and money for both himself and other members as he declared: "This is why I don't like doing work for government."

To eliminate the 14-day mandatory quarantine for all arrivals, which was seen as a major impediment to tourists travelling to The Bahamas, the Government initially announced its replacement with a series of more frequent tests. Besides presenting a negative COVID-19 PCR test upon arrival, visitors were to also receive an antigen test at the border and again if they stayed for five days.

The Living With COVID Coalition, in a joint statement with the Ministry of Tourism that was issued a week ago Sunday, touted that as part of a public-private partnership (PPP) between the two sides it had secured three million World Health Organisation (WHO) and Ministry of Health-approved rapid antigen tests via local medical supplier, Ports International, to enable country-wide testing of all arrivals.

Yet, just four days later, both the partnership and rapid antigen border testing were dumped by the Government. Both Dionisio D'Aguilar, minister of tourism and aviation, and Dr Delon Brennen, the Baltimore-based deputy chief medical officer, on Saturday said the "upon arrival" testing was dropped because it was not "supported by the science".

They argued that these tests would add little to a traveller's negative COVID-19 PCR test, which they have to obtain within five days' prior to getting on a plane to The Bahamas, adding that they would not detect visitors carrying the virus who are asymptomatic.

Mr Myers, disputing this, argued that international experience and research had shown it typically took three to five days before COVID-19 carriers became infectious and "started shedding". As a result, he said a rapid antigen test upon arrival would still "catch a large percentage" of these - especially those who had obtained a negative COVID-19 PCR test three to five days before travelling.

And Mr Myers also questioned why the Government did not conclude border testing was "not supported by the science" some 12 weeks ago, when it and the Coalition first started talks on providing a solution.

He added that Mr D'Aguilar, who was quoted in the November 25, 2020, press release touting the partnership with the Coalition, and Dr Brennen had been its main contact points and who had requested that kits be provided for a comprehensive testing regime that included the border.

"This is not something the Living With COVID Coalition came up with on its own," Mr Myers told Tribune Business. "This was a collaborative effort with the Government, Health and the deputy chief medical officer. Dionisio and the deputy chief medical officer were in constant contact, as were the Department of Health and other doctors,.

"You can imagine our complete surprise when they pulled this. We had built the whole system for them. We had delivered the tests throughout the country by plane on Thursday and Friday, and got the platform for the Bahamas Health Travel visa in place. That's where we're at. We can't do anything more than that. I can't help them any more. We've done all we promised to.

"They changed their minds and we don't support that change. We've worked for 12 weeks on this, spent hundreds of thousands of dollars. It's disappointing but that's life. It's not everything that works. We put a lot of time into it and at no cost. I didn't make any money. I put a lot of time and personal money into it, but if they do what they're doing it's a tremendous waste of my time and other people who contributed."

It is unclear why, just four days the Ministry of Tourism's name was placed alongside the Living With COVID Coalition's, the "science" supporting border testing abruptly changed from the Government's perspective - especially when the two sides had been talking for three months.

Mr D'Aguilar, in his national address on Saturday, indicated that the challenge of rolling out rapid antigen testing at all Bahamian ports of entry, and across all islands, was simply too complex from a logistical perspective.

"As you can imagine, the logistics and complexities of rolling out any type of testing in a country with as many islands and, as a consequence, as many ports of entry as we have in The Bahamas, is no small undertaking," he said.

"As the Ministry of Tourism fleshed out that idea, of testing at the border and began to roll it out with the huge support of the Immigration Department, Nassau Airport Development Company (NAD), the Airport Authority, the Grand Bahama Airport Company, marina operators, local health care providers and other interested parties in the private sector, the guidance from the Ministry of Health changed.

"The use of rapid antigen tests as an effective screening tool at the border was not supported by the available research or, was not supported by the science."

Dr Brennen later explained the "science" as being that rapid COVID-19 antigen tests upon arrival were of little use in picking up asymptomatic carriers of the virus given that all visitors coming to The Bahamas must produce a negative PCR test taken within five days of their travel.

"If someone were to be exposed on Monday, and travel on Tuesday, if they had a test done at that time it would not show as positive anyway, so it will not give you the type of results you are looking for," Dr Brennen added. Due to the five to six-day "incubation period" that COVID-19 carriers go through, he said "testing on arrival will not give you the type of results you think it would".

Mr D'Aguilar said: “I looked throughout the Caribbean, I looked at a total of 20 destinations, and of those 20 countries only three were testing upon arrival. So obviously this is not something that has gained traction, and not being generally accepted, so if everybody is not doing it, there must be some reason why they are not doing it.

"They are not doing it because science is not supporting it. We can only go with science. We have a very robust public health department. We are guided by them. We had the same questions as you."

It is unclear, though, why the Government would effectively wait until the last minute to abandon a partnership that it had endorsed via the Ministry of Tourism just four days before. And also why it took so long to research other countries and decide the support for border testing had evaporated when it had been talking to the Coalition for 12 weeks.

"I don't like doing work for the Government because there's not enough leadership," Mr Myers added. "It's always such a bloody mess any time you deal with the Government. That's why in all the things they do that don't attract the 'Grade A' people because they do not want to put up with their nonsense.

"The problem is at the 11th hour, after we had delivered the kits, they changed their minds. We didn't expect the Government to do a 180 degree on us, but we can't help them any more. I'm certainly not willing to give up any more of my time when you move the goal posts. I wasn't willing to play that game anyway."

The indications are that the Ministry of Health overruled their tourism counterparts on the rapid antigen border testing. However, Mr Myers argued that it was "a big risk to run", with the multiple doctors involved with the Coalition also disagreeing with the Government's decision.

He argued that elimination of this testing phase could potentially result in COVID-infected visitors being into their 10th day before they are uncovered, and spreading the virus to other tourists and Bahamians alike, even though the Government has narrowed the PCR test window from seven days before travel to five as a result - a deadline Mr D'Aguilar conceded will be a major "undertaking" to comply with.

Mr Myers, who said the Coalition will now focus on providing test kits for employers, churches, civil society and the Government, added that the end to "upon arrival" testing will cut the number of COVID tests required "in half" and thus make it uneconomic for clinics and private practices - who would just be covering their costs - to participate.

Whether the latest travel and tourism COVID-19 protocols provide the clarity and certainty the industry, and its customers, need remains to be seen. The framework unveiled on Saturday contained a number of last-minute changes and clarifications for the health procedures visitors must comply with, some of which raised more questions than answers.

Besides the decision to drop COVID-19 on-arrival rapid antigen testing less than 72 hours before the November 1 tourism "re-opening", and dropping the pre-arrival PCR test from a seven-day to five-day window, the latest Emergency Orders issued by the Office of the Prime Minister on Friday afternoon still stipulated that the mandatory 14-day quarantine period remained in place.

This forced Mr D'Aguilar to begin Saturday's national address with an immediate pledge that the 14-day quarantine - which most tourism industry participants have long argued was a major deterrent to visitors coming here - is indeed being eliminated consistent with previous promises, and that the oversight in the Orders will be corrected.

Comments

Porcupine says...

Is this an epitaph? For us as a country? For any semblance of good faith, trust, cooperation, by those who are elected and paid, by us, to look out for our own best interests? You don't have to pick sides. All you have to do is to understand that, at some point, none of us wants to feel disposable. Eventually, for any of us to get "involved" is to put yourself up for being considered disposable. This administration is no different from any that came before. All the same.

Posted 2 November 2020, 8:09 a.m. Suggest removal

KapunkleUp says...

I wouldn't go that far but it again shows that our government is as clueless as the rest of the world. Wasted money that could have been used for other needs. Common sense is the first to go when you get elected.

Posted 2 November 2020, 12:04 p.m. Suggest removal

Honestman says...

Government is leaving us at the mercy of COVID. Everyone must take personal responsibility for their health and the health of their family and friends. No one has your back - the hospitals will likely be unable to cope. The road to freedom is going to be long and uncertain and, sadly, many will not reach the destination.

Posted 2 November 2020, 8:23 a.m. Suggest removal

Mr-G says...

So if there are 3 million test units out there not to be used, then we should use them to test everyone in the country, ,something that should have been done a long time ago, use them for good, please dont let them go to waste.
Slovakia, a country of 5 million people has started testing EVERYONE FOR FREE.
We need a clear picture of who has the virus, full quarantine of those infected, move forward to get the country back on it feet..

Posted 2 November 2020, 8:25 a.m. Suggest removal

ColumbusPillow says...

Absolutely! We must determine who is NOT INFECTED and therefore able to return to work. Test everybody now!

Posted 2 November 2020, 2:44 p.m. Suggest removal

lovingbahamas says...

Mr. Myers- just wait! You’ll see a lot more twists, turns and u-turns in the road by our trusty government. No need to worry about hospitals filling up, the $60 “insurance fee” covers Med evac according to some. And, on our Family Islands, where does a person go when he tests positive after 5 days and has to get a PCR test and then wait 3-4 days for those results?

Posted 2 November 2020, 8:38 a.m. Suggest removal

Mr-G says...

3 million tests out there not to be used.. ???
lets use them for our people, please don't let them go to waste, test EVERYONE get a clear picture of were this virus is, quarantine and move forward..
Slovakia, a country of 5 million has just started testing EVERYONE FOR FREE.
use some of our resources for our people...

Posted 2 November 2020, 8:42 a.m. Suggest removal

Mr-G says...

3 million test units out there not to be used ??
lets use them for our own sake, test EVERYONE in the country, something that should have been done a long time ago, get a clear picture were we are with this virus, quarantine those infected and let the country move on...
Please don't let the 3 million units go to waste..
Slovakia, a country of 5 million has just started testing EVERYONE FOR FREE ..

Posted 2 November 2020, 8:50 a.m. Suggest removal

The_Oracle says...

So is the Coalition getting the tests delivered to ports of entry back?
Or is government keeping them but not using them in the way agreed upon?
In any case, the about face is not surprising but still incredibly disappointing.

Posted 2 November 2020, 11:50 a.m. Suggest removal

truetruebahamian says...

Like they did for the monetary and material donations by so many to Abaco after Dorian - which disappeared into the wonderland account (Wonder where it went) who received the necessary material donations and where did they go - and who profited?

Posted 2 November 2020, 5:28 p.m. Suggest removal

TalRussell says...

**Wasn't the government quick jump on Scotia Bank's decision be creating positions offshore now held by our local footprint?**
Me's goin' guess redcoats think makes logical sense during height virus attack have dispatched Dr. Delon, offshore be helpful Baltimore's sagging economy **whilst to remain physically at the 24-hour ready hands-on that one should've been expecting from a locally stationed Colony's comrade deputy chief medical officer.**
**Shakehead** once for Yeah imagine local shi* now be flying high like flagpole had Perry Gladstone only dared allowed such a **Renard authorised** Baltimore relocation, Twice for Not?

Posted 2 November 2020, 12:23 p.m. Suggest removal

JokeyJack says...

Mr. Myers, "Living with Covid Coalition"??? Seriously??? Who wants to live with Covid. We cannot "LIVE" with Covid - we can only be zombies with Covid. The society that China wants to place us in is not workable for us, and not acceptable.

This is the kind of world that the Biden folks want to create. 12 weeks ago, it appeared that Biden was going to win. Trump was down in the polls. So, likely, not to be on the wrong side - the government had to agree with your plan so they would not get in trouble with Joe after the election.

Now that Trump is clearly heading for victory, it seems the government has chosen life over zombie-life. Good choice. After he wins, Trump will very likely be firing no less than 500 people throughout the government in less than a week perhaps even within 24 hours. Draining the swamp has been shown not to work. Water pumps are needed to empty it at a super fast rate. I'm sure those pumps are fueled and primed, ready to crank up.

Life will return soon. Just say no to zombies. Refuse zombies. Do not associate with zombies. Zombies are not good - they are neither alive nor dead, often referred to as the "living dead". Not a good thing at all. Let us return to life and a respect for nature which has proven us weak and ignorant by comparison. It is hilarious that people who cannot cure the common cold are suddenly super experts and have all the answers (like saying ONLY a vaccine can solve the problem). The Earth knows more than we do.

Posted 2 November 2020, 12:55 p.m. Suggest removal

hj says...

As long as the emergency orders continue,and it looks this will last for a while,expect nothing better. The whole country will be run by one man,who will decide who can work and who can not,what time and day "you can be home or not. etc. All these decisions of course will be based on" scientific evidence" in consultation with "medical experts" But then again politicians will make sure their salaries will be fully paid with borrowed funds of course,that will be paid by the Bahamian public. The future of this country looks bright indeed.

Posted 2 November 2020, 1:07 p.m. Suggest removal

DDK says...

That's about it in a nut shell!

Posted 2 November 2020, 2:23 p.m. Suggest removal

truetruebahamian says...

That's about it until a shedding of the 'God Appointed Me' syndrome is brought under control and within the realm of fact and reality. His God and mine are of different opinions.

Posted 2 November 2020, 5:47 p.m. Suggest removal

newcitizen says...

Slovakia tested half of their population over this past weekend, 2 million+ rapid antigen tests, 6000+ locations and 20000+ workers. We can't figure out how to test the handful of tourists that show up here after 12 weeks of planning and 9 months into a pandemic. PATHETIC!

Posted 2 November 2020, 3 p.m. Suggest removal

lovingbahamas says...

And American Airlines can’t figure out how to Rapid Test in just the Miami airport for people getting on a plane. But, our government can test at 30 or 40 different locations and then figure out how to PCR the positive ones and then keep track of the positive ones and evacuate them so they don’t infect other people? Really? 3,000,000 tests? Believability is a real problem with our government.

Posted 2 November 2020, 8:32 p.m. Suggest removal

TalRussell says...

**Unlike any foreigner flying out of ground zero virus infestation Florida who has no travel restrictions or requirements to abide by before takeoff for the Abaco's,** on the other hand, should a PopoulacesOdinary at large POAL so **decide to travel from Nassau to say the Abaco's, or any other out island,** they are by Mr. Minnis's authoritarian law, **required upon their Abaco arrival to produce a full scale negative to the virus test certificate and must upon arrival undergo a mandatory 14 days quarantine.** Has all 35 House-elected redcoats MPs, now lost all their common sense marbles?
**Shakehead** once for Yeah **where is it Constituentially written** that there be's one law foreigner travelers, and another law we own POAL travelers, Twice for Not?

Posted 2 November 2020, 5:40 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment