‘IF YOU WANT WAR, YOU’LL GET WAR’: Furious Speaker shuts down Parliament over government’s inaction on COVID outbreak

By KHRISNA RUSSELL

Tribune Chief Reporter

krussell@tribunemedia.net

HOUSE Speaker Halson Moultrie accused the government of disrespecting Parliament by ignoring and refusing to implement his COVID-19 preventative measures, leading him to abruptly adjourn yesterday’s sitting until May 3.

As he chided the Minnis administration, Mr Moultrie urged members of the governing side not to “pick fights or wars,” adding “if you want a war, you can get a war”.

His rebuke was sparked yesterday by confirmation on Tuesday that a senior House of Assembly staffer had tested positive for COVID-19.

Despite this, Mr Moultrie revealed that not only was the House not sanitised before parliamentarians attended yesterday’s sitting, but he suggested that concerns were ignored by Leader of Government Business in the House Renward Wells and brushed off by Prime Minister Dr Hubert Minnis.

He said against his orders that staffers self-isolate due to possible exposure to the positive senior Parliament employee, another staffer was ordered out of quarantine and into yesterday’s session.

He reiterated that his previous recommendation for less seats in the House of Assembly and to adjust to a virtual setting had been blatantly ignored.

“This day is indeed a sad day for me,” Speaker Moultrie told the House. “Firstly, because the closest person in this Parliament to me as Speaker is not well today and we pray for his speedy recovery from this COVID-19 coronavirus.

“Honourable members today causes me to reflect on the circumstances that lead us here to this point today in that, one year ago approximately, we began the protocols based on the proclamation of emergency with respect to this COVID pandemic.

“Whenever we accept leadership positions the first thing we must do and recognise is that we should lead by example and so if we put protocols in place, we should be prepared to live by the established protocols because if we fail to do so, the general public who we represent cannot be expected to abide by those protocols.”

He continued: “Now if we look around this assembly today, we would note that we are in breach of our own protocols. We established a certain physical distancing within this Parliament.

“The Speaker announced those protocols and some authority, who believes that they have jurisdiction over the Speaker’s jurisdiction in this legislative branch, has caused numerous chairs to be added to this assembly in breach of the physical distancing protocols. Yet, we expect the public to abide by such protocols.

“In September last year the Speaker suggested to this Parliament that we should pass a resolution, like many other Parliaments in this Commonwealth Parliamentary Association (have) done to this point and time, so that this Parliament can meet in a hybrid form either face-to-face or virtually, but then again the Speaker’s recommendation was either ignored or refused.”

He said it was possible that the House was contaminated as it had not been sanitised and revealed what transpired on Tuesday upon confirmation of the senior staffer’s condition.

“So, we find ourselves today meeting in a Parliament that can be contaminated as a consequence of the coronavirus, in a Parliament that has not been sanitised since we discovered that the clerk of this Parliament has been affected.

“The most challenging matter to me was yesterday –  in the process of dealing with this matter with the staff of this Parliament – I made numerous attempts to communicate the situation with the member for Killarney (Dr Minnis) and with the member for Bamboo Town (Mr Wells).

“The staffers of Parliament we assembled in these very chambers waiting for answers. We got one response in one word from the member for Killarney and that was ‘noted’.

“We wanted to find out how we should proceed today, and we wanted to find out whether or not the staff, who were in a challenged position financially to take the test, would be able to go to a government clinic to take those tests or to have those tests paid for in a private institution by the government and we waited and we waited and we waited and got no response.”

He said the matter was further exacerbated by the lack of independence of Parliament with an anomaly over the pay of the chief clerk.

“This matter is further exacerbated by the fact that with the lack of the independence of this institution an anomaly has been created in the appointment of the clerk where the clerk’s salary is below that of subordinate staff.

“Any person in management would tell you that this is a grave anomaly that would undermine the very morality and administrative authority of the clerk of Parliament and for two years we have been trying to get this anomaly corrected,” Mr Moultrie said, adding they had also been trying for two years to have the deputy clerk’s position confirmed.

“The Cabinet Office, which seems to think that it controls the Parliament and the legislative branch of government, has refused the confirmation—refused.”

He added that despite indicating that the staff go into quarantine as they could not take COVID tests, another senior staffer was called upon to report for duty against his instructions.

“Now this to me was my final straw when it comes to the disrespect of this institution and the disrespect of the Office of the Speaker. I see it as a grave disorder and according to the rules of this Parliament if, in the opinion of the Speaker the behaviour of any member is creating disorder, level of disrespect to this Parliament, the Speaker is authorised by Rule 88(9) to have that circumstance corrected and to adjourn this Parliament until such circumstance is corrected.

“Now I don’t necessarily pick fights or wars, but if you want a war, you can get a war. They say if you don’t want a war don’t start one.

“So, don’t come in this Parliament talking about reading books of war because more than one person in this Parliament reads books of war and as a consequence, pursuant to Rule 88(9) this Parliament is hereby adjourned to May 3 at 10am.”

The normal practice is for a member of the governing side in Parliament to move a motion to adjourn the House until a specified date.

Comments

bahamianson says...

if you want war, you will have war. Wow, so, we are going back to the stone age . I thought we are to settle our differences via communication? I know he doesn't mean this literally, but please use other words to express yourself. it is too aggressive.

Posted 29 April 2021, 8:03 a.m. Suggest removal

JokeyJack says...

He tried communication, the response was "noted." That qualifies to you? We are mere inches away from dictatorship in this country and are blessed to have someone standing up.
What would happen if tomorrow morning at 6am the poluce were ordered to arrest Moultre, he had a quick closed door hearing and a judge ordered him remanded to prison?
What would happen? Who would stand up for him? Who would stand up for me or you?
The DNA candidates were already arrested and their charges are still pending. They could all be put in prison eith him anfld what would happen?
Nothing.
The State Dept would just have to add an extra sentence in their report next year, that's all.
Of course you would say none of that could happen. Nothing happens until it happens. Worldwide shutdowns? Could never happen.

Posted 29 April 2021, 4:05 p.m. Suggest removal

bahamianson says...

Imagine for a moment that our headlines read, " The Bahamas is Vaccinating 2000 people per day". The United States would report this and be in awe. The CDC would drop us to level 2 or 1 because of our response to the vaccination. It would encourage its citizens to visit a place where the citizens are taking the pandemic seriously. what do we have? we have a country that may vaccinate 100 per day, maybe. We have a population of around 450,000 and only 27,000 vaccinated in 1-2 months. !0,000 have contracted the virus. That adds up to 37,000 in a population of 450,000. at this rate , we will reach herd immunity in 20 years. so, about 200,000 people have to contract the virus and we are only at 10,000. We have a long way to go.

Posted 29 April 2021, 8:09 a.m. Suggest removal

tribanon says...

You're conveniently ignoring a two very important considerations here:

1) Many of the untested and unvaccinated have already been exposed to the original Wuhan virus or one of its variants and they therefore constitute a big part of the so called "herd";

AND

2) Minnis, being the incompetent, arrogant, bullying, power-crazed and most untrustworthy failed leader that he is, could never have planned and put in place the type of successful vaccination program you speak of - instead he has run our economy right into the ground.

Posted 29 April 2021, 9:36 a.m. Suggest removal

professionalbahamian says...

Hey if you are closing down because you don’t know how to wash your hands regularly please do take a 75% pay cut for the sake of the treasury!

A vaccine drive is the key out of this mess not ego.

Posted 29 April 2021, 8:17 a.m. Suggest removal

tribanon says...

And no one has bigger chip on his shoulder than our megalomanical and tyrannical dictator. Minnis.

Posted 29 April 2021, 9:52 a.m. Suggest removal

JokeyJack says...

Hey, thanks buddy. When the police try to arrest me for not wearing a mask, i will just mention your name. Very grateful to ya.

Posted 29 April 2021, 4:08 p.m. Suggest removal

DDK says...

Off his rocker🤣 Hand-picked by another ego-maniac!

Posted 29 April 2021, 11:27 a.m. Suggest removal

TalRussell says...

My Comrades, scary knowing here on the Realm's 1200 Out Islands, Cays, and Rocks, how it came about that a local opposition leader and members **were directly ordered by the highest of the Constabulary Authority** to be placed under arrest to undergo hours interrogation - shouldn't it awakens enough be alerting the PopoulacesCommoners', not to wait until after the heads local opposition leaders are clean-shaven, **including the head of the already face-gaunted House Speaker Halson,** are clean-shaven,** to begin to submit to more reading of distant stuff like when, "Alexei Anatolievich Navalny, **a Russian opposition leader, lawyer, and anti-corruption activist.** has appeared in court **from prison, head close-shaven** and face gaunt, and accused Vladimir Putin of attempting to rule Russia "forever" and caring only about "clinging to power."
High likely is the **arrest and interrogation** of the House Speaker - may be in the makin', yes?

Posted 29 April 2021, 12:01 p.m. Suggest removal

JokeyJack says...

He will most certainly be arrested or banned from the House by force and a new Speaker installed. C.A. Smith and Her Majesty will both watch only as spectators.

Posted 29 April 2021, 4:11 p.m. Suggest removal

DDK says...

Wow, Comrade, scary indeed!

Posted 29 April 2021, 2:08 p.m. Suggest removal

John says...

Should the prime minister also known as the competent authority be arrested and charged with breeches of the emergency protocols? Endangering lives even? Should he be fined $2,000 for calling an assembly in a place known to be infected with Covid-19 or, at least someone in that space to have the virus? Should he be further charged $300 for everyone that attended the assembly yesterday? Especially after failing to have the chamber’s properly cleaned.

Posted 29 April 2021, 2:37 p.m. Suggest removal

tribanon says...

If you're asking whether Minnis thinks he's about law, I can assure you he thinks in a most unequivocal and emphatic way that he's above all of 'his ordered laws' that apply to the rest of us.

Posted 29 April 2021, 3:15 p.m. Suggest removal

JokeyJack says...

Those are tiny amounts for him to pay as a multi-millionaire. Would mean nothing.

Posted 29 April 2021, 4:12 p.m. Suggest removal

TalRussell says...

@Comrades, The 34 House-elected redcoats' wrongly thinkin' use **the private toilet** issue - against the Honourable House Speaker Dewitt Halson, yes?

Posted 29 April 2021, 7:18 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment