‘BEATING’ COP PUT ON LEAVE: Force moves quickly on voice recording of ‘assault’ on suspect

By LEANDRA ROLLE

Tribune Staff Reporter

lrolle@tribunemedia.net

A POLICE officer has been placed on administrative leave pending the outcome of an investigation into an alarming, widely circulated voice note purporting police brutality and alleged assault of a man while in custody.

In the four-minute-long recording, an officer, who identifies himself as an assistant police superintendent, can be heard shouting and beating a man.

It is not clear what led to the confrontation. However, the incident took place during a conversation between another male officer and a man in custody, who is questioning the charges being brought against him.

About one minute into the recording, the officer at the centre of the audio’s controversy starts cursing and hitting the man in custody.

“My name is…assistant superintendent of police. You hear me? Put your hands down. Put your hands down. Look at me,” the officer in question said as a loud slap is heard.

“There you go. That’s what he needs,” another officer added, while laughing.

“Don’t mix me up, okay? Don’t mix me up with nobody else. You see these boys here. Don’t mix me up,” the ASP says amid what sounds like slaps. “You hear me? I talking to you. Did you hear me?”

To which the man in custody replied: “Yes, sir.”

“Sit your a-- down. Don’t ever shout at me,” the ASP continued.

Later in the audio, one officer can be heard bragging about beating drug dealers.

Police Commissioner Paul Rolle confirmed to reporters that the officer directly involved in the incident had been suspended. However, it is not clear what action has been taken against the officers who encouraged the move.

“Someone sent (the audio) to me yesterday,” the police chief said. “But I have taken a course of action. The officer involved, the complaint unit is conducting their investigations into that matter and the officer has been placed on administrative leave and that will go through the due process and I want to say that I don’t support that type of behaviour by no police officer on the Royal Bahamas Police Force.

“I think it is fair to say that I have been doing a whole lot to improve the image of this organisation and I will continue to do that. Each officer will be judged according to their own conduct and that matter is, as I said, under investigation.”

Similar incidents showing questionable police conduct have made the rounds on social media in the past, with residents long lamenting the harsh intimidating tactics sometimes used by officers.

In February, Commissioner Rolle admitted that he had to deal with “a few” officers who acted inappropriately when citing businesses found in breach of the COVID-19 Emergency Orders.

Yesterday, the police chief said he continues to remind police on how they ought to behave when carrying out their duties and interacting with the general public.

Yesterday, the victim’s attorney Craig Butler told a local talk show host that his client, who also happens to be his nephew, was just one of three men allegedly brutalised by police while in custody.

He said the trio were arrested together following a recent altercation that happened on Arawak Cay recently. Mr Butler is representing the three men.

“These are three young men - 26, 23 and 19 - (who) were leaving the Arawak Cay area and they were minding their own business and one of the other men was attacked by two young men out of a car, so in trying to get away from that fracas and this is when the police emerged,” he said while appearing as a guest on The Hit Back with Nahaja Black.

“They came in not fully understanding what was going on and interjected themselves and in that way, the other two boys and my nephew were arrested, taken into the police station and (allegedly) brutalised.”

Speaking on his nephew’s injuries, Mr Butler said: “I saw him Monday afternoon (March 1) before he went to a private doctor. I observed the injuries for myself. The footprint was still on my nephew’s shirt. The next thing I advised my clients to do was to take all of the clothes, the same that are not being washed and we put it in bags and sealed it as evidence.”

Speaking to reporters on the issue yesterday, National Security Minister Marvin Dames said it is under investigation.

He also strongly condemned the action and insisted the police force will not tolerate such acts.

“Yes, the police is aware,” he said before going into a Cabinet meeting on Tuesday. “During my conversations with the commissioner today, that matter is in hand and it will be addressed as soon as possible to determine exactly what it all means and what’s going on there.

“…I get it frequently from members of the public, not only involving police officers but anything relating to social issues and crime and so I’m very aware of it. I listened to it and we want to get to the bottom of this … and I’m very confident in my discussions and conversations with him this morning that he would do the right thing to ensure he gets the answers he needs.”

Asked yesterday if he was concerned that such incidents undermine the reputation of police, Mr Dames replied: “This is the era that we’re living in. I mean as things happen, they are being disseminated. This is the world that we’re living in today and so we talk about body cams and dash cams when we have cellphones which is just as good and just about everyone walking has a cellphone in his or her hands.

“You can record video or voice recording and so those of us in authority should act accordingly and I think it’s a good thing and not saying that this is the first time we would’ve had an incident such as this – no, this is the world that we’re living in.”

He added: “Everything is under the microscope and so it’s incumbent upon public officers to conduct themselves accordingly as they are hired by the people… for the most part, a vast majority of officers and those in law enforcement are good, decent people who would’ve taken an oath and are standing by the oath which they took and they take their jobs very seriously. There are times when officers go astray and when they go astray, then they ought to be dealt with.”

Comments

DWW says...

everyone knows RBPF is many thugs and criminals among the ranks. I know many good hard working officers but i have also met some really shady ones too.

Posted 10 March 2021, 8:30 a.m. Suggest removal

SP says...

The country is riddled with systemic corruption. How can anyone expect majority of cops to be anything else but corrupt?

We will get rid of thug cops when we get rid of decades of corrupt politicians that empowered corrupt cops.

Posted 10 March 2021, 8:47 a.m. Suggest removal

tell_it_like_it_is says...

This officer is being investigated. What about the countless others? They seem to beat **suspects** for fun. Then, later if they are found innocent, who cares? smh🤦‍♂️

Posted 10 March 2021, 10:45 a.m. Suggest removal

bogart says...

@Tell_it_like_it_is. There are likely to be countless other reasons of just beating persons just for "fun". And @SP. The systemic system has been to wait a few weeks JUST before Political Elections called for the governing party to then have the widespread Police Promotions done. Indeed. Time for the system of Police Force Promotions to be chànged not to coincide closely before Elections but closely done according to Merits of the Officer and requirements of the Department(s) to be à more effective and continuous fluid efficient force. Putting masses of promotions At one time tended to be bizarre when the results have more top indian chiefs and few indians. Lol.

Posted 10 March 2021, 12:16 p.m. Suggest removal

Sickened says...

But if we purge the rotten police out of the force what will we have left - a couple dozen competent cops? Not enough to man two stations let alone patrols. We just have far too much crime for our population. We need a complete purge of gang members and independent drug dealers by any means necessary.
Perhaps we can send in the violent police to battle the gangs to the death - win/win?

Posted 10 March 2021, 9:12 a.m. Suggest removal

KapunkleUp says...

Live stream it on a pay per view basis. I like it but the problem is that these cops are all a bunch of girly girls who are hiding behind their badges. I've come across a few of these so called police and the only thing that protects them from having the snot beat out of them by everyone else in the neighborhood is their badge. One on one without their "police status", they would wet themselves just walking down the street.

Posted 10 March 2021, 9:49 a.m. Suggest removal

bahamianson says...

we need a purge day. the country is corrupt , we all are.

Posted 10 March 2021, 9:23 a.m. Suggest removal

John says...

Is Paul Rolle sincere in his actions or is he trying to save face in light of irrefutable evidence against the police officers? Then the question is begged, ‘Who made the recording?’ Police obviously need more training and accountability. Slapping suspects around and bragging about is so 1980’s-1990’s. Do some real policing. What is criminal justice?

Posted 10 March 2021, 10:50 a.m. Suggest removal

sheeprunner12 says...

Good questions ................. A lot of details left unsaid by the COP

God knows if these matters will ever see the light of day

Posted 10 March 2021, 1:33 p.m. Suggest removal

xtreme2x says...

***Asked yesterday if he was concerned that such incidents undermine the reputation of police,***

Reporter ask the above question to Dames. He did not answer it. He talk about alot of other stuff, But did not answer.

Posted 10 March 2021, 2:05 p.m. Suggest removal

birdiestrachan says...

Commissioner Rolle did say. if anyone confronts the Police be prepared to meet one's

maker. It means one will die.

Those are very strong words. how it is viewed is another story.

Posted 10 March 2021, 2:23 p.m. Suggest removal

birdiestrachan says...

WHY did Mr: Dames buy body cams. if cell phones are Just as good.?

Posted 10 March 2021, 2:30 p.m. Suggest removal

John says...

The body cams are supposed to be activated when an officer leaves the station or reports for duty and continue to record for the duration of his shift. The officer cannot access or delete any footage on his camera. In fact some police cameras are set up where a third party stores the recordings and access is restricted.

Posted 10 March 2021, 3:02 p.m. Suggest removal

mandela says...

There has to be footage from inside the station lets view them, please, case closed,

Posted 10 March 2021, 3:06 p.m. Suggest removal

sheeprunner12 says...

Is any camera evidence from inside a police station entered into evidence in a judicial court of law???? ............. Or is it reserved for use ONLY by the "police court"????

Posted 10 March 2021, 3:20 p.m. Suggest removal

John says...

With The British now seeking to establish a warmer relationship with this country after its exit from the European Union, hopefully they will attempt to temper the negative and undue influence some of the US agencies have over this country’s armed forces. Some that clearly leads to violations of civil rights and death without accountability in some cases. The ambassador already says she was not in favor of the many black and grey listings launched against this country in the financial sector and ventured that Britain will, most likely, not be following suit with such listings in the future.

Posted 10 March 2021, 4:14 p.m. Suggest removal

John says...

Ok try wrap your mind around what is going on. Marvin Dames and Paul Rolle say the high incidence of murder s because of gangsters shooting each other for drug turf and retaliation. But which victim has been more riddled with bullets than when Paul Rolle and Marvin Dames officers shoot them. Y’all ain’t serious. The police are the most brutal, heartless murderers in The Bahamas! Agent Marvin Dames MUST GO!

Posted 10 March 2021, 9:13 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment