ALICIA WALLACE: Soundbites and social media won’t change a thing - we must force through a new mindset on gender-based violence

A FEW years ago I woke up to the sound of an argument in the street. A woman was telling a man to stop, telling him to let her go, telling him to leave her alone. I looked out the window to see them in the middle of the street, him behind her, his arm around her neck. He was berating her as he dragged her along. Their movement was slow. She was struggling.

I called the police but they never showed up that night. I could stand at the window and watch, go back to bed, or find a way to intervene. It did not take a long time for me to decide to do something to help, but I had to think quickly about how to be effective and minimise the risk for myself. In situations like that, we not only have to consider our responsibility to each other and dedication to whatever we believe in, but our own safety. We are regularly reminded the police are ill-equipped and, in most cases, by the time we call the police, it is (too) late.

Over the past few months, headlines have shown us that gender-based violence against women is a pervasive issue that is not being appropriately addressed. When reports of gender-based killing and domestic violence make it to the news, there is shock. “How could this happen here?” “What is wrong with these people?” “This place really changed for the worse!” There is outrage. “Something must be done!” “We need stiffer penalties!” “Time to hang these people!”

Gender-based violence against women is not new and it has not just arrived here. Not only are there serious problems with violent people, but we need to address the issue of violent and unresponsive systems. We need to understand the root of gender-based violence in order to end it. This means dismantling patriarchy - the socio-political system designed for men to hold the power, be dominant and have absolute control, authority and ownership of and over women - in all of its forms, including those that are considered “traditional” or “cute.” Think, for example, of fathers “giving away” their daughter to marry their husbands as though it is a transfer of property. These practices are not without consequence.

WE CAN AGREE, POLICE FAIL US REGULARLY

I have called the police and been told there were no cars available. I have gone to the police station and spent hours making a report. I have been told I cannot have a copy of my own report. I have been told by a 9-1-1 operator to leave safety to directly engage a party before they would send assistance. I have received a personal phone call from a police officer I have accompanied other people to make police reports after they had been turned away. I have heard the stories of women who have been harassed and stalked, documented the events and been told nothing can be done to protect them. I remember the murder of Alicia Sawyer and her daughter and the report she had gone to police to record the threats against her.

I know there are multiple problems with the police. I have seen the failings of law enforcement and the so-called justice system. We need an alternative to police and it will take research, imagination and consultation to develop it.

We all know the existing systems do not work and they were not designed to meet the needs we have now. Most people do not report gender-based violence and most people who report do not want to go through the painful, difficult process that is the court system. This is not a lack of strength or bravery on their part. This is a clear indication that what we have not only does not work, but does harm and puts lives at risk. Reform of systems and practices has to start with a foundation that includes an understanding of gender, knowledge about gender-based violence and the forms it takes, and the engagement of experts and survivors.

During the Global 16 Days Campaign, Equality Bahamas clearly stated its six demands and highlighted 16 CEDAW recommendations that need to be acted upon. This was a little over one month ago, when people were “oranging the world” to end gender-based violence, and there were a few short periods of outrage following reports of gender-based violence. Still, there have been no commitments to action from politicians. There are empty statements all the time, from senators and Members of Parliament, but no one is helped and no lives are saved by those soundbites and social media posts. We need them to take specific actions as a matter of urgency.

A STARTING POINT

The National Strategic Plan to End Gender-based Violence was published in 2015. The task force was chaired by Retired Justice Ruby Nottage with deputy chairs Dr Sandra Dean- Patterson and Dr Robin Roberts. It focused on prevention, protection and accountability with a vision of eliminating gender-based violence through a zero-tolerance approach.

Sub-committees focused on the criminal justice system, medical and psycho-social, communications, services for survivors, perpetrators and families, surveillance, data collection and information management, Family Island advocacy and education and training.

There was an assessment of The Bahamas at that time and recommendations were made including the establishment of a statutory Gender-based Violence Authority to facilitate the process of implementing the Plan and establishment of a national protocol which would include a Victim’s Advocate. Within its implementation strategy, the Plan lists “the ten low hanging fruit” which are practical and could be implemented with relative ease and within a short period of time. They include creation of a unified family court system, a national awareness programme on gender-based violence, a sexual assault response team project, programmes for men and boys and programmes for perpetrators.

The Strategic Plan to End Gender-based Violence is 184 pages long. It is rather thorough and organised in a way that makes it easy to read and easy to identify the action steps. I point this out because we all need to understand the government is not at a loss. It is not without the tools to do what needs to be done. We have research and researchers. We have plans and draft policies. We have stories and statistics. We have people who are capable of reviewing, editing, recommending and training. What we do not have is the political will required to get this done. It is on us, people in The Bahamas, to create the political will by making the elimination of gender-based violence a priority and a tool by which we measure performance and commitment to us.

What does this mean? We have to demand the Members of Parliament state their positions on gender-based violence. We have to reject the empty “violence is wrong” statements and demand answers to specific questions. Will you support a bill to criminalise marital rape and call it rape? Will you provide training on gender-based violence to your staff? How will you encourage your colleagues to support women’s rights and the elimination of violence against women? What are you doing to ensure The Bahamas takes steps toward compliance with CEDAW?

It also means we have to use our own power and influence and hold others with power and influence accountable for the way they use it. If you are an employer, look for ways to protect your employees. Provide gender-based violence training and bystander intervention training. Read the International Labour Organization’s Convention 190 and Recommendation 206 and make clear commitments toward the elimination of violence and harassment in the world of work. Consider ways to support employees who are experiencing violence which can include flexible schedules, working remotely and time off.

Speak to your faith leaders. What are their positions on domestic violence? Marital rape? The gender-based killing of women and girls? How do they talk about marriage? How do they talk about relations between men and women? What does that mean for your participation in the organisations they run and the spaces they control? Think about the ways you support, directly or indirectly, people who do not support women’s rights, blame victims of gender-based killing, or dehumanise women.

Pay attention to what they say in the media and the impact it has on survivors, family members of victims, perpetrators and the general public. You can challenge their positions. You can withdraw your support. You can encourage those who are quiet in their positions of support to speak up and join the people who are working every day to protect women, to save women’s lives.

Politicians listen to people of influence - people they believe drive votes. They are followers, so use your power to set trends. Implement measures within your organization and become a model. Go public with your initiatives and let the country see what you are doing. Challenge other organisations and the government to do the same, or to do more.

As an individual, ask the difficult questions and make them specific. Write to your MP. Write to cabinet ministers. Make it public. Call the radio talk shows, post on social media and let your positions be known in your social circles. We, quite literally, have to be the change. We have to do what we want to see done, apply pressure on those in positions to do it at higher levels and on larger scales - and be loud about it.

The outrage is useless once it dissipates in a few days. Take some time to focus on what you have the power to do and how you can use your influence to end gender-based violence and move others to take action too.

Comments

joeblow says...

... what a crock of nonsense. If having a discussion about violence you have to consider not only physical violence (which many women are capable of inflicting on men) , but psychological violence as well. Many men may have physical strength, but many women know how to use their tongues to psychologically traumatize men as well. In fact the effects of psychological violence last far longer than physical. Many women can say and do things that push men over the edge, where is the help for them?

The point is simply that women are not the only ones who may suffer in relationships, men suffer too and the attempt to pit one group against the other or to see one group as having more urgent needs is ridiculous. We need a cultural reset, but how can that happen when we encourage broken homes and do not value the discipline that is necessary to create courteous and respectful, self controlled citizens?

Posted 27 January 2022, 8:17 a.m. Suggest removal

1pnewman says...

Men like you are really part of the problem. This need to attribute a false sense of equivalency in gender issues such as this, is beyond stupid and uninformed. Men are BIGGER AND STRONGER than women. When it comes to gender based abuse be it physical or mental, men are responsible for 85% of the abuse and attacks. Do you comprehend that dynamic ? Its so overwhelming that there is no need for idiots like you to keep maintaining that there is some kind of level playing field at work here. Face up to and acknowledge that the abuse of women and girls is on the rise all around the world, not just here in The Bahamas and open your ears and mind.

Posted 27 January 2022, 12:30 p.m. Suggest removal

joeblow says...

... abuses in men will be underreported because of strong societal influences not to complain, so it is unlikely you can accurately note the rates of abuses in men, but clearly you fail to comprehend the actual point that was being made which that both sides abuse in different ways and aid should be offered to both whenever that happens. Unfortunately many men have nowhere to go when they are suffering from the abuses they experience in relationships or are they unimportant as well?

Posted 27 January 2022, 5:35 p.m. Suggest removal

1pnewman says...

You don't seem to get the point that is at the centre of this. There is no 'both sides' argument here. There is no 'not to complain' issue here. Those are outliers in this issue. The VAST amount of abuse is conducted by men against women. The VAST majority of domestic homicides are men killing women. There is no equivalency. All you are doing is deflecting by highlighting what you believe is men being overlooked by society in these cases. That is NOT a statistic that anyone with any type of understanding would say needs addressing over domestic violence perpetuated by males.

Posted 27 January 2022, 8:17 p.m. Suggest removal

Twocent says...

The point is this…. All violence and abuse is an evil that needs to end! The fight against violence and abuse is not a gender issue but a moral and ethical issue. Within that moral and ethical issue 85% of the focus will be drawn towards one demographic because of data and numbers; it does not mean that the other 15% should remain silent or ignored!

Posted 27 January 2022, 9:33 p.m. Suggest removal

joeblow says...

... perfect summary! Sad that these "social justice" warriors are so busy imbibing and spewing propagandist buzzwords in order to virtue signal their moral superiority that they lack the capacity for critical thought on any matter and shut down discourse that does not reflect their worldview!

Posted 28 January 2022, 8:07 a.m. Suggest removal

1pnewman says...

If 85% of domestic killings are conducted by men against women you wouldn't define that as a gender issue? Are you being purposely obtuse? Morals and ethics are concepts instilled in people through many channels and they involve distinguishing between right and wrong. So your argument is these men commit these acts because they don't know that they are wrong or 'evil' to use your emotive, religious term. We should however not condemn them because in the very few cases that are the opposite dynamic ; women display the same lack of morals/ethics. Utter garbage. You acknowledge the perpetrator, be it male or female but the reality is that men are committing CRIMINAL acts when they abuse and murder their partners/wives. The fight against violence and abuse is NOT a moral or ethical one, but a criminal one. We need to start prosecuting more of these men and setting examples to the boys who unfortunately are witness to some of it.

Posted 28 January 2022, 10:46 a.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment