Electric cars are a risk of electrocution

EDITOR, The Tribune.

In the 2022/2023 Budget Communication, Prime Minister Philip Brave Davis announced that his government will reduce the duty rate on electric vehicles valued under $70,000 to 10 percent. Electric vehicles over $70,000 will be reduced to 25 percent. I read in one of the dailies that sales for these vehicles are increasing, which is probably due to the historic oil inflation caused by the anti-fossil fuel policies of President Joe Biden and the Russian/Ukrainian War. Before well-to-do Bahamians in Nassau and Grand Bahama invest their hard-earned money into these vehicles, there’s something important they must factor into consideration.

Electric vehicles are an electrocution hazard like any other electronic device that uses significant amounts of electricity. For instance, a residential electric clothes dryer uses between 1,500 and 5,000 watts. Like electric vehicles while charging, dryers run on 240 volts with a 30-amp breaker on a single circuit installed for it. Similar to an electric dryer, electric vehicles are energised on 240-volt chargers and use just over 7,000 watts of electricity. No sane person would attempt to tamper with an electric dryer or any other appliance while ankle deep in water. Such an individual runs the risk of being electrocuted, which brings me back to my original point about electric vehicles in flood-prone Nassau and Grand Bahama. Just this past weekend parts of Grand Bahama and Bimini were flooded up to nearly 11 inches of rain by Tropical Cyclone Alex.

Several weeks ago, many communities in Nassau were also flooded. Understand, the two rainstorms were not even tropical storms, let alone a cat 4 or 5 storm that usually is accompanied by a storm surge. In low lying Grand Bahama and New Providence, flooding is inevitable. Now imagine a family of five in Pinewood Gardens during a cat 4 storm attempting to escape the flooding in their community by driving their Tesla Model Y through 3 feet of water, which is something US manufacturers strongly advise against, as water serves as a conductor of electricity. If water gets into the Tesla vehicle, there’s a good chance the family might be electrocuted to death. It would also pose a significant risk to others wading through the same water near the vehicle. Electric vehicles need a significant amount of current in order to rotate the driveshaft. The manufacturers of these models obviously were not thinking about low-lying New Providence and Grand Bahama.

Even if the vehicles are reinforced and sealed to prevent an electrocution, everything that man has invented is subject to the second law of thermodynamics. We see this everyday with the used cars imported into the country. Bahamians prefer to purchase used vehicles, which are far more affordable than brand new ones. Will the government thoroughly examine each used electric vehicle to ensure that they are safe? With our track record of slackness and alleged corruption in the civil service, it is not too difficult to envisage compromised vehicles slipping through the net, which will endanger the lives of many Bahamians during a rainstorm.

In view of the foregoing, it is my opinion that electric vehicles are not safe for Nassau and Grand Bahama.

KEVIN EVANS

Freeport,

Grand Bahama,

June 8, 2022.

Comments

FreeportFreddy says...

You stoopid

Posted 10 June 2022, 5:59 p.m. Suggest removal

pileit says...

Sheer, absolute, deliberately uninformed ignorance. Hurry up and tell the entire automotive industry that is shifting design and production from hybrid to pure EV as we speak.... I guess they didn't factor in what you so brilliantly observed. Absolute tripe, once again. Let's be better, Bahamas, we can't be this flippin dumb.

Posted 10 June 2022, 7:43 p.m. Suggest removal

themessenger says...

Armchair analyst Evans usually does his homework more thoroughly before opining on a subject he obviously, in this case, has little knowledge of.
But, as they say a little knowledge is a dangerous thing and common sense isn’t all that common.

Posted 11 June 2022, 7:56 a.m. Suggest removal

i_land_boy says...

So I guess we need to rip down all the high voltage power lines, and tell all the electricians to go home. We should remember that stupid island folk have no place around smart people tings. The person who wrote this obviously hasn’t seen how some of our local mechanics are rebuilding hybrid, and electric car battery packs.

Just remember, we stupid island idiots have no place trying to educate ourselves, or trying to fix things that are new to us.

To me this just sounds like a dumb brainwashed MAGA supporting Bahamian.

Posted 11 June 2022, 8 a.m. Suggest removal

DDK says...

I certainly don't think this is a stupid letter. Reports show that their IS a risk of electrocution in both electric and hybrid vehicles, both while driving and charging. Water and electricity certainly do not mix well!

Posted 11 June 2022, 2:56 p.m. Suggest removal

Bobsyeruncle says...

There's also a significnt risk of a fire or explosion from petrol combustion engine, but that doesn't deter people from driving them. Heck the process of combustion in your engine is basically a controlled explosion.

Oh, and Mr Evans, regular petrol powered vehicles have plenty of electrical wiring in them. And before you respond with the fact that it's only 12 volts, that's more than enough to start a fire or electrocute yourself. I dare you to drop a wrench across the positive and negative terminals of your car battery.

Posted 11 June 2022, 5:02 p.m. Suggest removal

newcitizen says...

Why is this even published? The Tribune just loves to include letters that really demonstrate the level of critical thinking that gets taught in our school system.

Posted 13 June 2022, 12:05 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment