Friday, July 28, 2023
By RASHAD ROLLE and JADE RUSSELL
Tribune Staff Reporters
BAHAMAS Power and Light CEO Shevonn Cambridge said if he had been involved in installing Wartsila’s engines in 2019, he likely would have agreed with the decisions his predecessors made, choices that have since had difficult consequences for the company’s ability to provide reliable power.
Mr Cambridge said the Wartsila engines are “somewhat compromised” and do not work as well as they would have worked if BPL had stuck with the original engine plans.
He said the reasons the plans were changed are complicated and reflect decisions made under intense pressure to provide reliable electricity.
His comments came after Prime Minister Philip “Brave” Davis said on Wednesday that the Wartsila engines “never worked properly” and described the situation as “rotten”.
Mr Cambridge was less harsh in his conclusion.
He said BPL’s initial plans to install four Wartsilla tri-fuel engines were disrupted when a fire erupted at Clifton Pier in 2018, destroying the plant’s two largest units.
“When you lose your two largest engines at Clifton Pier in a fire,” he said, “they needed additional capacity immediately to replace the shortfall from BPL’s own plant.”
Mr Cambridge said rather than put the four engines in a new station, BPL officials responded by putting them in a repurposed station along with three other machines.
“They wound up putting seven engines in there,” he said. “Here’s the thing. You have time, you have capacity and you have cost issues.”
He said officials did not build the system using an ideal “redundancy format”, instead installing “single systems”, “single fuel pump, single oil pump, single cooling oil system.”
“You put new engines in, but the support systems were not built at the usual redundancies that you put as a base in those plants, and the cooling water system was not optimal or as the manufacturers wanted it to be,” he said. “And they also didn’t put in the fuel treatment equipment to facilitate the operation of the unit on HFO, which is why they wound up burning 33 per cent HFO as opposed to the 60 per cent what was envisioned when the plant was designed.
“Because of the corners that were cut, so to speak, the performance of the plant was not what it would’ve been if it were installed by designed.”
Mr Cambridge wants to stay out of the blame game and to avoid the politics surrounding electricity issues in The Bahamas.
“I would like to think that under the circumstances, those were the best decisions to make,” he said.
“I will say, given what we were going through or what the country was going through then, in terms of right after the fire and the four, eight-hour rolling blackouts, I cannot be critical of the decisions because I probably would have agreed with the decision.”
Comments
AnObserver says...
Let us not forget that the two "largest engines" were lost due to Laurel and Hardy levels of incompetence on the part of BEC and it's employees.
Posted 28 July 2023, 10:23 a.m. Suggest removal
benniesun says...
Today's word and today's phrase are "innate" and "penny wise and pound foolish'"
innate: an innate quality or ability is something you are born with.
penny wise and pound foolish: not willing to spend small amounts of money, but likely to spend large amounts in a stupid way.
BPL'S many degreed boy wonder - aka Captain Clueless - refuses to criticize his predecessors as he knows that the same will be thrown at him at the end of his term. History has proven that they all are/were innately penny wise and pound foolish - this is easily proven from their works. We simply have to accept a dim visionless future from BPL.
Posted 28 July 2023, 11:55 a.m. Suggest removal
Sickened says...
Birdie - We are all waiting to hear from you.
Posted 28 July 2023, 2:03 p.m. Suggest removal
realfreethinker says...
Something sounds fishy here. before the current gov came to power' load shedding was a thing of the past. I have it from good sources that had the current gov kept the team they met in place they were extremely close to solving the generation problem.
Posted 28 July 2023, 2:51 p.m. Suggest removal
birdiestrachan says...
So Mr Cambridge if you would have agreed to purchase those engines and I do respect your oponion, so sir what is the solution and how soon will you correct the situation
Posted 28 July 2023, 8:18 p.m. Suggest removal
ted4bz says...
I'm sure this is not an engineering problem, its a political one. With personal and political interest involved in government and politics, who was expecting this not to go wrong. If this was a private company without the involvement of politicians, this would have gone right.
Posted 28 July 2023, 8:22 p.m. Suggest removal
Socrates says...
two comments.. we never know the full story, only the parts that support the narrative the 'gods' want to push. 2nd part, the negative consequences of big government.
Posted 30 July 2023, 1:24 p.m. Suggest removal
Commenting has been disabled for this item.