EDITORIAL: A vote passed - but what is mission in Haiti?

THE UN Security Council vote yesterday to send a multinational armed force to Haiti brings with it the very real prospect that Bahamian officers could be deployed in a dangerous situation by early next year.

The force is to be led by Kenya, which has previously proposed sending 1,000 police officers to Haiti. Yesterday, Kenya’s Foreign Affairs Minister, Alfred Mutua, said that a number of officers are being taught French in anticipation of a deployment.

The Bahamas has previous committed to sending 150 officers as part of that multi-national force – pending the approval of yesterday’s vote. That offer was welcomed by the US Embassy back in August.

The multinational force would support the current Haitian police force – but that is far from a robust unit.

The number of Haitian police is around 10,000 – that is active officers – to handle a country of more than 11 million people which has seen gangs seize control of large sections of the nation.

There have been numerous deaths among the police force too – Haitian human rights group RNDDH said at the start of the year that since Prime Minister Ariel Henry took power there had been around five police officers killed each month. The group estimated that from January to June this year alone, 29 police officers lost their lives.

It is a volatile situation to say the least.

Crucially, what remains unclear is the outcome that is being pursued by this intervention. The Russian Federation’s ambassador to the UN, Vassily Nebenzia, said yesterday that multiple requests for details, including the use of force and when officers would be withdrawn, “went unanswered”.

The Chinese ambassador to the UN, Zhang Jun, said he hoped there would be in-depth consultations with Haitian officials on the deployment while opposing the resolution.

What is challenging with that is that Haiti has no elected officials – terms have expired and the country is in desperate need of an election.

Our own former Prime Minister, Perry Christie, has been part of a group exploring discussions with Haitian leaders – but which leaders have authority to speak for the nation is an open question.

There has been resistance within Haiti to foreign intervention too – after all, a previous UN mission to the country led to the introduction of cholera to the nation, which killed nearly 10,000 people.

Concerns have been raised too about Kenya leading the effort, with a number of claims of torture, deadly force and abuse by Kenyan police.

Against all this, one thing is clear – simply ignoring the situation in Haiti is not an option either. The instability can affect the whole region, but more than that, these are our neighbours, and if we can help, we should.

Whether that means boots on the ground is another matter. We do not imagine there is widespread public support for such a move – and what support there is will be tested mightily if there are any Bahamian casualties.

If we are to commit to troops in Haiti, we need a clearly outlined mission. How long will troops be there? What is their role in Haiti? Will they be involved in potential armed confrontations with gangs? What is the exit strategy?

The Prime Minister should speak directly to those questions if we are to send Bahamians to action in Haiti – and he should do so at the first opportunity in the new session of the House.

Comments

birdiestrachan says...

If one life is lost the PLP will never be forgiven. The Bahamas has enough problems of it own and next year Haiti will be the same again. So many Bahamians need eye sugery

Posted 3 October 2023, 5:37 p.m. Suggest removal

Dawes says...

We can't sit here and complain about all the illegals coming over if we are not willing to offer a solution. The reason they are coming is the issues in their country. If we can help make it better which would hopefully lead to less if not no illegal immigration then it will be worthwhile. However we must do everything we can to make sure that our officers are protected there and come to no harm.

Posted 4 October 2023, 9:46 a.m. Suggest removal

Porcupine says...

The Tribune editorialist states,"Against all this, one thing is clear – simply ignoring the situation in Haiti is not an option either. The instability can affect the whole region, but more than that, these are our neighbours, and if we can help, we should."
Yes, we should help.
The first thing we should do is to learn history, and study the geopolitics of the "big" countries.
Haitians didn't fail. The international community failed Haiti.
We have allowed the rough shod treatment of a sovereign nation, which has been plundered throughout modern history. We have allowed the kidnapping of Haiti's president and allowed a foreign power to install and support a brutal dictator. Now, we think it is OK to send armed men into Haiti?
All adults should read the following:

https://www.counterpunch.org/2023/10/04…

Posted 4 October 2023, 10:01 a.m. Suggest removal

ExposedU2C says...

This comment was removed by the site staff for violation of the usage agreement.

Posted 4 October 2023, 11:24 a.m.

carltonr61 says...

RBDF could be better utilized fixing our potholes a national crisis outside of PHA unable to offer proper care for voters who pay taxes are though have the least entitlement in proper health care whuch today stands at zero.

Great that the Tribune showcased above that this UN Agenda for Haiti has dubious and limited international support. Black faces of Kenyans beholden to UK NATO and G7 alone with on paper support from The Bahamas in this massacre of millions of black Haitians hiding behind oil companies money.
Haitians Nationals leader, Barbecue, wants Haitian vast oil reserves for Haitians but oersonsvin the interest of big powercand oil had him declared a terrorist. The last Haitian leader who was pro nationalist was assisinated and a cozy puppet with zero local support was installed who says yes to the foreigners who installed him. So any reprisals will not go toward Kenya, a land too far away. But we'll armed Haitians could wreak terroristic catastrophic damage to our tourist industry. We must not be fools and be the convenient fallguy to war that will have generational revenge on our peaceful way of life. Even thecgreast USA is keeping their flag out. Who the devil are we?

Posted 4 October 2023, 11:32 a.m. Suggest removal

Porcupine says...

Posted 4 October 2023, 12:57 p.m. Suggest removal

carltonr61 says...

Yes. That says most if not all of it.

Posted 4 October 2023, 3:20 p.m. Suggest removal

ExposedU2C says...

Just think of the open door message that Sleasy Fwreddy Boy Mitchell and corrupt PM Davis are sending to the Haitian people by sending our ill-equipped troops (mainly of Haitian heritage) to gang ridden and disease infested Haiti. Mitchell and Davis are telling the Haitian people to flee to the Bahamas any way they can because the Bahamas is a sanctuary nation and the PLP government will welcome most of them with open arms and decades old, tolerated shanty town communities. The message could not be clearer.

Posted 5 October 2023, 6:52 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment