Investment fear on corruption charges

By NEIL HARTNELL

Tribune Business Editor

nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

Two former Cabinet ministers are warning that the drug and corruption charges levied against senior security officials could have a potentially chilling effect on foreign direct investment (FDI) flows to The Bahamas.

Branville McCartney, the former Democratic National Alliance (DNA) leader who previously sat in the last Ingraham administration’s Cabinet, told Tribune Business that the Government faces a “heavy lift to ensure foreign investor confidence will be rebuilt and sustained” after US federal authorities charged 11 Bahamians - including police and Defence Force officers - with participating in a drug trafficking conspiracy.

He was backed by Dionisio D’Aguilar, minister of tourism and aviation, who said both the US indictment itself and status of those charged may give investors pause for thought and cause them to “stop and review” their projects given the claims that corruption has penetrated key Bahamian government institutions at a high level. As a result, they may reconsider whether they wish to do business in this nation.

Both men, who each have their own private business interests, told this newspaper that the charges levied against Bahamian citizens - including the police chief responsible for aviation and overseeing airport security including at Lynden Pindling International Airport (LPIA) and a Royal Bahamas Defence Force chief petty officer - revived memories of this nation’s drug-boom years in the 1970s and 1980s.

Mr McCartney, in particular, said the situation recalled the unflattering ‘Nation for Sale’ headlines that appeared in the international media about The Bahamas at that time, while Mr D’Aguilar said the US allegations combined with other recent incidents - including the suspension of the officer heading the Criminal Detective Unit (CDU) - to leave the Royal Bahamas Police Force’s reputation “in tatters right now”.

Warning that the fall-out “will impact The Bahamas as a whole, you and me”, as well as all Bahamians and legal residents, Mr McCartney told Tribune Business that the drug and corruption allegations being made by the US authorities will “of course” impact the attitude of investors towards doing business in this jurisdiction.

“It’s always a turn-off in that regard, especially when they speak about high-ranking government officials,” the former DNA leader said. “We certainly won’t know the impact, but we do know it’s a turn-off. I just hope the Government can do what they have to do to ensure foreign investor confidence will be rebuilt and sustained.

“I don’t know how they do that. Your guess is as good as mine. I’m quite sure that it is paramount for this government in their governance to deal with that, trying to ensure foreign investor confidence is recognised and accepted in the country notwithstanding what’s going on. That’s a heavy, heavy lift. Hopefully they’ll be able to do that for all our benefit.”

Both he and Mr D’Aguilar said the fall-out from the indictment was unlikely to impact tourism, The Bahamas’ largest industry. However, the latter added: “It will probably impact people’s interest in doing business in the community. It may not stop that, but it may cause them to pause and reconsider. I don’t know whether it will go to cancel, or if it will depend on what actions are taken.

“In a number of instances, there’s a stop and review. It doesn’t lead to a cancellation, but a stop and review and delay. These allegations reflect incredibly poorly on certain institutions in The Bahamas, like the Royal Bahamas Police Force and possibly the Defence Force. In the case of the Royal Bahamas Police Force, this is the second expose to hit them in five months.

“Back in July we had recordings concerning the head of CDU, chief superintendent Michael Johnson, that led to him stepping down and going on gardening leave and we’ve heard nothing since,” Mr D’Aguilar continued. “Then, five months later, you get this huge bombshell come in.

“The reputation of the Royal Bahamas Police Force is in tatters right now. The whole community is talking about an organisation that needs help. Something has got to give. I’m sure there isn’t a single Bahamian talking about this who is not asking what the hell is going on?

“The question is what is being done about it, and done to correct it moving forward. Do we hope it gets better or do we do something serious and transformational to make the organisation work as it should. You can stick your head in the sand and hope it blows over and goes away but the reputation of the Royal Bahamas Police Force is being significantly negatively impacted.”

With Chief Superintendent Elvis Curtis, head of the police force’s aviation and airport security division among those charged, together with Chief Petty Officer Darren Roker from the Royal Bahamas Defence Force, Mr McCartney said the potential impact for The Bahamas is “far worse” than the $10m the Ministry of Tourism had to spend earlier this year to “clean up” the negative publicity related to US crime advisories.

Pointing out that the country’s national security has been endangered if the US allegations are true, the former DNA leader warned Bahamians will be impacted regardless of political affiliation. “It almost reminds of a ‘nation for sale’ many, many years ago,” Mr McCartney said of the US indictment. “You are reminded of that.

“I am very curious to see what is going to happen in trying to calm the reputation of The Bahamas. I think it’s an extremely unfortunate situation, and we as Bahamians - I’m talking about every day Bahamians - that we are put in this position because of the foolishness done by those persons, especially persons in our national security and possibly in government.

“It’s absolutely ridiculous and something we shouldn’t really stand for. I would hope and pray that the Government takes a hard stand in weeding out the bad apples and making a true example of those persons because it affects every single Bahamian and those who have a right to live here.”

Asserting that The Bahamas’ response to the indictment, and its national security and reputation implications, will be critical, Mr McCartney said: “Just like life we need to face it head on and do what’s best, and the Government does what’s best, for The Bahamas. Don’t take this lightly.

“They need to show not only The Bahamas, but the world, we cannot stand for these things and we are taking steps in these circumstances. It requires taking drastic steps. The Government needs to show it is serious and not pussy-footing around with the criminal element. I think the Prime Minister has to come out and indicate not only to the Bahamian people but the world that they are very serious about this.”

Mr D’Aguilar, meanwhile, said “every right-thinking Bahamian is embarrassed by this”. He added of the Government: “You cannot bury your head in the sand, which is what most people believe has happened so far. Nobody believes they’ve done anything material, and there’s a large belief in the local community that they’re waiting us out. Time passes, and we will forget about.”

Agreeing with Mr McCartney that the US charges revived memories of the 1980s, when “people steered clear of us”, Mr D’Aguilar added: “We’re trending back in that direction.”

 

Comments

ThisIsOurs says...

It was revealed during COVID that the kiddie carnival is required by every administration to pay the administration's political party 200k dollars. Why is a political party the doorway to a business license? It might make sense if there was a special contract between two entities but no, its whomever has *power*. A fee levied to the end of time. Can someone explain how this is at minimum ethical at worst not a corrupt practice?

Why when asked about contracts issued to multiple constituents for the same work and contracts issued to constiuents with no requirement for them to do work did the Deputy Leader of the FNM respond *in Parliament*, ~"*come on guys everybody does this*". This appears to be another corrupt practice.

"*This how the game is played*", is not transparency, accountability or ethics.

As long as we normalize these shady practices, why should a small police officer or the guy on the street who "*just playing the game*" do any different?

Posted 2 December 2024, 1:42 p.m. Suggest removal

birdiestrachan says...

NATION FOR SALE OH HOW THEY LOVE TO REAPET THAT it gives them Fnms pleasure. It is not good for our Bahamas but corruption is not unique to the Bahamas..and those two mouth pieces are no saints themselves.

Posted 2 December 2024, 4:24 p.m. Suggest removal

birdiestrachan says...

Johnson nor curtis just happned they were there when the Fnm was the Government.

Posted 2 December 2024, 4:29 p.m. Suggest removal

pt_90 says...

we voted the FNM out of office. What did the new guys do to fix the problem since 2021. Both of these parties are to blame.

Posted 2 December 2024, 4:42 p.m. Suggest removal

ExposedU2C says...

McCartney and D'Aguilar.......what a joke!

Posted 2 December 2024, 5:23 p.m. Suggest removal

IslandWarrior says...

> "People for a Better Bahamas" (PBB):

For nearly 70 years, the Bahamas and its people have endured a legacy of incompetence in leadership, a lack of vision, and stagnated growth. Over this time, our nation's potential has been squandered, and the standard of living, safety, and security of Bahamians have steadily eroded. Hope and prospects for a brighter future have been replaced by despair, leading our small, close-knit communities into the grips of gangs, drug wars, delinquency, and social decay.

This is not the future we deserve, nor is it the legacy we should leave for our children. People for a Better Bahamas (PBB) stands as a transformative force, committed to reversing decades of neglect and inefficiency. We recognize the urgency of change, and we are prepared to implement the bold, necessary reforms to rebuild our nation from the ground up.
We can fix this. Through strong leadership, innovative policies, and a relentless dedication to the people, PBB will restore hope, opportunity, and prosperity to every Bahamian. Together, we can reclaim our nation's promise and build a future where our communities thrive, and our people rise.

***Join us in this mission for a stronger, safer, and better Bahamas. PBB – People for a Better Bahamas.***

Posted 2 December 2024, 11:24 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment