Saturday, December 7, 2024
By JADE RUSSELL
Tribune Staff Reporter
jrussell@tribunemedia.net
WOMEN’S rights activist Alicia Wallace has warned that Assistant Commissioner of Police Shanta Knowles’ historic appointment as the first female Commissioner of Police may reflect the “glass cliff phenomenon,” where women are promoted during crises and set up to fail.
ACP Knowles' proposed appointment comes amid ongoing scandals in the Royal Bahamas Police Force.
During a national address, Prime Minister Philip Davis announced his recommendation last Wednesday. It follows Commissioner Clayton Fernander’s resignation and Deputy Commissioner Leamond Deleveaux’s impending retirement. While the decision has been described as a step towards reforming the RBPF, it has also raised questions.
Mr Davis insisted that Mr Fernander’s departure was unrelated to recent US federal indictments alleging that members of the RBPF and the Royal Bahamas Defence Force (RBDF) assisted drug traffickers smuggling cocaine from South America through the Bahamas to the US.
Mr Fernander’s resignation shocked the country, as he recently delivered a national address to outline plans to the quality of police officers and boost accountability.
Ms Wallace, Equality Bahamas Director, said: “We are aware, and remind the government and the general public, of the glass cliff phenomenon in which women are promoted in the midst of crisis and set up to fail."
She underscored that failure to provide ACP Knowles with the necessary tools and support, including backing from key officials, could lead to negative outcomes for her, the RBPF, and Bahamian women.
She added the country has a long way to go in reaching equal participation and leadership in public and political life.
Despite her concerns, Ms Wallace expressed hope that ACP Knowles would receive consistent support and be able to address critical issues such as gender-based violence.
She added: “We welcome opportunities to engage with the new Commissioner of Police to discuss gender-based violence, recommendations by human rights bodies that have not yet been implemented, and training for all police officers.”
Ms Knowles, 53, is a mother of one daughter and has served in the police force for 33 years. She has also held positions in the Southern Division, Criminal Investigations Department, Family Island Districts of Exuma and Eleuthera, the National Crime Prevention Office, and the Human Resources Department, in addition to serving as Commandant of the Police Reserves.
Her experience includes leading the Sexual Offences Squad and the Trafficking in Persons Squad, successfully investigating the first human trafficking case in the country.
From 2017 to 2020, she served as the Director of the National Crime Prevention Office. She had also worked as the press liaison officer, communicating with the media and the public on behalf of the police force.
Comments
trueBahamian says...
I agree that she should be given all the support she needs. I don't think she was put in this position because she is a female with the hope that she fails. Ensuring her failure doesn't do anything to restore confidence in the current administration. Also, I doubt the leader of the Opposition would sign off to an upcoming failure to have his name attached to such a situation. Any failure to support would be less about wanting the failure of a woman and more about ensuring certain deeds done by prominent individuals are not brought to light. Her credentials, as laid out in the media, shows she is qualified to be in charge. Let's all give her the time, the space and the support she needs to get the job done.
Posted 7 December 2024, 11:56 a.m. Suggest removal
ThisIsOurs says...
"*Let's all give her the time*"
Absolutely not. This is a crisis. Pick someone qualified to do the job from day one. She may well be that person, but we do not have time to "wait" to see.
Posted 7 December 2024, 2:47 p.m. Suggest removal
ThisIsOurs says...
A failure could also be the result of lack of necessary competencies... since none have been identified. Just pick someone who sat around long enough and has "years" of obscure "experience"
This nonsense about "*the first female to...*" is going a tad bit too far. Everybody loves Mother Pratt, but does anyone really believe she was chosen by Perry Christie as DPM because he thought she had had stellar leadership skills? Of course not, just the opposite, he chose her because he saw her as no threat to him. There was Brave, Obie and Fred, he steered clear of them and he went for the weakest. Now forevermore we get to hear a fairytale about "*first female DPM*" as a hard earned award. Lanesha Rolle was touted as "*first female Sports Minister*" she stepped in, had people standing when she entered the room, putting her face on medals and she break up the best china while she was at it. But again forevermore "*first female to..*"
I dont know anything about the new commissioner, we are basically now forced to accept someone with no job description. This selection process facade needs to end
Posted 7 December 2024, 2:45 p.m. Suggest removal
GodSpeed says...
So when should she be given the job? When it's easy?
Posted 8 December 2024, 11:02 a.m. Suggest removal
ThisIsOurs says...
**When she's *qualified* **. And that could be today. We dont know because the first step to making that determination is a list of concrete skills, qualifications as nd qualities that a first world country would demand of a police commissioner. Not a vague list of *years of experience* that qualifies anybody, even Superintendent Curtis, Michael Johnson, Sonny Miller and Symonnette.
Once you have the list of objective concrete criteria, you compare it against anybody's resume, not just the next socially promotable person.
We need to stop this guessing game of leadership, followed by "give them time, they never do this before"
Posted 8 December 2024, 6:42 p.m. Suggest removal
ThisIsOurs says...
Was there even enough time to do a forensic audit on the selection? She should have been made Acting Commissioner in light of the resignation and all the necessary checks completed in a 6month window before confirmation. What's to fear? If she's qualified, she's confirmed.
Posted 8 December 2024, 6:46 p.m. Suggest removal
bahamianson says...
She can be d÷signaled "acting commissioner". They need about 5 picks then background check all, let them come before a panel of questions.....the smart thing to do.
Posted 9 December 2024, 11:39 a.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment