INSIGHT: The PLP’s dark veil of secrecy

By TYLER MCKENZIE

WHEN Brave Davis came to office, he pledged to lift the veil of secrecy in government – instead, he has replaced it with a cloak of darkness.

The lead stories in each of the main newspapers on Thursday were informative, to say the least. Both The Tribune and the Nassau Guardian had main stories talking about the lack of information being given out by the government – incredibly, they were two entirely separate stories.

The Guardian’s lead story focused on the series of questions put by the FNM in a Q&A session in the House of Assembly, repeatedly dodged by the Prime Minister and by the Minister of Energy and Transport, JoBeth Coleby-Davis.

Over at The Tribune’s front page, it was the Freeport licensees wanting actual answers on what the plan is for Freeport after Mr Davis visited Grand Bahama to deliver more rhetoric but no details.

These were not even the only stories about a lack of information or transparency from the government in the week.

Just the day before, The Guardian reported on Mr Davis telling people in Grand Bahama that it was “never fruitful or constructive to have the media engaged in your business”.

Credit the administration with one piece of transparency – they’re telling us to our faces that they are not going to tell us anything.

After the licensees spoke up, who else waded into the debate but the undiplomatic diplomat, Foreign Affairs Minister and self-appointed warrior in the Grand Bahama Port Authority debate Fred Mitchell. Responding both to the licensees and the Port Authority which pledged to “set the record straight” with an event with stakeholders, Mr Mitchell called their statements “unfortunate, ill conceived, misdirected” and said they were “responding in a combative manner to the prime minister’s address to the Grand Bahama Chamber of Commerce”.

He added that “the statements were so similar that they can be accused as being authored and directed from the same mind and pen”.

Meanwhile, he told the Port Authority that “this is a time for silence, consulting your lawyers and stepping up to the plate and finding the money to make good”.

He didn’t tell the prime minister it was time for silence, who had just spoken to the chamber of commerce. Oh no, just the other side of the debate.

For their part, the licensees association were very polite – starting out by saying it was a privilege to hear from the prime minister in the “first opportunity to do so” since a request back in June of last year.

Indeed, the association simply pointed out that the “discourse lacked critical details on any tangible solutions and remedial action” and that it “failed to establish any forum for the genuine engagement and participation of licensees”. In other words, pretty much, they haven’t been told the way forward and there has been nothing set up for them to give input.

They are not alone.

How about consultation for the Electricity Bill before the House? You would think the Grand Bahama Power Company would have been part of the discussion. Not so! They say the first they heard of it was when it was in the newspapers.

Freedom of Information Bill? Get your binoculars out because it ain’t anywhere in sight.

Parliamentary disclosures? The chairman’s gone quiet and there’s little sign of anyone telling us if Parliamentarians actually followed the law or not. Mr Mitchell even thinks it is a nuisance to be asked.

Fines for companies that have damaged our environment? Somehow that has become a state secret, even as another ship has been stranded on a barge without being removed. Tell us the fines – how can they be a deterrent if no one knows what they are?

Even in a House debate this week, on the Trial By Judge Alone Bill, when FNM MP Adrian Gibson suggested that three judges might be better than one to ensure justice, he got his knuckles rapped by the Minister of National Security, Wayne Munroe, who said Mr Gibson should apologise, as if suggesting extra legal protections during a Parliamentary debate was some terrible offence.

As Maya Angelou said, “when someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time”.

Well, this administration is showing us who they are.

They don’t want you in their business. They don’t want you being able to offer an informed opinion. They don’t want you to know if they broke the law. They don’t want to give answers in Parliament.

They’re just not that into you. But just wait until election time. There will be knocking on the door, there will be promises of this, promises of that. There will be rallies and campaign shirts. They will be all into you then. Just remember how they are now.

There’s time to change still. Get that Freedom of Information Act implemented fully. Share the receipts on GBPA so we can agree – or disagree. Tell us which MPs missed the declaration deadline. Answer the questions on BPL. Tell the BPL staff what is coming in their future.

Mr Davis talks about having the media in your business – well, first thing first, it’s not your business, Mr Davis, it’s the country’s business. Secondly, it’s not just the media you’re snubbing – but stakeholders in the future of GBPA or BPL or other entities, and your fellow Parliamentarians in the House.

It’s about time you gave some of them some real answers. Or don’t be surprised when they’re not that into you in the ballot box when the time comes.

Comments

stillwaters says...

It started when Clint said we didn't need to know how much was being spent on travel, that he will say something if the spending looks odd....or some such words.

Posted 13 May 2024, 12:39 p.m. Suggest removal

hrysippus says...

Mo one has ever accused any of the PLP governments of being not being smeared with allegations of corruption and cronyism. The Bend or Break speech, Part 2, is most probably being presented to the gullible public as a distraction from what is about to happen with BPL.

Posted 13 May 2024, 12:44 p.m. Suggest removal

Sickened says...

This is a Catch 22 for the PLP. If they speak then we know they're lying. If they're silent then we know they're up to no good.

Posted 13 May 2024, 2:12 p.m. Suggest removal

rosiepi says...

Common sense seems lost with voters today…
‘though a snake might change his skin many times, he will always be a snake’

Posted 13 May 2024, 3:14 p.m. Suggest removal

DWW says...

i see what you did there!

Posted 14 May 2024, 2:03 p.m. Suggest removal

sheeprunner12 says...

I don't feel sorry for you jellyback so-called media journalists ........... The PLP rejoiced when Ivan Johnson (The Punch) died because Brave dem knew that he could buy off the rest of them.

If the Fourth Estate had the guts to do its job ......... the PLP will be shaking in their boots every day. As it stands now, the toothless Bahamian media is making this 2021-2026 term a cakewalk for the PLP.

It is the Media who has let down the Bahamian citizens ......... not the PLP.

Posted 13 May 2024, 3:18 p.m. Suggest removal

regrolli says...

The media has been ‘bought’ by several agendas that the Bahamian people will never get the full story, let alone the truth.

Posted 13 May 2024, 3:27 p.m. Suggest removal

ExposedU2C says...

So true. Many readers of the Nassau Guardian do not even know that it is controlled by the same two individuals who control Colina Insurance, CFAL and a host of other companies.

Posted 13 May 2024, 3:43 p.m. Suggest removal

birdiestrachan says...

Both newspapers for the most part are bias towards the Fnm the person who wrote this article is chief among them along with the DNA big time looser they carry the torch and water for the Fnm media in the business they twist what is said like a whirl wind the Fnm could have signed the freedom of information bill Mr Gibson is right now before a judge where will they find 3 judges to sit on one case campaign for the Fnm is it Mr Pintard or doc if GBPA and FlA are not paying you they should send them a bill for a job well done

Posted 13 May 2024, 8:20 p.m. Suggest removal

FreeportFreddy says...

Punctuation...try it sometime to avoid word salad!!

Posted 14 May 2024, 7:04 a.m. Suggest removal

ExposedU2C says...

That's a tall order for birdie.

Posted 14 May 2024, 12:17 p.m. Suggest removal

DWW says...

is this why Bahamas Press always says "Watch The Road"? is it like saying stay in your lane and don't mind what we doin over here. Is anyone truly surprised? As long as PLP don't take on any new jumbo loans on my behalf, then I think we will survive another 3 years. then again giving snake back his lucrative fuel contract and unleashing the rates for commercial customers while making it free for pensioners sounds like a great robinhood type of act and should be lauded. carry on smartly then just be aware of the bed you make that you must sleep in.

Posted 14 May 2024, 2:09 p.m. Suggest removal

birdiestrachan says...

It is said that a true liar lies to themselves it is my hope folks know better the Fnm government has done more bad to the Bahamas than good it seem the Bahamas best do not join their party what fool signs a 150 year contract . It is the PlP that has always had the vision and have done what is good for us no doubt they have made mistakes

Posted 14 May 2024, 8:42 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment