Thursday, November 14, 2024
By FAY SIMMONS
Tribune Business Reporter
jsimmons@tribunemedia.net
The Ministry of Finance’s top official yesterday revealed he expects next year’s Business Licence fee revenues to be “extraordinary” following a 10 percent increase in collections this year.
Simon Wilson, the financial secretary, addressing the Bahamas Institute of Chartered Accountants (BICA) accountants’ week conference, gave the optimistic forecast when asked by an attendee to compare the revenue generated since the introduction of the new Business Licence Act and the administration’s enhanced enforcement and compliance efforts.
He added that while not a “fair comparison”, as the majority of Business Licence fees are collected between January and April, the tax authorities have seen a 10 percent increase when compared to the same period in 2023 and he expects collections to be “extraordinary” based on current indicators.
“Business Licence, as you know, is a calendar tax, so it’s not a fair comparison because the bulk of Business Licence is collected in the period January to April, but we are tracking roughly 10 percent above last year same time,” said Mr Wilson.
“We feel a structural change in compliance is taking place. We look forward to the tax period between January through April, and believe it will be extraordinary based on what we’ve seen so far.” The Government is forecasting that Business Licence fee revenue will increase by 44.4 percent or more than $62.5m for the 2024-2025 fiscal year, growing from $141m in 2023-2024 to $203.555m.
Another accountant, meanwhile, questioned what is being done to enforce tax compliance on unregulated businesses that operate in the informal economy. She adderd that many registered businesses have received compliance checks, and have to submit audits, while those in the informal sector are selling products that directly compete with them and could possibly be making above the $100,000 VAT registration threshold.
Mr Wilson, in reply, said compliance officers have “touched” most businesses several times. One challenge is that 90 percent of businesses declare they make less than $100,000, keeping them below the VAT registration threshold, but audits can reveal information about the businesses they engage with.
“Let me assure you, I also drive around this country, and I also talk to my compliance people almost on a daily basis. If a business is out there, chances are they have been touched by our compliance people several times, so we do have a high level of compliance,” said Mr Wilson.
“The challenge that we have is that 90 percent of businesses who register say they make less than $100,000, so that’s a challenge, and that’s why we do the audits and so forth. And we use the audits not only to gather information about the business we audited but the other businesses who are related through business transactions.”
Another participant said accountants are aware of the challenges involved in governing The Bahamas, but argued that if the Government would make more effort to explain how tax revenue are used Bahamians would not have the “overall perception that the economy is bad in the country”.
He pushed for the Government to be more transparent with its challenges and keep the public informed of its fiscal state to prevent negative outlooks. Mr Wilson said persons, who he did not name, are painting the the Bahamian economy in a negative light for their own purposes.
“Persons who have the bully pulpit and so forth have to use it responsibly because when they talk down the economy, they impact everybody,” he argued.”They are not just impacting the Government, they’re impacting everybody because, eventually, somebody in Toronto who’s in charge of risk at one of the Canadian banks can say, you know what, the economy in The Bahamas isn’t doing so good. We’ll reduce the credit levels.
“This will affect our ability to borrow. So we have to be responsible in terms of how we interpret information. I do not think it’s my responsibility to dictate how someone should feel the economy, but I am saying the information is available. It’s all there. People should utilise the information responsibly.”
Mr Wilson said a new economic impact study is being undertaken that could show the cruise industry makes a greater contribution than previously thought. He added that The Bahamas has seen a 20 percent year-over-year increase in cruise arrivals that is the envy of Caribbean competitors.
“We’ve seen a 20 percent year-over-year increase in cruise business. That’s a very powerful number,” said Mr Wilson. “When you talk to our competitors in the Caribbean, they will tell you The Bahamas is like a vacuum. They all see the impact of the resurgence of The Bahamas’ tourism industry on their numbers. All through the Caribbean, we talk to them, and they’ll tell you that.
“But yet, still in this economy, we who are benefiting directly and indirectly from this resurgence, it’s viewed as a negative, it’s viewed as it’s not good enough, or so forth. There has to be a balance, that’s all I’m saying.”
Comments
Dawes says...
When you have changed what Business license is made up of there will be an increase. Many things not included before now have business license, he of course will say no new taxes but by changing how the current taxes are done you have really brought in new taxes. In addition you have hit companies with making them pay on revenue they have not earned in 2024 as the fee is now on the year in question and not the year before. Of course there will be an increase in fees this way. the better test will be to see what happens in the year after that.
Posted 14 November 2024, 1:44 p.m. Suggest removal
moncurcool says...
You would think this "meet me outside" so called financial secretary would know this and be transparent with people, rather than trying to spin this.
Posted 14 November 2024, 2:40 p.m. Suggest removal
TalRussell says...
**Gonna be this church Saturday/Sunday talk, so: -- **Endocrine thyself, beforehand as to:** -- If your church, preaches against drinking alcohol and gambling.** -- How **should it impact** worshippers: -- **From working** for, **or serving on,** a government alcohol or gambling board, ministry, department, or even a **licensed betting shop:** -- Yes?
Posted 14 November 2024, 7:46 p.m. Suggest removal
ThisIsOurs says...
"*Persons who have the bully pulpit and so forth have to use it responsibly because when they talk down the economy, they impact everybody,” he argued.”They are not just impacting the Government, they’re impacting everybody because, eventually, somebody in Toronto who’s in charge of risk at one of the Canadian banks can say, you know what, the economy in The Bahamas isn’t doing so good. We’ll reduce the credit levels.*"
If someone in Toronto in charge of Credit Risk bases their decisions solely on what someone on a talk show says, they're *dumber* than us.
That's not how it works. They gather information, check legitimate news sources, examine world markets and trends, place all of that into their models, perform some analysis and then come up with an assessment.
Only in the Bahamas are knee jerk existential economic decisions made by talk show.
Posted 15 November 2024, 2:37 a.m. Suggest removal
Porcupine says...
Mr. Simon seems ignorant.
Why are we still borrowing, Mr. Simon?
If you are transparent, why not tell us why a 10% increase in government collections is good for the Bahamian economy?
Mr. Simon, having listened to you, it is difficult to believe you, or think you have the brains to do any good for this country.
You are what is called a lackey.
You do not seem qualified to work in the private sector, so you ended up in government.
The Bahamas suffers as a result.
Posted 15 November 2024, 6:26 a.m. Suggest removal
DWW says...
why does one need to pay tax before your do the business? are there other countries in the world where you need to prepay to play in business? What if the economy tanks and the business sucksass do they get a refund? Has anyone ever got a refund from the bah govt??
Posted 15 November 2024, 7:24 a.m. Suggest removal
Dawes says...
Only those connected get refunds. The rest can wait until they have got them selves into a position that their new tax obligation is more then the refund. If that is 10 years then so be it
Posted 15 November 2024, 9:13 a.m. Suggest removal
ThisIsOurs says...
Because they dont want the tax income to reflect reality. They want it to reflect their overly optimistic projections
Posted 16 November 2024, 5:27 a.m. Suggest removal
DreamerX says...
Perhaps you should review again how the business licence tax is levied in this country. The first year of business' fees related to licencing is primarily registration and documentation matters. If you earn below the threshold you pay based on the prior year for the upcoming year and submit unaudited but accountant revenue attestation. If you are beyond the first first threshold then you may be required to submit audited reports by June 30 of the following calendar year in which the licence fees can/may be charged based on the variance. In terms of a refund, these are not directly outlined but based on a case by case basis, albeit quite difficult to achieve. Depending further on your turnover of the prior years you may be required to submit estimated account during the year which may provide a basis for licence fee adjustments same as the prior. In my years of experience I have not encountered someone paying license fees for the first year of business based upon projected revenues so the fees are primarily or in most cases based upon a past year of operation, so I am not sure where you determined your point of paying fees before you "play in business".
Posted 18 November 2024, 8:27 a.m. Suggest removal
Dawes says...
You are correct. In the first year it is a nominal fee. But the next year you then pay 0.75% (assuming sales below $5 million) for the year just gone and then 0.75% for the year to come. So in effect 2 years in one go
Posted 18 November 2024, 9:16 a.m. Suggest removal
Sickened says...
Most governments brag about reducing taxes. But this ja brags about sucking an extraordinary amount of taxes from the very machinery that keeps the country going - businesses, big and small.
I guess he couldn't survive in the private sector so brainless brave hired him to work in the biggest money pit we have.
And here I thought dodo birds went extinct.
Posted 15 November 2024, 8:59 a.m. Suggest removal
whatsup says...
TAXES, TAXES AND MORE TAXES.....Polictians need more money. WHERE DOS THE VAT GO???
Posted 15 November 2024, 10:29 a.m. Suggest removal
realfreethinker says...
When is gov going to pay it's small vendors. They owe me over $200,000.00 for more than a year and i a, not the only one
Posted 15 November 2024, 4:37 p.m. Suggest removal
ExposedU2C says...
This is one uncontrollably angry and incompetent buffoon who needs to be put out to pasture forevermore.
Posted 18 November 2024, 4:08 p.m. Suggest removal
truetruebahamian says...
Where is the cruise industry’s business licence breakdown? Downtown is suffering and paying for them while our politicians are having to buy bigger trousers and belts with ten more notches..
Posted 18 November 2024, 4:56 p.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment