‘Time-tracking needed to justify Doctor overtime’

By LEANDRA ROLLE

Tribune Chief Reporter

lrolle@tribunemedia.net

PRIME Minister Philip “Brave” Davis has raised concerns about demands for overtime pay from healthcare workers, insisting that payments cannot be justified without a proper time-tracking system to verify hours worked.

He also urged union leaders to return to the negotiating table, warning that the government cannot meet all financial demands without ensuring accountability.

“Every Bahamian who pays taxes has a stake in ensuring that public funds are managed responsibly,” Mr Davis told reporters at Baha Mar yesterday.

“I ask you, the Bahamian people, would you agree to pay overtime in your business or workplace without verifying that the hours were worked? Accountability is not negotiable. It protects the fairness and integrity of the system for everyone.”

The prime minister noted that healthcare workers have resisted calls for a time-tracking system, making it difficult for the government to approve their overtime demands.

His comments come amid heightened tensions with healthcare workers, who have raised unresolved issues such as overtime pay, lack of health insurance, and an expired industrial agreement.

While commending doctors for their dedication to saving lives, Mr Davis said the government must balance the needs of healthcare workers with those of the wider population. He pointed to efforts by his administration to address financial concerns, including resolving $2.8m in outstanding payments last October. This sum included $1.5m in ex gratia payments to healthcare workers.

On the issue of health insurance, Mr Davis said the government has presented three “comprehensive” options designed to provide workers with flexibility and choice while maintaining financial sustainability.

He also expressed frustration with delays in finalising industrial agreements, claiming that union representatives have missed scheduled meetings.

“The government has shown its readiness to sign agreements and move forward,” Mr Davis said. “However, there have been occasions where union representatives fail to attend scheduled meetings, causing unnecessary delays. This undermines the process and ultimately exacerbates challenges faced by both workers and the public.”

Consultant Physician Staff Association president Dr Charelle Lockhart refuted these claims yesterday, insisting that union representatives have consistently attended meetings, including one reportedly called by Mr Davis, where he failed to appear.

“We have gone to every single meeting, including the meeting with him, where he called us to a meeting, and he did not show up,” Dr Lockhart said. “Disrespectfully, they had us waiting for one hour before they told us that the prime minister was on a plane going to another country.”

Dr Lockhart also criticised Mr Davis for accusing healthcare workers on Wednesday of neglecting patient care during a two-day nationwide strike earlier this week, saying that the strike had been carefully managed to ensure critical care was not disrupted.

“Medical workers take their oath to care for patients very seriously,” she said. “That is why the senior physicians made sure that the critically ill patients who were in the hospital and the ones who were coming into the hospital were covered and seen. So I think that his comments are very reckless, and I am disappointed in the fact that he is questioning our integrity as a group.”

The strike, which was led by Trade Union Congress (TUC) president Obie Ferguson, involved healthcare professionals, air traffic controllers, and other government workers. It forced some clinics to close and left health facilities in “crisis mode.”

Mr Ferguson accused the government of failing to fulfil promises outlined in a 2021 Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) between the Progressive Liberal Party (PLP) and union leaders, despite the TUC’s support for the PLP in the last general election.

Mr Davis insisted that his administration has honoured most of the MoU’s terms, with only “one or two matters” pending resolution. He said he had instructed Labour Minister Pia Glover-Rolle to engage with Mr Ferguson following a recent email.

The prime minister also responded to Bahamas Union of Teachers (BUT) President Belinda Wilson’s criticism of his government’s handling of labour issues, which she rated as an “F.”

Mr Davis said: “There must be mutual respect for fruitful dialogue. I will speak to people who will be respectful and who will not come to a table and say, ‘well, I ain’t trust what you gon’ say.’ How you gon’ talk to me when you don’t trust me? You have to start off by trusting.”

In addition to his comments on healthcare and banking, Mr Davis said he has ordered a comprehensive review of all heads of agreements.

“Every company benefiting from concessions has a duty to reinvest in our nation and its people,” he said. “This is not optional. But accountability is just the beginning.”

Mr Davis pledged to ensure Bahamians have a real path to leadership in the workforce. While acknowledging the country’s success in attracting foreign talent, he criticised the dominance of foreign labour in senior roles, calling it “unacceptable” without clear opportunities for Bahamians to rise.

“My government will ensure that Bahamians have the training and mentorship needed to lead,” he said. “This is a priority of the Prime Minister’s Delivery Unit. And let me add this: it’s not just about jobs; it’s about ownership.”

 

Comments

birdiestrachan says...

No doubt the sands, the Lockhart and the Rolle are all apart of this strike it appears all about politics

Posted 17 January 2025, 12:01 p.m. Suggest removal

rosiepi says...

The WHO recommends that the minimum ratio of doctors 2.5 per 1000 ppl.
Regrettably one must rely on statistics from 2017 for an approximation here in the Bahamas, that being 1.8/1000 ppl.

We do know that the problem has only grown worse, eg having to mass import skilled nurses, the number of patients unable to secure beds some who’ve subsequently died, and these increasing job actions due to this government’s refusal to fulfill their end of the bargains made years ago.

We also know that other countries like Canada (2021-2.4/1000ppl) and the UK (2022-3.2/1000ppl are also experiencing severe healthcare systems problems due to their lack MDs, especially GPs, nurses etc with of course a corespondent lack of staffed beds/facilities.

So why pray tell are Bahamians allowing Davis to continue to affront their intelligence by speaking so scurrilously of what we all know to be an overworked, and underpaid workforce- our healthcare workers?
Give them the healthcare benefits promised to them, pay them for their service to our community as per the agreement made.

Then you can start negotiations to additional terms.

Posted 17 January 2025, 12:55 p.m. Suggest removal

Dawes says...

So who is responsible for having a way to track the doctors overtime? Of course it is the Government. Is he now saying he won't pay the overtime as there was no way to track it? He has known this for the last 3 years and done nothing to change it. Yet again trying to spin that it is the other sides fault and never the Government who seem to be unable to change anything in a positive manner.

Posted 17 January 2025, 1:11 p.m. Suggest removal

moncurcool says...

Davis really believe we have no intelligence. They can track the doctors regular work hours but don't have something in place to track their overtime?

And like you say, he is the employer responsible to track overtime. WHo is he trying to blame for not doing his job?

Posted 17 January 2025, 1:32 p.m. Suggest removal

TalRussell says...

Can't be just meself who says, there can't be much concern over, 'overtime pay at the hospital morgue....cause due to non-payment by govt. ---- bodies go uncollected and left to rot...wherever deaded from natural causes or murdered. -- Is there just the one PMH that has a morgue. -- Yes?

Posted 17 January 2025, 8:42 p.m. Suggest removal

pt_90 says...

So the government has no way of tracking overtime in 2025.

then they wonder why no one trusts thier sand dollar.

Posted 19 January 2025, 12:29 p.m. Suggest removal

tetelestai says...

The sand dollar is distinct from government. Just stop with your nonsense, please.

Posted 20 January 2025, 3:41 a.m. Suggest removal

pt_90 says...

I wasnt expecting to explain figures of speech this morning but here we are. Obviously the CBB is the issuer of legal tender.

However the govt has also been working with them and has made it a policy goal to see its success and is not an indifferent observer.

"Their" is used loosely here as in they are invested in its success. Its like saying "my Lakers lost", "your party won". Obviously I'm not Jeannie Buss and I dont own the Lakers.

They have wanted it to work as a matter of policy and have been trying to get it to wide spread use. (see below). However my point is that the same organization cant figure out how to rollout OT in 2025....simple.

Per the PM's 1 year anniversary speech:

"Our government also partnered with The Central Bank of The Bahamas to increase the circulation and use of the Sand Dollar. It is expected that this will make small business transactions faster, less costly and more secure."

Or the 23/24 budget "and thus we are working to expand the use of the Sand Dollar on all of our islands."

the Government's Digital Assets White Paper.

"7.1 Enabling access to digital assets for Bahamians in B$ and encouraging greater use of Sand Dollars (the Central Bank Digital Currency issued by the Central Bank of The Bahamas) is a priority for the Government. We will work with the SCB, the Central Bank of The Bahamas, and the private sector on ways to enable Bahamians to access digital assets with B$, and for Bahamians to pay taxes using Sand Dollars. We will also seek to promote wider use of Sand Dollars in commerce
on the islands."

Posted 20 January 2025, 8:21 a.m. Suggest removal

TalRussell says...

Me not much into **if all** who has raised concerns about demands for overtime pay.... are entitled to gettin' it and as to the amount $$. --- **But I do question after notin' what looks be a wardrobe adjustment:** ---Whose idea was it to be done wearing the most-watched **blue suit** on Bahamian mans' since the "Brave" premiership took up office in 2017? --- Fast forward to premiership 2025 trending over to wearing a off-pastel pink lookin' colour and style for Bahamian mans' suit and tie? --- Can't quite make out the foots accessories (shoes and ankle socks)...which does need to match in color coordination and pattern. -- Yes?

Posted 19 January 2025, 4:44 p.m. Suggest removal

Log in to comment