Tuesday, October 13, 2026
By LYNAIRE MUNNINGS
Tribune Staff Reporter
lmunnings@tribunemedia.net
THE family of a man who died less than three months after returning to prison has accused correctional officials of denying him proper medication and medical care despite assurances to the court that his serious health conditions could be managed in custody.
Thomas Jean-Baptiste, who suffered from diabetes, morbid obesity and a history of potentially life-threatening blood clots, died on October 4 after spending about two weeks in hospital.
His sister, Alicia Jean Baptiste, told The Tribune that he had repeatedly complained about inadequate medical care and food after the Court of Appeal revoked his medical bail in July. “He was sick or whatever, but he wasn't sick to the point of dying,” she said.
Asked whether prison officials had done everything reasonably possible to protect her brother's life, Ms Jean Baptiste said: “Absolutely not, they made no efforts, period." “The court order did not matter. It did not stand. They took no care, no concern.”
In July, the Court of Appeal rejected Mr Jean-Baptiste's challenge to his prison sentences, finding that his medical conditions did not justify reducing his terms or replacing them with a non-custodial sentence.
The court revoked his bail and ordered him to return to the Bahamas Department of Correctional Services to serve the remainder of his concurrent sentences of three years for possession of an unlicensed firearm and two years for possession of ammunition.
During the appeal, consultant urologist Dr Robin Roberts warned that Mr Jean-Baptiste's diabetes, morbid obesity and history of multiple pulmonary emboli placed him at high risk of serious complications. He required lifelong anticoagulant medication.
Dr Roberts warned that prison conditions could increase his risk of serious infection, including potentially fatal Fournier's gangrene, and expressed concern about another pulmonary embolism.
However, the Court of Appeal placed greater weight on the assessment of prison physician Dr Scavella, who said the institution could manage his illnesses and transfer him to Princess Margaret Hospital if specialised treatment became necessary.
Dr Scavella recommended that Mr Jean-Baptiste be provided with a bed, daily exercise and access to bathing and toilet facilities.
Ms Jean Baptiste alleged that her brother was supposed to be housed in the prison infirmary but instead spent about a month in intake before being moved to another section of the institution.
She claimed the area had no air conditioning, frequently lost electricity and was far from the infirmary. She also alleged that he was not consistently given medication he had purchased before returning to custody.
“One of his medications alone was like almost like $300 just for one,” she said.
She questioned why prison officials would fail to administer medication he had obtained himself after assuring the court that his medical needs could be managed.
Ms Jean Baptiste also alleged that her brother frequently complained about prison food, sometimes barely eating and relying on meals purchased by relatives.
She said he was initially taken to hospital after complaining of leg pain and was found to have blood clots, but was returned to prison either that night or the following morning.
Mr Jean-Baptiste later complained that prison officials were not checking on him, although his family initially believed he was expressing frustration with prison life rather than signalling a medical crisis.
He was subsequently rushed to hospital again, but relatives were not immediately informed.
Ms Jean Baptiste said her mother travelled to New Providence to visit him. By then, his condition had deteriorated significantly.
She said that after two medical episodes, doctors discussed discharging him despite his inability to speak or move one side of his body.
The family was also told that officials were concerned about returning him to the prison infirmary because it was on the second floor and his size would make transporting him upstairs difficult.
Ms Jean Baptiste said her brother cried at the prospect of returning to prison.
She said the family would have needed further legal proceedings to secure his release, but he died before they could pursue that option.
“I feel like the neglect began from the courthouse,” she said. “Everybody know the prison within itself is not a humane place to be. It's not a clean place to be.”
Mr Jean-Baptiste was convicted on November 10, 2025, after police found a firearm containing five rounds of ammunition in his vehicle during an April 2023 traffic stop.
He was granted medical bail in December 2025 but returned to prison after losing his sentence appeal in July.
The Court of Appeal ruled that his medical conditions had to be weighed against the seriousness of his offences and the need for punishment and deterrence. It noted that he could seek relief through the Prerogative of Mercy if prison authorities became unable to provide adequate care.
Ms Jean Baptiste said her brother's death had devastated his family, including his three children. She described him as an outgoing man known through his work as a boat captain.
“Why was he being neglected? Why was he not being provided with the medications that he took for himself to stay in good health, as his body depended on those medications every day," she said.
“They don't have to provide the bare minimum just because they're inmates, or be neglectful just because they're inmates,” she said.
Ms Jean Baptiste called for accountability and an investigation into her brother's treatment, although she could not confirm whether the family intended to pursue legal action.
Comments
Sickened says...
Obese people with medical issues shouldn't be roaming around with illegal firearms and bullets. Just saying.
Posted 13 October 2026, 8:47 a.m. Suggest removal
Cobalt says...
Yes, but his crimes are irrelevant at this point. Criminals are still entitled to healthcare and medications even when they are incarcerated. It’s actually listed in our laws.
Posted 14 October 2026, 2:01 a.m. Suggest removal
birdiestrachan says...
Sickened I am inclined to agree with you.
Posted 13 October 2026, 11:57 a.m. Suggest removal
Cobalt says...
And the fact that you agree is proof that he/she is wrong.
Posted 14 October 2026, 2:02 a.m. Suggest removal
licks2 says...
This case will go nowhere. . .her accusations are making no sense. . .his case has been exhaustedly adjudicated and he was found wanting!!
Posted 13 October 2026, 12:06 p.m. Suggest removal
empathy says...
Ignoring the negative comments about Mr. Baptiste’s weight, but including his obesity as another serious medical condition apparently relayed to the Court of Appeal by Dr. Robin Roberts, one can only surmise that this was a grave error by the Appeals Court. Firstly a custodial sentence for these offences under these circumstances is not unthinkable, we have no information of ‘priors’ or other mitigating factors. Secondly knowing about the inadequacy of our prison system and the medical care provided there one could easily forecast this particular outcome. Dr. Scavella’s comment that he could be transferred to PMH “if specialist care became necessary” misses this critical point, by the time specialists care becomes necessary would be AFTER a predictable serious event has occurred! Not sure if he is unaware of the ‘potential’ (or lack there of) of his institution’s capabilities…seems like his comments set HM Prisons up for failure.
It is tragic that this man dies in prison custody while many alleged KILLERS roam our streets…I hope the Baptiste Family receives justice and The Bahamas repairs this very problematic and broken system.
Posted 13 October 2026, 5:09 p.m. Suggest removal
joeblow says...
... there are morbidly obese people with different medical problems who die outside of prison all the time! Too many people expect medication to do for them what they won't do for themselves. Was he trying to lose weight, getting exercise, eating properly (especially since his family would bring him food) or was he eating what he wanted to? Nobody but him was responsible for his physical condition or his breaking the law to end up in prison. We seem to be a nation divorced from the concept of personal responsibility; people always looking for someone else to blame! So far we only have one side of the story, so it would be nice to have a little more information.
Posted 13 October 2026, 6:51 p.m. Suggest removal
Sickened says...
100% correct!
Posted 14 October 2026, 8:50 a.m. Suggest removal
Cobalt says...
Is anyone familiar with the term “Criminal Justice?”
It’s a legal precedence that enforces criminal rights. Prisoners are entitled to medical necessities just as they are entitled to food. If the Geneva Convention finds out about prisoners being denied life-saving medications while incarcerates they can levy heavy sanctions against the Bahamas under the clause of human rights violations. This is actually the same law that prevents the RBDF from shooting Haitian and Cuban sloops entering our waters illegally.
Posted 14 October 2026, 2:19 a.m. Suggest removal
Sickened says...
Criminal Justice also means that criminals should have justice met against them. That doesn't happen very ofter here either. Murders getting bail while stealing food gets you prison time. Our whole justice system is corrupt and upside down.
I this guy fat guy complains about his prison mattress being too thin would you defend that too? Does the Geneva Convention also state that a good and comfortable nights rest should be afforded to prisoners?
Posted 14 October 2026, 8:54 a.m. Suggest removal
Cobalt says...
You’re still missing the point. Prisoners are entitled to medication no matter their offense. It’s a part of the law. It’s illegal to prevent prisoners from having access to life saving medications. Period.
Posted 14 October 2026, 11:02 p.m. Suggest removal
Dawes says...
I agree, the onus is on the nation to ensure that the proper medical facilities were available, especially after they said they did have them. Yes Mr. Bapitiste broke the law, but the penalty for what he did should not be a death sentence.
Posted 14 October 2026, 9:58 a.m. Suggest removal
Log in to comment