I am comparing the actions of the Bahamian government to those of Cayman (Compass Compass) and the Turks and Caicos (Turks and Caicos Weekly) both newspapers can be received online. Cayman and TCI are colonies of the UK and therefore their governments are run much more efficiently and correctly.
We are all doing the same thing except for the Bahamian governments propensity to questionably and probably unconstitutionally fiddle with private agreements at worse and at best to rule in a dictatorial and none consultative manner.
With the BEC Rate Bond, which thankfully failed, the government was attempting to force BEC customers to assume $650 million of BEC debt. This is legally impossible under contract law because BEC clients signed up to purchase electricity from BEC and not to assume their debt for zero consideration. Did these guys take Intro to Law 101 in College?
The issue with the insurance companies is far more interesting because I believe they can do it under the Emergency Powers Act. In fact they can do almost anything under the act which is why Cayman probably didn't use it to enforce their "soft" and "hard" curfews. TCI used the Emergency Powers Act.
My fear is what private property is next for the government to "take over" under the Act with zero consultation with steak holders?
Simple tax collection procedures such as mandated direct payment to the government on the same day that the employees are paid would immediately resolve this issue. In the US special payroll companies such as ADP are used as intermediaries and credit the payment to the employees bank account at the same time the government is paid social security and other tax payments.
There is zero penalty for not immediately paying the government except for customs duties (you don't get your merchandise) and VAT (interest penalties for late payments).
We can therefore expect, because there are zero penalties, that during this CoVID 19 lock down virtually no one to pay BEC, Water and Sewerage, Real Property Tax, BTC, VAT, mortgage payments and will push back out of rent payments. There are ppl in the country that can pay these bills but there is zero incentive to pay anything.
Having a credit bureau and “FICO” score for each Bahamian adult would go along to encourage Bahamians to pay their BEC bill.
With such credit monitoring systems if you don’t pay your BEC bill your score goes down so when you go to the bank for credit they will view you as a higher risk which would restrict your ability to trade.
BEC asks for a deposit which is inadequate because by the time they turn off your lights the deposit has long been exhaustived.
In developed countries deposits must be returned to customers after one year.
Download the VesselFinder App on your iPhone and check out the number of green dots (cruise ships) idling around our northern islands.
I assume they are crewed but have nowhere to go or land. Without the ability to land or get supplies the environment on all of these ships could be less than ideal.
Many of these ships are registered under the Bahamian flag. Bahamas happy for the registration fees but don’t know them when they are in trouble or dumping garbage in our oceans.
BPL has an accounts receivable problem but (1) the government won’t tell us exactly how much (2) they have not decided what they will do about the problem (3) we delayed the international rate bond issuance so much that it can’t be done anymore (4) even ppl that can pay their bills are not because there is a “do not disconnect list” for the politician (5) we have done zero solar which is virtually free to protect the lucrative import of global warming fossil fuels for the big shots (6) oil has dropped from $70 to $20 but we have no money to buy future supplies (7) we have done zero grid upgrades and hurricane season starts in 2 months.
Well mudda, great idea on the wealth tax, believe me its coming faster than you think. You can't threaten to lock down a country through April 30, tens of thousands of ppl have lost their jobs, government is supposed to be "working from home" but no one is answering their phones and the e mail server is overloaded and all e mails are being rejected. Something some where and sometime will have to give.
I made the following comments on the Lyford Cay job losses:
As tens of thousands of workers in the private sector are losing their jobs it is ironic that not a single government employee has either taken a pay cut, lost their job or are working at reduced hours.
I say its ironic because the government derives it revenue to meet its payroll by taxing Bahamian citizens and tourist. In any other business there would be some belt tightening as revenues decline.
We just don't the Minster of Health, Finance and the PM telling us how awful it is and how we must stay in our homes. We need hope, we need to see you sharing in our pain. How about taking a 30% pay cut at the top (Minister level) going down to 10% at the Manager level. Leave the salaries of those at the bottom alone.
Tetelestai. It would be constructive if you didn't denigrate my comment as "stupid". You do have a point that laying off government working is not helpful because it will further cause the economy to decline.
However, I had two other recommendations for government to impliment an austerity program of 30% pay cut for Ministers, 20% for Managers and reduced time for worker. Example if the airport is closed, which it is, then there is reduce work for Customs Officers and Managers. Why not, in sympathy with the tens of thousand of Bahamians that lost their jobs that they take a 10% reduction in working hours and pay.
On the high end the Minister of Tourism is a multi millionaire who I am sure would not feel a 30% reduction in his salary.
However, if the government implemented an austerity program like this they would be able to say truthfully "we are all in this together".
Ppl are just becoming more and more fearful.
70% of government expenditure is payroll. If you want some material savings to offset a portion of $1 billion of revenue short fall from a $2 billion budget there is no where else that it can come from. Except foreign reserves and if we deplete $1 billion of foreign reserves we will put a strain on the 1:1 B$:US$ peg which was anecdotally trading at 70 cents before this economic collapse.
As tens of thousands of workers in the private sector are losing their jobs it is ironic that not a single government employee has either taken a pay cut, lost their job or are working at reduced hours.
I say its ironic because the government derives it revenue to meet its payroll by taxing Bahamian citizens and tourist. In any other business there would be some belt tightening as revenues decline.
We just don't the Minster of Health, Finance and the PM telling us how awful it is and how we must stay in our homes. We need hope, we need to see you sharing in our pain. How about taking a 30% pay cut at the top (Minister level) going down to 10% at the Manager level. Leave the salaries of those at the bottom alone.
observer2 says...
The rating agencies have downgraded all the cruise lines as junk.
Anyone who thinks that ships filled with 5,000 ppl and zero social distancing will be back in business on October 1 is wishful thinking.
So what happens to the $150 million in bonds? Bay Street shut down and laying off. So we will build another Baystreet along the shore?
I never heard so much nonsense in my life.
Almost as bad as the $650 million BEC bond to be paid by consumers who are not paying electricity bills.
Don't forget the hotel freeport being bought by a cruise ship which is going bankrupt.
Meanwhile, the government has no economic plan....except lock down.
On Cruise port stands firm over forecast despite new delay
Posted 22 July 2020, 7:06 p.m. Suggest removal
observer2 says...
Excellent point!
I've been paying $400 a year for almost 4 decades for third party.
If we cancel this insurance the savings on over 100,000 cars would be $40 million a year.
....but maybe ppl are already saving because of the 19% drop in insurance coverage!
On 'Between rock and hard place' over 16% slump
Posted 22 July 2020, 7:02 p.m. Suggest removal
observer2 says...
I am comparing the actions of the Bahamian government to those of Cayman (Compass Compass) and the Turks and Caicos (Turks and Caicos Weekly) both newspapers can be received online. Cayman and TCI are colonies of the UK and therefore their governments are run much more efficiently and correctly.
We are all doing the same thing except for the Bahamian governments propensity to questionably and probably unconstitutionally fiddle with private agreements at worse and at best to rule in a dictatorial and none consultative manner.
With the BEC Rate Bond, which thankfully failed, the government was attempting to force BEC customers to assume $650 million of BEC debt. This is legally impossible under contract law because BEC clients signed up to purchase electricity from BEC and not to assume their debt for zero consideration. Did these guys take Intro to Law 101 in College?
The issue with the insurance companies is far more interesting because I believe they can do it under the Emergency Powers Act. In fact they can do almost anything under the act which is why Cayman probably didn't use it to enforce their "soft" and "hard" curfews. TCI used the Emergency Powers Act.
My fear is what private property is next for the government to "take over" under the Act with zero consultation with steak holders?
On Insurers’ anger at premiums ‘holiday’
Posted 1 April 2020, 2:16 p.m. Suggest removal
observer2 says...
Simple tax collection procedures such as mandated direct payment to the government on the same day that the employees are paid would immediately resolve this issue. In the US special payroll companies such as ADP are used as intermediaries and credit the payment to the employees bank account at the same time the government is paid social security and other tax payments.
There is zero penalty for not immediately paying the government except for customs duties (you don't get your merchandise) and VAT (interest penalties for late payments).
We can therefore expect, because there are zero penalties, that during this CoVID 19 lock down virtually no one to pay BEC, Water and Sewerage, Real Property Tax, BTC, VAT, mortgage payments and will push back out of rent payments. There are ppl in the country that can pay these bills but there is zero incentive to pay anything.
On Fusion NIB problems add to staff worries
Posted 31 March 2020, 1 p.m. Suggest removal
observer2 says...
Having a credit bureau and “FICO” score for each Bahamian adult would go along to encourage Bahamians to pay their BEC bill.
With such credit monitoring systems if you don’t pay your BEC bill your score goes down so when you go to the bank for credit they will view you as a higher risk which would restrict your ability to trade.
BEC asks for a deposit which is inadequate because by the time they turn off your lights the deposit has long been exhaustived.
In developed countries deposits must be returned to customers after one year.
On BPL cash crisis as payments collapse
Posted 30 March 2020, 8:38 p.m. Suggest removal
observer2 says...
Download the VesselFinder App on your iPhone and check out the number of green dots (cruise ships) idling around our northern islands.
I assume they are crewed but have nowhere to go or land. Without the ability to land or get supplies the environment on all of these ships could be less than ideal.
Many of these ships are registered under the Bahamian flag. Bahamas happy for the registration fees but don’t know them when they are in trouble or dumping garbage in our oceans.
On 14 infected crew aboard RCCL vessel off Coco Cay
Posted 30 March 2020, 8:26 p.m. Suggest removal
observer2 says...
A good example of visionless and poor leadership.
BPL has an accounts receivable problem but (1) the government won’t tell us exactly how much (2) they have not decided what they will do about the problem (3) we delayed the international rate bond issuance so much that it can’t be done anymore (4) even ppl that can pay their bills are not because there is a “do not disconnect list” for the politician (5) we have done zero solar which is virtually free to protect the lucrative import of global warming fossil fuels for the big shots (6) oil has dropped from $70 to $20 but we have no money to buy future supplies (7) we have done zero grid upgrades and hurricane season starts in 2 months.
On BPL cash crisis as payments collapse
Posted 30 March 2020, 8:35 a.m. Suggest removal
observer2 says...
Well mudda, great idea on the wealth tax, believe me its coming faster than you think. You can't threaten to lock down a country through April 30, tens of thousands of ppl have lost their jobs, government is supposed to be "working from home" but no one is answering their phones and the e mail server is overloaded and all e mails are being rejected. Something some where and sometime will have to give.
I made the following comments on the Lyford Cay job losses:
As tens of thousands of workers in the private sector are losing their jobs it is ironic that not a single government employee has either taken a pay cut, lost their job or are working at reduced hours.
I say its ironic because the government derives it revenue to meet its payroll by taxing Bahamian citizens and tourist. In any other business there would be some belt tightening as revenues decline.
We just don't the Minster of Health, Finance and the PM telling us how awful it is and how we must stay in our homes. We need hope, we need to see you sharing in our pain. How about taking a 30% pay cut at the top (Minister level) going down to 10% at the Manager level. Leave the salaries of those at the bottom alone.
....I must be dreaming.
On Bahamas left facing 'God awful situation'
Posted 27 March 2020, 6:06 p.m. Suggest removal
observer2 says...
Tetelestai. It would be constructive if you didn't denigrate my comment as "stupid". You do have a point that laying off government working is not helpful because it will further cause the economy to decline.
However, I had two other recommendations for government to impliment an austerity program of 30% pay cut for Ministers, 20% for Managers and reduced time for worker. Example if the airport is closed, which it is, then there is reduce work for Customs Officers and Managers. Why not, in sympathy with the tens of thousand of Bahamians that lost their jobs that they take a 10% reduction in working hours and pay.
On the high end the Minister of Tourism is a multi millionaire who I am sure would not feel a 30% reduction in his salary.
However, if the government implemented an austerity program like this they would be able to say truthfully "we are all in this together".
Ppl are just becoming more and more fearful.
70% of government expenditure is payroll. If you want some material savings to offset a portion of $1 billion of revenue short fall from a $2 billion budget there is no where else that it can come from. Except foreign reserves and if we deplete $1 billion of foreign reserves we will put a strain on the 1:1 B$:US$ peg which was anecdotally trading at 70 cents before this economic collapse.
On LYFORD CAY CLUB SHUTS: 150 JOBLESS
Posted 27 March 2020, 5:55 p.m. Suggest removal
observer2 says...
As tens of thousands of workers in the private sector are losing their jobs it is ironic that not a single government employee has either taken a pay cut, lost their job or are working at reduced hours.
I say its ironic because the government derives it revenue to meet its payroll by taxing Bahamian citizens and tourist. In any other business there would be some belt tightening as revenues decline.
We just don't the Minster of Health, Finance and the PM telling us how awful it is and how we must stay in our homes. We need hope, we need to see you sharing in our pain. How about taking a 30% pay cut at the top (Minister level) going down to 10% at the Manager level. Leave the salaries of those at the bottom alone.
....I must be dreaming.
On LYFORD CAY CLUB SHUTS: 150 JOBLESS
Posted 27 March 2020, 12:31 p.m. Suggest removal