Okay. You still have said exactly what I said, which is that outside of court proceedings, CVR transcripts in Canada are not published for public consumption. An article of Law in Canada prevents such release outside of court proceedings. Whether The Bahamas has similar restrictions, who knows. The provision of information in this country is always problematic so I don't see this matter being any different, though such matters ought to be different.
You just repeated exactly what I said. You often comment without reading it seems. I said the CVR transcripts in Canada are not released, but the recordings from Air Traffic Control can be. The CVR and Air Traffic Control recordings are not one and the same.
Some countries, like Canada as just one example, do not permit such transcripts to be made public outside of court orders pursuant to legal actions being taken. The prohibitions in Canada on the recordings from Air Traffic Control on the other hand, are less restrictive. I don't know if we have such prohibitions here but if the media were doing its job in this regard, it would know that and should be able to tell the public the same.
The media never did any investigations with respect to this incident and they still are not doing any. They were too wrapped up in the personalities on the plane as opposed to handling a crash investigation story the way it ought to be handled.
Where is the full uncensored report. That is what we need to see; along with CVR transcripts and FDR information. We don't need a summary of the report's findings, that tells us nothing in detail.
Indeed. The detailed report itself ought to be released too though, not just quotes from it or from persons at CAD. The public should also be able to get access to the transcripts from the CVR as well. I know not all countries allow it, and I know it's a pipe dream to expect ours to make it available to us.
Publius says...
The only thing I can do at this point is curse and threaten persons, so I'm out.
On New tax to pay for NHI scheme
Posted 24 February 2015, 12:39 p.m. Suggest removal
Publius says...
Okay. You still have said exactly what I said, which is that outside of court proceedings, CVR transcripts in Canada are not published for public consumption. An article of Law in Canada prevents such release outside of court proceedings. Whether The Bahamas has similar restrictions, who knows. The provision of information in this country is always problematic so I don't see this matter being any different, though such matters ought to be different.
On Pilots blamed for Munroe crash
Posted 24 February 2015, 12:44 a.m. Suggest removal
Publius says...
You just repeated exactly what I said. You often comment without reading it seems. I said the CVR transcripts in Canada are not released, but the recordings from Air Traffic Control can be. The CVR and Air Traffic Control recordings are not one and the same.
On Pilots blamed for Munroe crash
Posted 23 February 2015, 5:38 p.m. Suggest removal
Publius says...
Some countries, like Canada as just one example, do not permit such transcripts to be made public outside of court orders pursuant to legal actions being taken. The prohibitions in Canada on the recordings from Air Traffic Control on the other hand, are less restrictive. I don't know if we have such prohibitions here but if the media were doing its job in this regard, it would know that and should be able to tell the public the same.
On Pilots blamed for Munroe crash
Posted 23 February 2015, 2:51 p.m. Suggest removal
Publius says...
The media never did any investigations with respect to this incident and they still are not doing any. They were too wrapped up in the personalities on the plane as opposed to handling a crash investigation story the way it ought to be handled.
On Poor decisions by crew caused Myles Munroe plane crash, report says
Posted 23 February 2015, 12:41 p.m. Suggest removal
Publius says...
Where is the full uncensored report. That is what we need to see; along with CVR transcripts and FDR information. We don't need a summary of the report's findings, that tells us nothing in detail.
On Pilots blamed for Munroe crash
Posted 23 February 2015, 12:36 p.m. Suggest removal
Publius says...
Such dialog, if it exists, may be picked up on the CVR, which is one of the reasons I said we should be able to have access to those transcripts.
On Poor decisions by crew caused Myles Munroe plane crash, report says
Posted 23 February 2015, 12:04 p.m. Suggest removal
Publius says...
Indeed. The detailed report itself ought to be released too though, not just quotes from it or from persons at CAD. The public should also be able to get access to the transcripts from the CVR as well. I know not all countries allow it, and I know it's a pipe dream to expect ours to make it available to us.
On Poor decisions by crew caused Myles Munroe plane crash, report says
Posted 23 February 2015, 11:23 a.m. Suggest removal
Publius says...
This is such a stupid poll question.
On Do you think a Haitian-Bahamian party would improve the country's political landscape?
Posted 20 February 2015, 4:40 p.m. Suggest removal
Publius says...
Not to worry, he wont actually be doing anything.
On PM to meet BTC CEO
Posted 20 February 2015, 4:39 p.m. Suggest removal